Sift-KG — incomplete current-publication audit

Decision and stop

Hold — incomplete independent audit. No semantic clearance is issued. Root depth: evidence stop (unfinished audit), not an inferred source, profile or authority defect. No analysis restart job is selected; independent review must resume before a supported content-depth diagnosis is possible. Substantive review stopped at the group session's context limit after five cases. This case received mechanical binding and deterministic validation only.

Assignment and identity

  • Run: AAS-2026-10-15-sift-kg-dca68bc45a2c-01.
  • Intake SHA-256: 29c5a94a2c926f9c8b895cf5a5f50b0157461fa2a8aff39779131d14ab6d530e.
  • Ownership: sorted needs fresh audit* publications, slice [0::4], index 7.
  • W: /home/zby/llm/commonplace/.commonplace/worktrees/sift-kg-dca68bc45a2c.
  • P: W/kb/agentic-system-analyses/retained/sift-kg.
  • Source: https://github.com/juanceresa/sift-kg.
  • Fresh source HEAD: d786991c024f5401f113fc0cb70aee96dd1bd3bf.
  • Fresh method HEAD: a568c6dc489ad546374536b642c3889ce23149a8.
  • Actual auditor: Pi, openai/gpt-6.1-sol, medium; independent group session 01a146d3-f5b3-75b6-9c30-c98fd129da65; no delegation.

Fresh mechanical evidence

Recursive map: 13 files, exact intake file set/bytes and exact completed own publish effect new map. Digest: da65f938e2cc3ddf5233ba48a80a408dbde0ef73dc71065b281e5246b819323b. Encoding is SHA-256 of UTF-8 sorted relative-path/hash JSON with compact separators (',', ':'); values hash exact file bytes, no newline added. Run-definition, preparation, publish-effect and publish-attempt hashes equal intake. Effect is completed and binds the exact run/source identity. All publication version blobs, role-specific publish pins and manifest pin match exact current bytes. Freshly parsed manifest member hashes match. Opening metadata hash/record equal intake and bind run/source/method. Producer manifest reports pi-sol, Pi, openai/gpt-6.1-sol, medium for all model roles. This is metadata, not proof of worker conduct.

Prepared W/.venv/bin/commonplace-validate P, cwd W: exit 0, VALIDATION SUCCESS, one set, zero failures and warnings. Deterministic success supplies no semantic or operational clearance.

Missing work and unblock

Assigned historical kb/agent-memory-systems/reviews/sift-kg.md has not been read for this audit. Current public boundary/overview/synthesis, verification/profile/records and frozen-source discrepancy checking remain substantively unaudited. No producing-worker operational trace was inspected. No target execution, tests, fetching, analysis edits or integration occurred. Earliest faulty version/job and missed verifier are unknown, not absent. Prior holds are not released by these mechanical checks. Unblock by completing the assigned source-specific independent audit and issuing a supported current-byte disposition; do not send this partial audit to analytical workers or treat it as a finding that an analysis reset is needed.