Batch 23 Autogenesis exact-publication audit

Disposition: hold — the frozen checkout has a missing local import on both ordinary task entry paths. Boundary, runtime and public synthesis still describe their progression without this concrete startup qualification. Deterministic publication success does not resolve it.

Identity and exact-byte binding

• run-id: AAS-2026-10-19-autogenesis-05936a4e4c3b-01.
• method-commit: 3e2491c83a4613d410511af8c3cfde30f4b67689.
• source-revision: 5b070d5cd497e951a188a01409138e8b530eaf4a.
• Source: https://github.com/DVampire/Autogenesis.
• W: /media/zby/2b5e98b6-baf0-4e97-90d2-03321ea23372/outputs/commonplace-worktrees/batch-23-autogenesis.
• S: W/related-systems/DVampire--Autogenesis.
• P: W/kb/agentic-system-analyses/retained/dvampire--autogenesis.
• R: W/kb/agentic-system-analyses/state/ plus the exact run ID above.
• Prepared command prefix: W/.venv/bin; preparation: W.preparation.json.
• Log: /media/zby/2b5e98b6-baf0-4e97-90d2-03321ea23372/outputs/batch-23/autogenesis.output.
• Auditor: independent Pi project session 01a15552-ac1f-7637-8c95-544698c9acc2; environment reports PI_PROVIDER=openai, PI_MODEL=gpt-6.1-sol, PI_REASONING_LEVEL=medium. No delegation.

The complete cases.autogenesis object in sealed intake was programmatically loaded. Independently hashed all 2,065 source files, 13 publication files and 192 run files against its maps: zero mismatches. Worktree HEAD equals the method commit; source HEAD equals the source revision and source short status is empty. Worktree short status shows only the untracked own publication. Preparation agrees on worktree, commit and command prefix. Completed R/effects/publish.json binds this run/source/destination, expected absent, old null, and the identical 13-member new map. No incumbent substitution is involved.

Current evidence	Verified SHA-256
Preparation	9870136104c62a16e6493e490d0e54a34cd487dbb8b6f36dca586f161c4e71f6
Publication effect	bd4c5f736bdd14673438175535bfe5c3b264420b99d050e3078d8d373c0d7578
External log	bb78f9e75eef8236e7e26193e6946b6e86d7f33efa09f5fdc08e309546fd32dd
Published manifest	d43862b428f1c64cc844a6e7fda062a85be83362bfab4696364eaed91734fb46
Public synthesis	c58cd6366390644797b5a68718966a6ec9838aae180ec4ec06ec0d404d9554df

Consequential source discrepancy

Historical audits were leads only: the post-migration hold and renewed hold concern a different run/method. systems.md links the authored review, which mixes paper v5, release fd6ab4c3… and this main revision. Only matching-main claims supplied discrepancy leads; neither paper results nor historical test outcomes are fresh evidence.

Independent confirmation in S:

• autogenesis/tool/__init__.py:4 unconditionally executes from .other import *. Its directory contains context.py, default/, __init__.py, README.md, server.py, types.py; neither other.py nor other/ exists.
• autogenesis/gateway/service.py:66 imports tool_manager from that package. autogenesis/cli.py:48–54 imports the Gateway in the terminal-session path; serve paths also import it at lines 143 and 157.
• examples/run_general_agent.py:22 and examples/run_meta_agent.py:37 import from the same package. The general-agent driver is explicitly included by this boundary.

Under ordinary Python package loading, these paths encounter the absent relative module before reaching their described task machinery, assuming earlier prerequisites succeed. Installing external dependencies does not supply that missing local module. This is a static prerequisite finding, not a target import/test execution or a fresh seven-error count.

P boundary.md, “Classification and loop coverage,” describes console/Gateway startup and the direct driver without this condition. P runtime.md:20–22 and RT-RTE-gateway-task describe the startup/task chain; P synthesis.md, “From request to model-directed work,” advances from submission through MetaAgent/model dispatch without the missing-module qualification. Its limitations table discusses external prerequisites and unobserved execution, not this concrete local defect. Overview's retrieval description supplies no correction. P report verification supports the Gateway route and declares no blockers/limits.

The internal architecture remains useful as a conditional account. However, “not executed” does not substitute for disclosing a known source-visible barrier to reaching it. The synthesis type requires preservation of conditions changing whether mechanisms operate. An audit-only caveat cannot repair the public omission. This establishes the hold without reconstructing the whole analysis.

Preserved qualifications and historical coverage limits

Read complete overview, boundary, synthesis and report verification; inspected runtime entry/admission passages and the profile/synthesis verification qualification and verdict passages. The new public account retains valuable distinctions: internal change versus demonstrated improvement, nonempty summaries versus faithful retention, transcript replay versus tier reload, advisory review versus product correctness, and route-local permissions versus deployed confinement. It additionally carries memory-class instance and hashless-checkpoint exceptions; those claims were not independently rebuilt here.

A bounded independent source sample confirms the admission qualification: S autogenesis/extension/server.py:210–264 loads/registers and archives/writes the manifest before optional smoke. autogenesis/extension/smoke_gate.py:51–102 selects a general agent and checks response success/constraint status, not exact OK or compulsory changed-component invocation. This is consistent with the public account and does not cancel the startup omission.

Historical paper/release mechanisms, benchmark reproduction, six gitlinks, installer behavior and the earlier test count were not re-established. The current boundary explicitly excludes separate gitlink contents and supplies no observed-run evidence. No paper/main equivalence or fresh reproducibility pass is inferred. Previous exact-run holds and incidents remain preserved, not cleared by this publication.

Bounded operational evidence

Inspected the settled report-verifier result at external-log JSONL line 4554, message.details.results[0], task handout 000035-report-verification; model gpt-6.1-sol, medium, exit 0. Locators below use zero-based messages indices. Exact tool-call IDs were paired with results inside that same worker, not streaming snapshots:

Call/result messages	Call ID prefix (before the function suffix)	Established action
2/3	call_b6VRXpebknd6cQyHwsKegzoo	Successful invocation read
4/5	call_5bE8L25b1fkhiTMYCo0n1cjy	Successful report-verifier instruction read
54/55	call_9azvMtRXowBQCK8xZ8fkWbaV	Successful extension-server source read, offset 209, limit 125
93/94	call_CzpLEqzQTaXlcSWUHmb5Bxcp	Actual successful write of handout-local worker identity
95/96	call_aYZX4UXRoc1jhetKVT6gfvD0	Actual successful write of handout-local outputs/verification.md
97/98	call_9HOknHorZjovgEnBvfNhwODL	Performed validate-output; returned member-content pass, explicitly not acceptance or claim support

These are completed reads, writes and a check, not suggested actions. They establish some performed obligations in this worker, not universal worker compliance, exhaustive write-scope safety or target operation. The missed source qualification is evidenced by the published verifier's accepted route assessment, not speculation about hidden reasoning. No new specific authority violation was established in this bounded sample.

Validation, stop and unblock

Read applicable workshop/text, analysis collection/set, overview and synthesis contracts, plus the complete commission, audit procedure and workshop README. In W with its prepared prefix, bare commonplace-validate P returned VALIDATION SUCCESS: one directory-artifact subject, zero failures/warnings, no notices. The owned report was also validated with bare commonplace-validate from that prepared environment: VALIDATION SUCCESS, one text file, zero failures/warnings and no notices. Deterministic checks do not adjudicate the missing semantic qualification.

Unblock: a supported new publication must publicly qualify both ordinary entry paths with the frozen missing-module prerequisite and carry the conditional account through boundary, runtime and synthesis; alternatively provide source-backed evidence that the relative import resolves in this exact checkout. Rebind and revalidate exact bytes afterward. Do not patch accepted bytes or execute/install the target merely to disclose this static fact.

Stop at this specific defect. Complete memory/epistemic inventories, every dependency, all worker effects and historical test reconstruction remain uninspected, not passed. Only this report was authored. No analyst feedback, delegation, commits, run commands/effects, integration, acquisition, target execution, source/state edits, cleanup, termination or push occurred. Unpublished timeout cases were not inspected.