JAZ profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I checked all ten axes in the memory profile against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow members. I applied the supplied reconciliation: the memory rollout object and export route are canonical; the epistemic rollout declarations supply no independent second mechanism. No correction answers or refusal were supplied. No source files were read and no new evidence or records were added.
Storage, form and lineage. File and process-memory findings follow the retained objects, not their serialization labels. Serving parameters remain distinct from persisted model-selection settings. The profile separates interpreted transcripts, fixed-rule record/code/token parts and distributed parameters; it does not classify arbitrary live payloads from their repr displays. Capture lineage is separated from original payload provenance, helper-generated settings, offline conversion and imported replacement weights. These distinctions are supported by MEM-OBJ-conversation-history, MEM-OBJ-helper-history, MEM-OBJ-atif-trajectory, MEM-OBJ-trajectory-directory, MEM-OBJ-token-stamp, MEM-OBJ-rollout, MEM-RTE-weight-update and RT-CMP-llm. The parameter findings describe the exposed serving-policy interface, not observed replacement or known training provenance. Opaque and remote alternatives remain unresolved rather than excluded to obtain complete coverage.
Authority and write agency. Main/helper history supplies context, saved source supplies executable actions, recorded expectations supply comparison criteria, and replay state controls subsequent serving. The separate findings preserve those effects even where one unit groups the comparison and serving chain. Model selection routes later work; credentials authorize access. Training and generated-program consumers remain afforded rather than observed or automatically installed. See RT-RTE-console-turn, RT-RTE-trajectory-replay, EPI-RTE-replay-comparison, RT-BAP-settings-load, MEM-OBJ-credentials, MEM-RTE-rollout-export and RT-RTE-workflow-emission. Automatic capture is not confused with human authorship or recorder activation. Direct content supply and confirmed helper changes support manual admission; the external replacement-weight caller does not establish its human control. See RT-RTE-settings-admission and MEM-RTE-weight-update. The authority inventory has the local omission retained below, not an unsupported emitted value.
Curation. The retained readline cap supports forgetting; settings and credential replacement support revision; divergence withdraws saved-response reliance without deleting the trace. Their distinct effects are supported by MEM-OBJ-readline-history, MEM-OBJ-credentials, RT-BAP-settings-load and EPI-RTE-replay-comparison. The profile does not infer synthesis from artifact generation or classify current-invocation observation abbreviation as retained-memory curation. Its unresolved transformation inventory does not claim bounded absence of other operations.
Read-back direction and signal. Requested live-object inspection, line recall, trace loading and export access are distinguished from automatic later-history supply, replay response selection and startup configuration application. The trace-load request and subsequent per-query selection are different operations, not duplicate labels on a requested return. Nonemptiness, sequential availability/divergence and configuration availability support coarse push signals; a filename or requested credential key alone does not establish identifier-targeted push. See MEM-OBJ-conversation-history, MEM-OBJ-helper-history, MEM-OBJ-readline-history, RT-RTE-trajectory-replay, EPI-RTE-replay-comparison and RT-BAP-settings-load. Unresolved remote selection is preserved on both axes.
Trace learning and source. Event-derived workflow code is a durable behavior-shaping output with an intended later executor; token samples have a documented external update consumer. The afforded positive findings do not assert wired trainer closure, exercised learning, successful replay or benefit. See RT-RTE-workflow-emission and MEM-RTE-rollout-export. Workflow source findings follow recorded code-bearing session and execution content, not merely callback names. Rollout conversational provenance is supported while other conditioning content remains separately unresolved; see MEM-OBJ-token-stamp and MEM-OBJ-rollout. Neither the word trajectory nor hook delivery establishes an additional trace-origin value. The absence of a bounded absence record prevents local negative findings; the profile correctly emits none. Independent weight-update transport does not close the export-to-training chain.
All ten axis assessments remain partial. Their positive findings have local warrants and their unresolved included alternatives prevent complete-value comparisons. Missing runs and experiments limit operation and benefit, not the inspectable architectural findings. I found no unsupported system-level absence, complete-coverage assertion or evidence-strength upgrade requiring correction.
Blockers
none
Limits
- The partial behavioral-authority inventory in the memory profile does not separately classify the afforded human inspection consumer of diagnostic directory displays. MEM-OBJ-trajectory-directory explicitly retains that consumer, and the profile includes it under read-back direction but not authority. Human diagnostic-consumer comparisons therefore remain incomplete. The emitted authority findings and the partial inventory assessment remain supported; this omission neither establishes absence of that consumer nor changes the system's emitted authority-value union.