Proposals Directory

Type: kb/types/index.md

← Parent

  • A reader-facing banner for unreviewed notes (note) - Proposal: warn readers of unreviewed notes with a standardized top-of-note banner derived from review-state, kept consistent with the canonical status by a validator check
  • Assertion force separate from lifecycle status (note) - Proposal: split status semantics — lifecycle stays a structural enum; what commitment 'current' expresses (endorsed, attributed, captured) becomes contract-defined assertion force
  • Automated note refinement as a search over a fixed source bundle (note) - Proposal: build the automated note-refinement loop on a source bundle that emits a set of notes, not a single identity-stable note — reframing non-convergence (split, drift, kill) as search outcomes
  • Backlink surfacing (note) - Proposal: how Commonplace could surface inbound links — build-time web rendering for humans, on-demand inversion for agents, curated symmetric labels for tension; committed generated footers and full manual bidirectionality are foreclosed
  • Factored dependency pairs for review freshness (note) - Proposal: admit new review dependencies as factored (note, dependency) pairs with the dependency as the gate — source-as-gate and a cohort-scoped ack remain; COLLECTION.md-as-gate adopted (ADR 041)
  • Gate learning from accepted edits (note) - Proposal: learn review gates from accepted note edits, with candidate mining, usefulness tracking, lifecycle promotion, and budgeted loading. Atomic gates shipped; learning has not
  • Harness-orchestrated review sweeps (note) - Proposal: run review sweeps through harness sub-agent orchestration once comparable surfaces exist in more than one harness
  • Model partition registry (note) - Proposal: introduce a model partition registry for review validation, aliases, and runner defaults without making the registry the review identity
  • Review configuration object (note) - Proposal: a ReviewConfig object owned by commonplace.review, consolidating the review subsystem's project-shape constants (scan roots, gates root, artifact root, db path) with per-project override — deliberately not a global ProjectConfig, so the experimental db-backed review subsystem stays decoupled from the stable core
  • Structured-output codec for the review protocol (note) - Proposal: make review output a pluggable codec, with sentinel markdown today and schema-validated structured output when harnesses expose it
  • Verifiable quotes (note) - Proposal: mechanically verify verbatim-marked citations against their source snapshot — a Level A deterministic check, not a review gate, since the derived-copy rule forbids leaving it hand-trusted