sift-kg profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

Checked all ten axes in the profile, including their units, positive findings, evidence bases and inventory assessments, against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow accounts. Applied reconciliation's discovered-domain supersession. The profile uses the separate info record rather than extending the runtime retrieval record to cover the disputed info attribution. No classification depends on that unresolved attribution. Source-read log: none; the handed records suffice for this judgment.

• Storage substrate and representational form: files, the operative loaded graph and SQLite export are supported within the named retained-artifact boundary. Text parts are distinguished from typed structures and numerical metadata. External weights, transient vectors and the unretained first-chunk summary are explicitly excluded rather than declared absent. Whole-narrative reading retains its afforded basis instead of inheriting wired semantic consumption from description sidecars. See MEM-OBJ-document-extraction, MEM-OBJ-discovered-domain, MEM-OBJ-graph-data, MEM-OBJ-relation-support, MEM-OBJ-narrative and RT-RTE-view-export.
• Lineage: imported documentary assertions, model-authored interpretations and definitions, fixed-code compilation and explicit human alternatives have supported derivation paths. These classifications concern origin and production, not source truth, semantic fidelity or novelty. Their known assessment does not purport to resolve the documents' upstream authorship or excluded embedding provenance. See RT-RTE-document-extraction, RT-RTE-schema-discovery, RT-RTE-graph-build, RT-RTE-entity-resolution, RT-RTE-review-application and RT-RTE-narrative-generation.
• Behavioral authority: the findings identify retained parts and actual effects: assertions and reasons provide knowledge; discovered definitions supply instructions and code-consumed constraints; cache metadata routes subsequent work; stored topology and names affect priority; review statuses validate eligibility and enforce mutation or exclusion. Fixed ranking code need not itself be retained or learned. Status control is not factual acceptance, and reason display is not surgery enforcement. The narrative's external reader remains afforded. See RT-BAP-domain-guidance, MEM-OBJ-merge-proposals, MEM-OBJ-relation-review, MEM-OBJ-communities, RT-RTE-graph-retrieval and RT-RTE-review-application.
• Write agency: software/model admission supports automatic findings independently of workflow initiation or physical file I/O. Interactive human decisions support wired manual admission; human schema replacement is separately afforded. Generic direct file writers remain not-determinable, so the partial axis does not imply authenticated human control of every editable YAML path. See RT-RTE-document-extraction, RT-RTE-schema-discovery and RT-RTE-review-application.
• Curation operations: retained graph aggregation, duplicate removal, existing-entry revision and rejected-edge withdrawal support consolidate, dedup, evolve and invalidate within their specified scopes. Retained rejection decisions bound the withdrawal finding; it does not imply reversible graph history or sidecar retraction. The conditional origin-to-destination normalization supports synthesize through the recorded non-entailment argument, not through a command name or observed incident. See MEM-OBJ-graph-data, MEM-OBJ-relation-support, MEM-OBJ-relation-review and EPI-RTE-relation-normalization. General model transformations retain unresolved semantics and therefore leave the axis partial.
• Read-back direction: requested query/search/topology/info and presentation delivery support pull; small-graph and narrative reading retain afforded alternatives. Automatic supply of retained definitions, extractions, graph subsets and decision controls to subsequent consumers supports internal push separately from the upstream stage request. Neither finding asserts an enclosing host-session scheduler. See RT-RTE-graph-retrieval, MEM-RTE-project-info, RT-BAP-agent-skill, RT-RTE-graph-build, RT-RTE-entity-resolution and RT-RTE-narrative-generation.
• Read-back signal: stage availability, structural filters and caps support coarse selection. Narration's normalized-name context join and application's ID/triple matches support identifier selection of retained parts, unlike a requested filename alone. Optional embedding clustering supports its own wired selection finding without upgrading the dependency-internal SemHash alternative. The latter remains unresolved in a partial axis. See MEM-OBJ-document-extraction, RT-RTE-narrative-generation, RT-RTE-review-application, RT-RTE-entity-resolution, RT-CMP-sentence-transformer and RT-CMP-sem-hash.
• Trace learning and trace source: neither axis asserts a positive or bounded negative. Document-fed writes and retained decision metadata do not by themselves establish an automatic trace-fed durable update chain. The accepted records do not exhaustively type possible imported content or provide a bounded absence warrant. Not-determinable preserves that gap; source is not incorrectly made inapplicable on the strength of an unestablished learning route. See MEM-OBJ-document-extraction, RT-RTE-document-extraction, RT-RTE-schema-discovery, RT-RTE-review-application and RT-RTE-narrative-generation.

Rechecked the predecessor's prose-evolution objection against the current profile and correction answer. The model-prose/style-rewrite unit now has no findings and explicitly identifies the missing retained-entry premise. Its note, axis note and rationale no longer treat replacement of current-generation prose before persistence as evolution of retained prose. This agrees with EPI-RTE-style-rewrite and RT-RTE-narrative-generation. The separately warranted graph-evolution findings remain intact. The previous blocker is resolved.

The grouped units are coarse but preserve the consequential differences in form, consumer effect, admission control, evidence basis and unresolved alternatives. No grouped uncertainty upgrades an opaque alternative. Known assessments concern the explicitly scoped retained inventory, not the whole runtime or observed performance. Partial and not-determinable assessments already express the remaining uncertainty; they require no additional publication limit. No observed activation, reliable semantic compliance or causal benefit is inferred from wiring.

Blockers

none

Limits

none