SkillX profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the memory profile, including every unit's scope, assessment, findings, evidence basis and supporting records. I assessed the prior objection and the author's answer afresh. Classification used the handed reports and reconciliation; source-read log: none. The feedback-summary and plan-object supersessions are respected. Combined records with noncoextensive parts are not treated as additional independent witnesses or as superseded parts.

Storage and form. MEM-OBJ-skill-library, MEM-OBJ-trajectory, MEM-OBJ-retrieval-vectors and MEM-OBJ-task-checkpoint support file, in-process and vector storage. The profile does not turn the FAISS-HNSW configuration label into an implemented persisted index. Model-consumed plans, reference bodies and examples are distinguished from symbolic keys, tool/type fields and recovery controls, and from dense parametric access representations. Grouping some equally classified parts makes the units coarse but does not transfer a finding across incompatible consumers or unresolved payloads. Remaining bundled content stays uninspected, and both axes remain partial.

Lineage and admission. RT-RTE-library-build, MEM-RTE-proposal-context and MEM-RTE-feedback-summary support trace extraction and automatic admission on their named paths. Imported histories and compiled retrieval encodings retain distinct derivation paths. Unknown initial authorship and caller content decisions are not inferred from workflow startup or physical file writing. The blocked checked-export preflight is not counted as an operative admission gate; EPI-RTE-export-validation supports that qualification. Known transformations do not resolve initial-content provenance or opaque backend provenance.

Authority. History supplies contextual evidence and feeds durable updates; reference plans and skills supply advice to later extraction and prompt consumers. RT-BAP-skill-guidance supports reference use, not callable installation, standing host policy or exercised compliance. MEM-OBJ-skill-metadata supports routing and the tool-eligibility veto at their fixed-code consumers. MEM-OBJ-task-checkpoint and RT-RTE-task-synthesis support threshold/hash validation, enforced exclusion and progress routing. MEM-OBJ-retrieval-vectors supports ranking. These effects are distinguished from unconsumed provenance metadata and unresolved sample consumers; the partial authority axis does not assert complete consumer coverage.

Curation. Compression and cluster reduction support consolidation; incoming atomic redundancy suppression, duplicate-query removal and same-name revision support the emitted deduplication and evolution findings. Their warrants are MEM-RTE-feedback-summary, MEM-OBJ-skill-library, MEM-RTE-proposal-context and RT-RTE-task-synthesis. Semantic fidelity is not required to classify implemented compression, but novelty is not inferred from generative route names. The profile retains unresolved semantic alternatives and does not claim a global predecessor sweep, history-preserving invalidation or observed quality gain. Check-placement limits in RT-CLM-quality-control do not contradict these transformation classifications.

Read-back direction and signal. The revised profile separates wired service task/step pull from the afforded public PlanRewriteService.get_pseudo_plan pull invocation. RT-RTE-prompt-prepare supports that distinction: wired internal progression does not supply a shipped helper caller or later delivery. Both units and the rationale now preserve it, so the prior blocker is resolved. Automatic proposal and copied-summary supply are distinct push operations; MEM-RTE-proposal-context supports coarse functional-list supply and the atomic map's actual identifier match. MEM-RTE-feedback-summary supports coarse copied-history supply. Checkpoint recovery automatically supplies matching saved state as a whole, with processed indices controlling continuation rather than identity-targeted delivery. Requested vector retrieval is not mislabeled as embedding-based push. Inapplicability is local to the assessed pull unit; unresolved artifact/API delivery remains not-determinable.

Trace learning and source. RT-RTE-library-build and RT-RTE-prompt-prepare establish automatic history-fed durable instructions with later context preparation. MEM-RTE-feedback-summary and MEM-RTE-proposal-context establish retained replacement/proposal context crossing model invocations. Their wired yes findings do not require a separately saved summary file, improved capacity or successful benchmark execution. MEM-OBJ-trajectory supports the conversational, tool and linked-trajectory inputs to the qualifying writes. Summary sources remain tied to user/tool feedback and the preceding action, not adapter labels. The synthetic-objective consumer and arbitrary input origins remain unresolved locally; no system-wide no, source absence or event-stream finding is asserted.

No current inter-report conflict changes these classifications. All ten axis assessments remain partial; unresolved included alternatives are not erased by the positive witnesses. The emitted bases do not assert observed operation or causal benefit. The remaining uncertainty is faithfully scoped rather than a defect requiring an additional publication limit.

Blockers

none

Limits

none