Harness² memory profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I checked all ten axes of the memory profile, including findings, evidence bases, unit scopes and inventory assessments, against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow members. Reconciliation makes no supersessions and identifies no unresolved conflict. Its distinctions between the experience document, reflected payload and navigation artifact, and between the evidence container and its consumer projections, are preserved. The empty profile-answers input supplies no repair argument to adjudicate.
The profile's scope covers accumulated or changed material reaching later invocations, not all runtime storage. It correctly includes within-task reconstructed history as well as cross-task library entries and recovery state. Unchanged baseline instructions are excluded until retained as exemplars. External compaction and delegated/provider memory remain unresolved alternatives, not established absence. These boundaries agree with MEM-RTE-evidence-frame, MEM-OBJ-experience and MEM-CLM-compaction-boundary.
| Axis | Independent disposition |
|---|---|
| Storage substrate | Supported. Files are the recorded substrate of the named harness, explanation, evidence and cache objects. JSON/Markdown encodings do not create additional substrates. The unresolved external-payload unit prevents complete system coverage; provider-hosted model components alone do not establish retained model-weights memory. See RT-OBJ-harness-text, MEM-OBJ-evidence-tree, MEM-OBJ-cached-response and EPI-RTE-score-cache. |
| Representational form | Supported. The units distinguish model-interpreted prose from executable code and fixed-rule metadata at their respective consumers. Copied raw assets and external checkpoints are not classified from their display summaries. See RT-OBJ-harness-code, RT-BAP-harness-consumption, MEM-OBJ-library-index and MEM-OBJ-evidence-tree. |
| Lineage | Supported as derivation-path findings, not authenticated ultimate provenance. Authored edits, trace-derived reflection, deterministic projections and imported inputs remain distinguishable; fallback need not create newly authored content. Scripted demo authorship is separately scoped. See RT-RTE-edit-admission, MEM-OBJ-experience, MEM-OBJ-call-fingerprint, EPI-RTE-judge-result and MEM-CLM-demo-experience. |
| Behavioral authority | Supported at the named consumers. Reference/advice and durable-artifact updates are distinct from installed solver instructions. Stored identity fields supply reuse routing, conformance criteria and vetoes; retained trial grade availability supplies ranking, not higher-score preference. Saved scores supply report data. The profile leaves arbitrary generated executable effects unresolved rather than assigning universal enforcement. See RT-RTE-experience-admission, RT-BAP-harness-consumption, RT-RTE-resume-reuse, RT-RTE-solver-execution and EPI-RTE-score-report. |
| Write agency | Supported. The grouped framework mechanisms share software/model admission without per-content human approval. Workflow initiation and human authorship of fixed demo text do not make subsequent admission manual. Direct API caller control and native checkpoint control remain unresolved. See RT-RTE-edit-admission, RT-RTE-experience-admission, MEM-RTE-library-withdrawal and EPI-RTE-score-cache. |
| Curation operations | Supported. Recorded clipping reduces retained history, harness revisions evolve existing artifacts, and entry deletion forgets material from future library supply. Reindexing is not independently treated as curation. Lesson semantics remain indeterminate: requested transfer reasoning and parser loss establish neither consolidation nor synthesis of an actual lesson. See MEM-RTE-evidence-frame, RT-RTE-edit-admission, MEM-RTE-library-withdrawal and EPI-RTE-lesson-parse. |
| Read-back direction | Supported. Stage-triggered supply and subsequent requested browsing/cache retrieval are separate operations in a chain. Delivery of requested material is not counted again as push. Native alternatives prevent a complete direction inventory. See MEM-RTE-evidence-frame, MEM-OBJ-library-index, MEM-OBJ-cached-response and RT-RTE-resume-reuse. |
| Read-back signal | Supported. The inspected push uses stage entry, domain/mode/prefix membership and supplied history, copying eligible material without a targeted relevance selector. Requested file identity and exact cache keys do not establish identifier-based push. Pull-unit inapplicability is local; unresolved native selection remains included. See MEM-RTE-evidence-frame, MEM-OBJ-library-index, MEM-OBJ-call-fingerprint and MEM-CLM-compaction-boundary. |
| Trace learning | Supported. Automatic execution/history-fed writes produce retained harness changes or experience with later consumers. That chain supports a wired yes without weight changes, epistemic acceptance or measured improvement. Scripted demo and opaque native alternatives are not turned into negative findings; no absence record supports a local or system-wide no. See RT-RTE-task-recursion, RT-RTE-experience-admission, MEM-RTE-evidence-frame and MEM-CLM-demo-experience. |
| Trace source | Supported for the named qualifying update inputs: conversational records, tool activity and linked rollout experience. Mixed task/source assets remain unresolved, and event serialization does not establish event-stream origin. The profile does not assign the ordinary route's sources to scripted or opaque alternatives. See MEM-OBJ-evidence-tree, MEM-RTE-evidence-frame, RT-RTE-experience-admission and EPI-OBJ-execution-evidence. |
All positive findings retain implementation-level bases. None is upgraded to observed operation or causal support. The learning-authority and trace-learning findings do not imply improved capacity, valid criticism, accepted lesson truth or exercised self-improvement. The intervening adaptation/admission step before solver authority is retained, consistent with the workflow retention account.
Each axis has supported controlled findings and explicitly unresolved included coverage, supporting partial rather than known, absent or inapplicable axis assessments. Grouped units retain their named parts and consumer distinctions sufficiently for the emitted findings; they do not assert exhaustive external-store or mechanism counts. The unresolved native routes, actual model use and unavailable generated lesson content are faithfully scoped uncertainties, not additional verification defects. No unsupported emitted value, evidence-strength upgrade or material coverage assertion was found.
Source-read log: none. The accepted records were sufficient; no source ambiguity required additional inspection.
Blockers
none
Limits
none