deja-vu profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I checked all ten axes, their findings and evidence bases, their classification units, and their coverage assessments against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow accounts. The profile rationale keeps the comparison boundary on retained content, access structures and later-consumer mechanisms rather than all runtime storage. Reconciliation resolves the duplicate fix objects to the memory declarations and the duplicate convention selector to the memory route; the profile uses those canonical referents. The distinct epistemic check, disposition, retention and selection records remain applicable. No prior refusal was supplied, and the supplied profile answers file is empty.
Storage and form. Filesystem findings distinguish JSONL, gob, binary and dense encodings from substrates. Lifecycle memoization independently supports in-memory storage. The form units distinguish interpreted prose from fixed-code selectors and dense representations; parametric form does not assert model-weight training or vector-database storage. Local filesystem witnesses do not classify opaque provider retention or specialized checkpoint payloads. Those alternatives remain unresolved, so the partial assessments are supported (MEM-OBJ-notes, EPI-OBJ-lifecycle, MEM-OBJ-records, MEM-OBJ-session-meta, RT-CMP-embed-client, RT-RTE-auto-delivery).
Lineage. Caller-authored notes, imported history/copies, trace-extracted derivatives and compiled retrieval representations retain distinct derivation paths. Default promotion is separated from caller override; rule formulation is claimed while distribution is wired. Known derivation scopes do not resolve initial rules provenance, authenticated imported authorship or provider weights. The unresolved units preserve those distinctions rather than upgrading them through another wired witness (EPI-RTE-promote-distill, MEM-OBJ-notes, MEM-OBJ-records, MEM-OBJ-compaction-data, RT-RTE-import-records, RT-RTE-rules-sync).
Behavioral authority. The findings name consumer effects rather than granting one authority to an entire container. Historical reference and continuation evidence support knowledge; imperative reminders and constraints support requested instruction force, not demonstrated obedience. Standing-rule loading remains afforded. Update consumers give retained experience learning force separately from downstream knowledge. Text, vectors and candidate/lifecycle fields influence ranking; identity and delivery metadata route selection. Suppression and candidate gates provide validation and enforced withholding where their actual consumers apply them. The profile preserves the requested-lookup candidate fallback and the narrower confirmed-only plan gate. Its convention instruction finding does not settle the tension with untrusted framing or assert effective priority (RT-BAP-recall-reference, RT-BAP-standing-rules, MEM-RTE-convention-delivery, EPI-RTE-fix-selection, EPI-RTE-fix-retention, MEM-RTE-forget-cleanup, MEM-OBJ-compaction-state).
Write agency. The profile distinguishes per-content human selection in the prescribed rules workflow from subsequent software copying and automatic extraction/admission. Starting a command does not make its transformations manual. Generic CLI caller identity and direct source edits remain unresolved rather than being assigned manual agency. The claimed manual finding does not imply a code-enforced consent gate; the workflow account confirms this distinction (RT-RTE-note-admission, EPI-RTE-promote-distill, RT-RTE-rules-sync, workflow account).
Curation. The seven emitted operations have local transformation warrants: extractive reduction, tuple/display deduplication, revision, lifecycle or contribution withdrawal, salience elevation, bounded forgetting, and the separate inferred outcome assertion. Consolidation does not assert semantic preservation. The compaction synthesis finding is supported by the epistemic ledger's overlay on the recovery record: no detected friction can produce a passing assertion without entailing actual success. It is not inferred merely from lossy extraction, and it is not a truth warrant. Rules semantic reduction remains claimed; ordinary rebuilding and embedding acquisition are not relabelled curation. The session-fact precision dispute does not affect these classifications, which make no exact four-entry capacity comparison (EPI-RTE-promote-distill, MEM-OBJ-compaction-data, RT-RTE-compaction-recovery, epistemic authority ledger, MEM-OBJ-fixes, EPI-RTE-fix-retention, MEM-OBJ-notes, MEM-RTE-convention-delivery, MEM-OBJ-sessionfacts).
Read-back direction and signal. Explicit requests and internal update reads support pull; unsolicited event delivery and continuation recovery support wired push. Later whole-rule loading is a separate afforded push. Request fulfillment is not counted as another push. Signal units identify triggers, actual selector inputs and selected parts. Project-convention and session/workspace matches select delivered retained parts and support identifier push. Broad recency/budget filtering remains coarse, while task, prompt, error and plan relevance support inferred-lexical selection. Dense requested reranking is not evidence of inferred-embedding push. Pull-only units have locally inapplicable signal findings without making the partial axis inapplicable. Specialized deferred/checkpoint routes remain uninspected; ordinary recovery output bookkeeping does not establish their retry safety (RT-RTE-requested-recall, MEM-RTE-session-recovery, RT-RTE-auto-delivery, RT-RTE-spawn-context, MEM-RTE-convention-delivery, EPI-RTE-plan-delivery, RT-RTE-compaction-recovery).
Trace learning and source. Fix mining, continuation extraction and command/failure derivatives support wired automatic trace-fed durable artifacts with later consumers. These findings establish architecture, not observed improvement. Conversational records and tool activity support session-logs and tool-traces on the named qualifying writes. Event triggers do not add event-stream content, and temporal association alone does not establish trajectories. Provider internals and incompletely traced alternatives remain unresolved, not negative. The inventory omits another supported qualifying write, identified below; that omission does not invalidate the emitted positives or the explicitly partial system assessments (MEM-RTE-trace-mining, MEM-OBJ-compaction-data, MEM-OBJ-commands, MEM-OBJ-commandfails, RT-CMP-embed-client).
No emitted value asserts observation, causal support, complete system coverage or bounded absence. Some units group homogeneous consumers or transformations, but they retain the material differences in force, agency and evidence basis. I found no unsupported positive value requiring a publication blocker. Source-read log: none; verification used only the handed records and their overlays.
Blockers
none
Limits
- The partial trace-learning and trace-source inventories omit default promoted-note distillation as a qualifying route. EPI-RTE-promote-distill establishes fixed automatic extraction from retained session messages, durable note admission and later recall/convention consumption; MEM-OBJ-notes supplies persistence and reload. The profile already classifies this derivation as trace-extracted and its extraction agency as automatic, but its trace axes enumerate fixes, continuation and command/failure derivatives without this branch (profile rationale). Consumers should withhold complete qualifying-route enumeration and route-by-route trace-source comparisons for promoted notes. This is a local inventory omission, not evidence of absence: both affected axes are partial, and their wired yes, session-logs and tool-traces findings remain valid. Adding this branch would not change those emitted system-level positive values or establish complete coverage.