Playground reconciliation

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-reconciliation-report.md

Reconciliation

Connected account and current corrections

The reports share the provider-and-gateway scope in boundary and the frozen evidence identity in its Source register. Runtime traces caller-selected execution and admission; memory distinguishes retained material and later consumers; epistemic separates delivered evidence from substantive warrant; workflow traces client-owned start, poll, cancellation and release. None establishes observed target execution or causal benefit.

The current memory Integration issues explicitly correct the implementation classification of telemetry and maintenance from afforded to wired after script rereads. Its current declarations agree with the corresponding epistemic records' wired implementation findings and implemented ledger rows. The previous reconciliation's two status conflicts therefore no longer describe the supplied reports. No separate correction answers or declined objections were supplied to this attempt. The corrections change neither the external semantic limits nor the shared uninspected operation findings. No remaining cross-report disagreement is identified below.

RT-RTE-sandbox-exec, RT-RTE-retained-jobs and RT-RTE-file-exchange provide common route referents. The memory annotations add retained inputs, selection and delivery limits; the workflow annotations add sequencing and recovery responsibilities. The epistemic ledger distinguishes acquisition, retention and operational admission over these routes from acceptance of their substantive assertions. These overlays supply complementary fields, not duplicate declarations.

Identity, containment and overlap

Amendment: MEM-RTE-telemetry-display is superseded by EPI-RTE-telemetry-report. Both identify the same complete operator invocation of SRC-1 scripts/view_telemetry.rs: fixed-branch selection, duration decoding, grouping by name, ranking and stdout delivery. Their retained console-loop and arithmetic passages establish the identity; they are not successive stages. Affected findings are selection, conditional arithmetic reporting and absence of a wired adaptation consumer in this script. Both now assign implementation wired and operation uninspected. Memory's subsequent rereading of existing spans and epistemic's non-retention of the derived report concern different objects, not conflicting read-back findings. Supersession connects the duplicate referent without replacing either analyst's fields.

MEM-RTE-storage-maintenance remains a valid container for two explicitly separated wrapper operations. EPI-RTE-timestamp-reshape and EPI-RTE-timestamp-retain separate conversion from persistence in SRC-1 scripts/migrate_timestamps.rs; EPI-RTE-link-rewrite describes the wiki operation in SRC-1 scripts/rewrite-links.sh. Supersession is ruled out: the parts do not make the container's combined findings wrong. The memory correction agrees that those wrapper operations are wired while native acceptance, resolver correctness and subsequent semantic consumption remain unresolved. No missing operative part is established by this difference in granularity.

The declared parts retain distinct identities: MEM-OBJ-output-log is retained data within RT-CMP-job-manager; MEM-OBJ-job-snapshot is a delivered page within RT-RTE-retained-jobs; MEM-RTE-native-onboarding is initialization within RT-RTE-tenant-provision. EPI-RTE-file-check and EPI-RTE-file-disposition separate checks from consumption of their results within RT-RTE-file-exchange. None replaces its container; supersession is ruled out for each part/container pair.

Object supersessions are also ruled out for EPI-OBJ-file-payload and MEM-OBJ-workspace-files. The former spans exchange buffers and file content; the latter identifies persistent filesystem material also changed by arbitrary execution. EPI-OBJ-exec-result spans output and status across synchronous and retained execution, whereas MEM-OBJ-output-log identifies stored chunks and MEM-OBJ-job-snapshot a delivered page with access metadata. Shared bytes do not establish identical complete referents. EPI-RTE-result-render is a distinct cross-route delivery transformation, neither a duplicate execution kernel nor a part wholly contained in one supplied runtime route.

EPI-OBJ-timestamp-tribles, EPI-OBJ-wiki-fragments and EPI-OBJ-telemetry-spans identify selected script material, not replacements for MEM-OBJ-self-pile or MEM-OBJ-shared-pile. The reports do not establish that all scripts use those provisioned piles. MEM-OBJ-self-key and MEM-OBJ-session-profile identify signer material and executable defaults, not duplicate declarations of RT-BAP-shell-command. Supersession is ruled out for these overlaps.

Claim supersession is ruled out between MEM-CLM-memory-cover and EPI-CLM-memory-provenance: SRC-1 docs/playground_memory_architecture.md supplies both, but the former concerns hierarchical context selection and competing consolidation doctrine, the latter temporal association and warrant. Neither duplicates EPI-CLM-shell-causality, which concerns sequential model-command feedback and replay. EPI-CLM-file-lossless concerns encoding fidelity, distinct from storage lifetime in RT-CLM-persistent-sandbox.

Integration dispositions and independent convergence

The lifecycle qualification in memory does not contradict RT-RTE-tenant-provision. Runtime describes removal of sandbox resources and credentials; MEM-OBJ-self-pile, MEM-OBJ-shared-pile and MEM-OBJ-self-key distinguish retained host material in SRC-1 src/sandbox/jail.rs and src/sandbox/lima.rs. Clone/disk removal and persistence of external piles can coexist. The qualification prevents interpreting destruction as total memory erasure without requiring a runtime correction.

The final-page qualification likewise agrees with RT-RTE-retained-jobs, which names observed terminal final pages, not acknowledged delivery. MEM-OBJ-job-snapshot, EPI-RTE-result-render and the workflow account independently retain SRC-1 src/jobs.rs's server-observation-versus-network-acknowledgement passage. Result construction can permit capacity recycling before client receipt. Ring eviction, TTL and daemon restart remain distinct loss mechanisms; none establishes complete transcript retention or model consumption.

The reports agree on RT-RTE-worker-forward: fixed destination mapping and pile/key/persona launch configuration establish transport and custody, not native content selection, admission, model state or semantic memory. Its retained SRC-1 src/mcp_http/workers.rs timeout passage leaves execution outcome unknown and explicitly excludes retry. Memory's annotation and epistemic's admission ledger do not require a stronger native-memory finding. These external unknowns are limitations, not disagreements or evidence of absent worker memory.

MEM-ABS-context-loader supports a bounded absence on provider entry/module surfaces. MEM-CLM-memory-cover, EPI-CLM-memory-provenance and EPI-CLM-shell-causality retain model-loop doctrine without attributing it to the current provider implementation. Memory's temporal-provenance wording, legacy-lens and breath-display discrepancies are conflicts within source-native documents, not between analyst findings. They prevent a definitive external renderer account while leaving the bounded provider absence intact.

EPI-RTE-smoke-check identifies a distinct operator test route with fixture reference outcomes in SRC-1 deploy/freebsd/smoke.sh. Supersession with normal execution is ruled out. The test does not contradict workflow's lack of task-semantic verification: its predicates control a smoke script, not acceptance of an arbitrary agent deliverable. Neither a supplied pass nor a production release gate is established.

Finally, file checks, source-fingerprint build completion in RT-RTE-bundle-build, raw-output retention, timestamp encoding preservation and telemetry arithmetic retain separate authority scopes. The corrected maintenance classifications do not grant substantive warrant or demonstrate learning. External admission, actual caller control, deployed append-only enforcement, model compliance, exercised self-improvement and benefit remain independently unestablished, not cross-report conflicts.

This reconciliation uses the supplied members only. No named ambiguity required a frozen-source read. No analyst value or report was rewritten.