Evidence boundary
The workshop originates in analysis run
AAS-2026-08-27-commonplace-review-freshness-01. The run froze revision
c5afbf1c5efff02d47d71c4bf05779fa5170ab4a and inspected the review/freshness
subsystem from selection through result read-back. At workshop creation, the
registered subsystem files remained byte-equivalent at checkout revision
64e84517712ffa61682bd3f63ba859223f9330cc.
Inspected material
- implementation under
src/commonplace/review/,src/commonplace/freshness/, the review/freshness CLIs,src/commonplace/store.py, andsrc/commonplace/store-schema.sql; - review architecture, freshness architecture, the review-system guide, the batch procedure, the review-gate contract, and the grounding and fix contracts; and
- registered review, freshness, worker-contract, and store-health tests.
Observed checks
The complete test suite passed: 580 passed in 30.01s. Disposable-repository
interventions also established that:
- finalizing
FAILcreates a fresh baseline, removes the pair from stale selection, and does not place it in the warning queue; - changing only linked evidence leaves a completed pair fresh;
- changing only derived result prose changes warning read-back while the SQLite outcome stays unchanged;
- an invalid declared snapshot hash and canonical source do not prevent
model-shaped
PASSoutput from finalizing and becoming fresh; - failure in a later creation group leaves earlier queued state and the failing job in SQLite without returning their normal JSON handles; and
extract_warns()returns an explicit- warn:item from PASS-shaped input.
These interventions establish deterministic subsystem behavior. They do not establish what a properly instructed external reviewer would read, infer, or return.
Excluded evidence
No real provider trace, parent-harness dispatch trace, production review store, operator disposition history, or gate-calibration corpus was inspected. The workshop therefore treats activation frequency, reviewer accuracy, production incidence, and model-equivalence quality as unresolved.