SoL-Pi profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes, their findings and evidence bases, unit boundaries, unresolved branches and inventory assessments against the handed records and annotations. I also checked the comparison rationale. No additional source read was needed. The handed profile answers are empty; there is no supplied refusal whose objections establish a defect.

The scope follows accumulated archives, replacement context, retained control state and shipped handoff/cache consumers. It does not treat static prompts, arbitrary workspace mutations or external weights of unknown mutability as memory changed through use. Reconciliation's observation, transcript and crop supersessions preserve their qualifications; the profile uses their canonical memory objects. Receipt quotation and label parts remain distinct from the valid receipt container. No unresolved report conflict requires choosing between contrary findings.

  • Storage substrate: File findings are supported by concrete archives and example run/cache artifacts; process-memory findings concern replay counts and transient OCC state. External session persistence remains unresolved rather than being inferred from JSON encoding or the Skill file route (MEM-OBJ-observation, MEM-OBJ-run-result, RT-OBJ-online-state).
  • Representational form: Language and fixed-rule metadata are separated. The described native summary supports natural-language form without establishing fidelity. Crop pixels are not classified from their receipt display or mistaken for learned parameters; their controlled form remains unresolved (MEM-OBJ-magnify-artifact, RT-RTE-online-compaction).
  • Lineage: Imported raw text, model-authored plan content, trace-extracted receipts/estimates/exports and compiled crops have supported derivation paths. Those positives do not settle original tool assertions, host-summary provenance or source-image initialization (MEM-OBJ-archive-object, MEM-OBJ-progress-summary, MEM-OBJ-context-export).
  • Behavioral authority: The grouped findings name their consumed parts and consumers. Advisory downstream context is separated from experience consumed by artifact updates, code-consumed routing state and integrity criteria with enforced rejection. Learning authority here does not assert improved competence. Progress persistence and the pack ledger are not promoted to an unsupported model-guidance path (MEM-OBJ-validated-receipt, RT-OBJ-online-state, MEM-OBJ-magnify-artifact).
  • Write agency: Ongoing software/model admission supports automatic findings. Workflow initiation and manual compaction initiation do not establish per-content human approval. Initial host/image admission remains unresolved (RT-RTE-online-compaction, RT-RTE-skill-handoff, MEM-OBJ-magnify-artifact).
  • Curation operations: Quote/excerpt reduction and transcript/result selection support consolidation; OCC revisions and historical-state resets support evolution and invalidation. Native consolidation retains an afforded basis. Collision checks do not become deduplication, and indeterminate label semantics do not become synthesis (MEM-OBJ-observation, MEM-OBJ-run-result, RT-OBJ-online-state, EPI-OBJ-receipt-labels).
  • Read-back direction: Requested pages, CLI results and crop reuse are pulls; independent projection, restore and correlated notification are pushes. The archive shell read remains afforded rather than observed. Requested delivery is not counted again as an unsolicited push (RT-RTE-observation-replay, RT-RTE-reducer-receipt, RT-RTE-skill-handoff).
  • Read-back signal: Coarse eligibility/budget selection is distinguished from reducer judgment and actual custom-type/run-id targeting. Identifiers on requested reads do not establish identifier-based push. Native summary-content selection stays partial (RT-OBJ-online-state, MEM-OBJ-run-result, RT-RTE-reducer-receipt).
  • Trace learning: Receipt, retained estimate, native summary and persisted handoff transformations have automatic trace-fed writes and later consumers. Wired classification requires neither observed improvement nor a novel proposition. Raw archives, transient pack projection and progress without independent prompt readback do not acquire an extra positive or an unsupported negative (RT-RTE-online-compaction, MEM-OBJ-context-export, MEM-OBJ-progress-summary).
  • Trace source: Findings follow diagnostic output, conversational turns, execution feedback and discrete runtime/process observations, not JSONL serialization. Native selected history and imported host-summary origins remain partial; unresolved crop origins do not establish a trace source (MEM-OBJ-archive-object, RT-OBJ-online-state, MEM-OBJ-context-export, MEM-OBJ-run-result).

The homogeneous groups retain named constituent parts and routes; grouping does not transfer a stronger basis to an opaque alternative. Every axis remains partial, with supported positives and explicit unresolved included branches. These assessments support existence comparisons, not complete-value statistics or claims of observed activation, faithful summarization, successful host delivery or causal benefit. The stated uncertainties are faithfully scoped, not publication defects.

Blockers

none

Limits

none