OpenKB profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the memory profile, including unit scope, controlled findings, evidence basis, unresolved alternatives and axis coverage. I used the handed analyst records and annotations, resolving the source-content supersession through the supplied reconciliation. I made no source reads and added no records or quotations. The supplied profile answers are empty; no predecessor objection determines this judgment.

  • Storage and form: Files are supported for retained local artifacts; reusable history also has an in-memory list representation. Symbolic routing/control fields are distinguished from interpreted prose. Exported source files do not determine PageIndex's private substrate or representation. The unresolved provider and visual-payload units appropriately prevent complete coverage. See MEM-OBJ-source-content, MEM-OBJ-session-history, MEM-OBJ-graph and RT-CMP-pageindex-client. The transient graph-construction mapping alone is not an additional retained-memory witness; the reusable session list independently supports the emitted in-memory finding.
  • Lineage: Imported source artifacts, authored model text, deterministic metadata/projections and extracted interaction history have distinct derivation warrants. Known downstream derivation does not resolve initial local-instruction authorship or provider summary provenance. Summary, concept and entity parts remain valid alongside their body container. See MEM-OBJ-source-content, EPI-OBJ-summary, EPI-OBJ-concept, EPI-OBJ-entity and MEM-OBJ-session-history.
  • Authority: Knowledge at answering consumers is not truth endorsement. Planner briefs and source counts influence priority; paths/source associations route operations; registered hashes constrain duplicate admission. Saved expected labels supply comparison criteria and select coverage questions without vetoing installation. Local schema and installed skills have instruction consumers, whereas generating a package does not install it. See MEM-OBJ-page-frontmatter, MEM-OBJ-hashes, MEM-RTE-skill-eval, RT-BAP-schema-instructions and RT-BAP-skill-instructions. The history learning-authority finding concerns its update consumer, not improved capacity.
  • Write agency: Automatic generation/admission remains separate from user initiation. The human-facing editor supports an afforded manual path, not a claim that all API callers are human. Operator-selected checkpoint restoration supports manual replacement; it does not make the subsequent generator's content admission manual. Initial schema/skill control and arbitrary callers remain unresolved. See RT-RTE-document-add, MEM-RTE-page-edit, MEM-OBJ-iterations and RT-RTE-skill-create.
  • Curation: Summary/brief reduction supports consolidate, and full-body update or explicit replacement supports evolve. Model requests for synthesis do not establish novel claims absent from inputs. Hash skipping, edge uniqueness and index maintenance do not independently establish memory deduplication. Source withdrawal does not establish history-preserving invalidation or complete factual erasure. See EPI-OBJ-summary, MEM-OBJ-page-frontmatter, MEM-RTE-page-edit and EPI-RTE-source-withdrawal.
  • Read-back direction and signal: Requested paths, ranges, bodies and saved sets support pull; automatic history, planner context and instruction catalogs support push. Session identity selects the history actually delivered. The compiler's model choice of update targets supports inferred-judgment, with the subsequent slug lookup a distinct identifier operation. Availability-based enumeration supports coarse selection. Requested file identifiers alone are not push signals. The external-host route retains afforded rather than wired basis. See RT-RTE-wiki-query, RT-RTE-session-chat, RT-RTE-document-add and MEM-RTE-host-read. Exploration retention is not silently upgraded to catalog-mediated discovery, and critic artifact reads are not attributed to ordinary foreground chat.
  • Trace learning and source: Sanitized SDK activity is retained and supplied to later turns, supporting wired yes without a semantic-summary or weight-update requirement. Saved conversational results also have a retained artifact and later wiki consumer route. Session turns and recorded tool requests/results support the respective session-logs and tool-traces findings. Display traces are not substituted for model history. No supplied absence record supports local no, and unresolved alternatives correctly keep both axes partial. See MEM-OBJ-session-history, MEM-OBJ-session-display, MEM-OBJ-explorations and RT-RTE-session-chat.

All axes retain partial inventory assessments rather than claiming complete enumeration. No emitted existence finding depends on observed operation, reliable model compliance or causal benefit. The remaining local omissions below do not change the supported system unions and do not justify suppressing their positive findings.

Blockers

none

Limits

  • The partial authority inventory omits the exploration-producing update consumer as a separate learning-authority path: MEM-OBJ-explorations and RT-RTE-session-chat support the automatic conversational-result retention chain that the profile already classifies as trace learning. The history path independently supports the emitted learning value, and later exploration reads already support knowledge. Withhold a complete comparison of which trace-fed update consumers carry learning authority; this omission does not invalidate those existence findings.
  • Some retained output parts are not individually classified in the partial form and lineage inventories. In particular, RT-RTE-deck-produce and WF-CLM-cli-delivery establish retained model-authored deck content, while EPI-OBJ-lint-report distinguishes derived assessment from the raw log grouped in diagnostics. The profile covers deck markup and diagnostic prose but does not separately inventory slide prose or lint-report authorship. Natural-language and authored already have independent supported witnesses. Withhold complete part-by-part form and derivation comparisons for these outputs, not the emitted system-level existence values.