Sig profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

Checked all ten axes in the memory profile, including each unit's scope, positive findings, evidence basis and coverage assessment. The profile preserves a documentary memory boundary rather than classifying all runtime storage. Its positive findings remain claimed; none is upgraded to wiring, operation or benefit. The supplied reconciliation resolves the duplicate factual and personal objects to the memory declarations. The organizational proposal remains distinct from approved team knowledge. No correction answers or predecessor objections were supplied.

  • Storage substrate: The files finding is supported for the two private note parts by MEM-OBJ-factual-record and MEM-OBJ-personal-layer. Grouping them preserves their common substrate and documentary coverage. Git transport does not settle operative storage for MEM-OBJ-team-knowledge or RT-OBJ-skills. Their unresolved units and the opaque retention alternatives justify partial axis coverage, not a complete files or repo classification.
  • Representational form: Natural-language findings apply to described content at human and intended AI interpretation paths, not to undisclosed metadata or provider state. The private parts, organizational proposal and published content have support in MEM-OBJ-factual-record, MEM-OBJ-personal-layer, EPI-OBJ-org-version and MEM-OBJ-team-knowledge. The conditional capture finding preserves unknown independent retention in EPI-OBJ-capture. Opaque workflow bodies and provider context remain unresolved rather than inheriting the form of their labels or of the external model.
  • Lineage: Authored input, other-compiled private/proposed output and recipient import are supported as separate derivation paths by EPI-OBJ-capture, EPI-RTE-private-synthesis, EPI-RTE-org-draft, MEM-OBJ-team-knowledge and RT-RTE-skill-sync. Compilation does not imply semantic fidelity. Partial units retain initial provenance and retention gaps; recipient import does not imply unchanged proposal-to-publication content.
  • Behavioral authority: Claimed knowledge force at later AI consumers is supported by EPI-RTE-context-use, with selected payload and personal-layer inclusion left unresolved. Direct human reading is a separate supported reference consumer in MEM-OBJ-factual-record. The profile does not infer instruction authority from the skill label or retained enforcement/validation objects from the publication policy. Those distinctions preserve actual part, consumer and effect boundaries.
  • Write agency: Manual team publication follows the explicit per-content review and send decision in EPI-RTE-share-approval. Private admission remains unresolved in EPI-RTE-private-synthesis; authoring structured text and physically writing it do not independently resolve the missing approval policy. RT-RTE-skill-sync likewise does not disclose enough admission control to classify every skill write. The known publication unit does not upgrade these alternatives.
  • Curation operations: No controlled operation is established by the accepted records. EPI-RTE-private-synthesis and EPI-RTE-org-draft leave transformation semantics and retained inputs unresolved. The product's synthesis label alone does not establish either controlled synthesize or consolidate. EPI-RTE-local-deletion establishes documentary local removal but not the history-preserving withdrawal required for invalidate or a classified automatic maintenance process. Not-determinable preserves these gaps without asserting absence.
  • Read-back direction: The explicit human file-opening route in MEM-OBJ-factual-record supports claimed pull. It is kept separate from later AI-context delivery in EPI-RTE-context-use and workflow distribution in RT-RTE-skill-sync. Immediate synchronized availability does not resolve whether a later model receives requested retrieval or unsolicited context. Partial direction coverage is supported.
  • Read-back signal: Local requested file access has no push selector and is locally inapplicable. The remaining units preserve unknown triggers, selector inputs and selected retained parts in EPI-RTE-context-use, RT-RTE-skill-sync and RT-RTE-provider-message. No identifier or coarse push finding can be inferred from synchronization or availability alone; the whole axis correctly remains not-determinable rather than inapplicable.
  • Trace learning: EPI-RTE-private-synthesis, EPI-RTE-context-use and EPI-OBJ-capture establish intended derived retained context but do not resolve automatic admission and original qualifying trace content. The profile requires neither novelty nor demonstrated improvement; its uncertainty rests on the missing qualifying write chain. Manual publication does not establish a negative for precursor writes. Opaque skill, conversation and provider alternatives remain included, so neither yes nor bounded no is warranted.
  • Trace source: A retrospective meeting account alone does not establish session logs, timestamped runtime events, tool traces or linked trajectories. EPI-OBJ-capture, RT-RTE-skill-sync and RT-RTE-provider-message leave qualifying source content unresolved. Not-determinable does not falsely make source inapplicable merely because no positive trace-learning finding can yet be emitted.

The coarser unresolved units group alternatives that share an inconclusive classification, with no positive finding or complete-coverage assertion masking their differences. Their notes identify missing retention, representation, admission or consumer facts. The exclusions for diagnostics, install linkage and public support intake are explicit and supported by MEM-OBJ-install-id, RT-RTE-analytics-egress and RT-RTE-product-feedback: diagnostic use is not denied, but no durable app behavior-shaping update route is established. Provider model form in RT-CMP-ai-provider is not evidence that its weights belong to accumulated Sig memory.

No unsupported emitted comparison value, evidence upgrade, bounded negative or complete-inventory assertion was found. The unresolved application loop already travels with the extracted axis and unit assessments. It is faithful scoped uncertainty, not an additional verification limit. No source reads were needed; this judgment uses only the supplied members and contracts.

Blockers

none

Limits

none