sift-kg profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the memory profile against the handed records, including their annotations and reconciliation dispositions. The superseded extraction and support identities resolve to MEM-OBJ-document-extraction and MEM-OBJ-relation-support. The valid domain/graph containers and their separately declared parts remain usable. No new source reads or quotations were needed.

Storage and form. Filesystem artifacts, the operative NetworkX graph and process-resident parsed material support the emitted files, graph and in-memory findings. Text interpretation is separated from fixed-rule IDs, endpoints, scores and control fields. The profile does not infer vector storage from temporary embeddings or accumulated parametric memory from the external model component (RT-OBJ-graph-data, RT-CMP-sentence-transformer, RT-CMP-llm-client). Opaque provider accumulation remains unresolved rather than falsely classified.

Lineage and admission. Document/model derivation and deterministic compilation support other-compiled paths; human review supports authored decisions. Initial caller provenance remains unresolved. Automatic admission is not upgraded to manual merely because a human starts a command. Human review keys and file edits remain separate mechanisms from confidence decisions and automatic application (RT-RTE-document-extraction, RT-RTE-schema-discovery, RT-RTE-review-decisions, RT-RTE-apply-decisions).

Authority. The findings distinguish reference content, interpreted standing guidance, fixed-rule conformity criteria, enforced mutations, ranking inputs and operation-selection metadata. Review reasons do not acquire the status fields' execution force. Conditional schema enforcement is not represented as universal validation. Narrative file reading remains afforded rather than inheriting the wired description consumers' basis (RT-BAP-domain-guidance, EPI-OBJ-domain-vocabulary, RT-OBJ-review-files, RT-RTE-agent-retrieval, MEM-OBJ-narrative). One local authority omission is retained below.

Curation. Aggregation and merges support consolidation, deduplication and revision; cleanup and rejection support local forgetting. Deletion is not mislabeled as history-preserving invalidation. Generation and phrase repair do not establish synthesis merely by requesting new prose. The unresolved semantic transformations remain separate from supported mechanical operations (MEM-OBJ-relation-support, RT-RTE-apply-decisions, EPI-RTE-graph-cleanup, RT-RTE-narrative-generation).

Direction and selection. Requested CLI/stage reads support pull. Automatic domain and summary supply to later chunk model invocations supports the separate push finding. The recorded availability/configuration selector supports coarse selection; requested IDs, lexical matching and temporary clustering do not establish identifier or embedding push. The profile preserves the distinction between requested return and automatic internal context supply (RT-RTE-agent-retrieval, RT-BAP-domain-guidance, RT-RTE-document-extraction).

Trace learning and source. The accepted records establish document-derived writes and output-fed correction, but neither a qualifying recorded activity-to-durable-update chain nor a canonical bounded absence. Thus the two not-determinable axes assert neither a false negative nor an unsupported positive. Unknown provider/API alternatives are not made inapplicable by the classified local routes (MEM-OBJ-document-extraction, RT-RTE-narrative-generation, RT-CMP-llm-client).

The grouped units retain identifiable objects, transformations and consumer effects in their scopes, findings and notes. Their granularity does not create an unsupported emitted value. Partial axes retain unresolved alternatives, and no finding is upgraded to observed operation or causal benefit. No material defect requires correction before publication.

Blockers

none

Limits

• The profile's partial behavioral_authority inventory does not separately classify the first-chunk summary at its later chunk-call consumer, although that summary is included in the profile's scope and other axes. The memory annotation on RT-RTE-document-extraction establishes model-produced summary context supplied to later chunk invocations. The profile classifies its storage, form and automatic delivery but omits that consumer from its authority units. Complete consumer-level authority comparisons should therefore be withheld. This local omission does not invalidate the emitted knowledge value, which has independent graph/excerpt witnesses, or turn the already partial authority inventory into a complete one.