JAZ profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the memory profile against the handed accepted records: scope, natural units, positive findings, evidence bases and inventory coverage. I applied the supplied reconciliation's supersessions for the rollout object, rollout export and weight transport. No source reads were needed; this verification adds no records or quotations.

The profile's boundary is accumulated session content, execution derivatives and changed defaults, not all runtime state. It distinguishes opaque retained results from their capped displays and excludes ordinary invocation state, shipped templates, credentials and command recall. Every axis remains partial; unresolved payload internals, initialization and external update/consumer paths are not silently removed to claim complete coverage.

  • Storage substrate: MEM-OBJ-conversation-history, MEM-OBJ-helper-history, MEM-OBJ-atif-trace, MEM-OBJ-rollout, MEM-RTE-trace-display and MEM-OBJ-user-settings support the in-memory and file findings at their named containers. Opaque payload backing and external server/trainer retention remain unresolved rather than being classified from serialization or transport.
  • Representational form: the profile separates interpreted transcripts from bindings, tags, replay source, workflow programs and fixed-rule token/sample structures. MEM-RTE-session-history, RT-RTE-trajectory-replay, RT-RTE-workflow-emission and MEM-RTE-rollout-export support those consumption distinctions. RT-CMP-model-backend identifies external parametric form independently of unknown storage and parameter provenance. A displayed repr does not classify the original live payload.
  • Lineage: authored requests, captured results, execution-derived programs/displays and token samples retain distinct paths. The configuration projection has a recorded software producer, while initial settings authorship and weight provenance remain unresolved. MEM-RTE-session-history, MEM-RTE-trace-recording, RT-RTE-workflow-emission, MEM-RTE-rollout-export and EPI-RTE-model-ping support these local findings without authenticating arbitrary source content.
  • Behavioral authority: MEM-RTE-session-history supports history as later context. RT-RTE-trajectory-replay supports execution-directing retained code separately from routing, compatibility validation and saved-response veto. RT-RTE-workflow-emission supports experience at the durable program producer separately from the output's afforded executor. MEM-RTE-rollout-export supports afforded training input, not a wired optimizer. MEM-OBJ-user-settings supports configuration routing and permission effects. The profile preserves the distinction between helper action admission and completed execution established by the workflow annotation.
  • Write agency: automatic session append, serialization, program emission, sample collection and display conversion are supported at their software admission mechanisms, not inferred from authorship. Explicit file editing or approved settings-changing helper content supplies the separate manual path. MEM-RTE-session-history, MEM-RTE-trace-recording, RT-RTE-workflow-emission, MEM-RTE-rollout-export, MEM-RTE-trace-display and RT-RTE-settings-change support those distinctions. Generic caller-controlled persistence and external admission are appropriately unresolved.
  • Curation operations: MEM-OBJ-user-settings and EPI-RTE-model-ping support revision of retained defaults as evolve. Raw append, display projection, workflow materialization and token-mask construction do not establish semantic synthesis or consolidation merely by producing another representation. Their unresolved units assert no bounded absence.
  • Read-back direction: MEM-RTE-session-history supports automatic delivery separately from requested live-object inspection. RT-RTE-trajectory-replay supports caller-selected trace acquisition followed by automatic per-query response supply. RT-RTE-workflow-emission supports afforded requested standalone execution, while MEM-RTE-rollout-export and MEM-RTE-trace-display support requested exports/conversions. Startup defaults loading is automatic delivery, not a separate request for each value.
  • Read-back signal: coarse availability-based history and settings delivery is supported by MEM-RTE-session-history and MEM-OBJ-user-settings. Pull-only operations are locally inapplicable, without making unresolved alternatives inapplicable. Replay's shared-stack-top and cursor progression in RT-RTE-trajectory-replay does not establish an identity-match selector. The revised replay unit now has no positive signal finding and explicitly states not-determinable coverage.
  • Trace learning: RT-RTE-workflow-emission supports automatic durable program production with an afforded later executor. The profile's afforded yes does not require automatic installation into the next Agent, successful execution or improvement. Raw history/replay and external training paths remain unresolved, with no unsupported no. MEM-RTE-rollout-export and MEM-RTE-weight-transport do not establish the missing trainer-to-durable-parameter chain.
  • Trace source: the workflow route's conversational response text and REPL code/results support session-logs and tool-traces at the afforded qualifying route. RT-RTE-workflow-emission supports both without adding event-streams merely because hooks deliver event envelopes. Other update chains remain unresolved rather than having their visible raw inputs counted as established qualifying sources.

I rechecked the previous identifier-selector objection and the profile author's correction. The unsupported identifier finding is removed, the replay unit is not-determinable, and the axis note and rationale no longer claim positional identity matching. Wired replay push is preserved independently of signal uncertainty. This repairs the comparison defect; neither the previous objection nor its correction establishes replay absence. The remaining uncertainty is faithfully expressed in the extracted unit itself and needs no additional publication limit.

The weight-wrapper afforded/wired disagreement does not become a positive finding about server application or automatic training. The canonical weight-transport record remains unresolved at those external boundaries; the positive workflow route stands independently. No emitted finding claims observed use, causal benefit, a complete system inventory or an evidenced absence. The handed profile supports publication within its stated partial coverage.

Blockers

none

Limits

none