Stigmergy profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes of the memory profile, including each finding's scope, basis, coverage assessment and operative unit. The review used the handed boundary, reports, reconciliation and empty profile answers. Reconciliation establishes no supersessions affecting the cited records. No source reads, new records or replacement classifications were needed.

Storage and form. MEM-OBJ-artifact, MEM-OBJ-source, MEM-OBJ-fragment-vector and MEM-OBJ-knowledge-changes support the file/repository, evidence-store and relational/vector distinctions. The in-process evidence-store alternative is explicitly separated from durable remote storage; its implementation classification does not claim process-independent persistence. Readable content, fixed-rule metadata and dense vectors have separate form units. Original media remain unresolved rather than inheriting the readable derivative's classification. The grouped corpus units identify homogeneous parts for their respective findings; they do not classify transient model inputs as accumulated memory.

Lineage. Import and subsequent compilation are separate derivation paths. MEM-OBJ-artifact, MEM-OBJ-knowledge-body, MEM-OBJ-fragment-vector and MEM-RTE-workspace-replay support those paths without establishing original authorship, upstream trace extraction or provider weight provenance. The profile preserves those distinctions instead of treating model involvement as trace origin.

Authority. Knowledge, ranking, enforcement, validation and routing findings name actual consumed parts and consequences. RT-BAP-corpus-data establishes evidence delivery, not standing directions. MEM-OBJ-page-metadata and MEM-OBJ-fragment-vector support selector influence; MEM-OBJ-contradiction-data supports capture-path preservation criteria and vetoes. Recovery and handover routing are supported by MEM-OBJ-knowledge-changes and MEM-RTE-workspace-replay. The capture-specific scope avoids extending preservation guarantees to garden.

Agency and curation. RT-RTE-capture-filing, MEM-RTE-alias-recording and RT-RTE-maintenance-admission support automatic derived-content admission independently of workflow initiation. Explicit operator-confirmed replay has a separate admission unit; generic principal/master authorization remains unresolved. Consolidation and duplicate removal have a concrete transformation witness in EPI-RTE-entity-merge. Revision and history-preserving withdrawal have distinct warrants. Unresolved source-to-proposal semantics in EPI-RTE-filing-transform are not converted into an unsupported synthesis finding.

Direction and signal. MEM-RTE-scoped-reading supports requested pull. Automatic context supply in RT-RTE-capture-filing and the initial search in RT-RTE-scoped-answer support push at the selection operation, despite request-rooted enclosing workflows. The profile correctly distinguishes this operation from requested returns. Identity matching, lexical overlap, vector similarity and coarse availability/budget filtering are tied to their respective selectors; a requested page address alone is not used to infer targeted push.

Trace axes and coverage. Automatic durable updates and later consumers are supported, but the cited records do not identify qualifying original trace inputs. The profile therefore emits neither trace-learning value nor trace-source value. There is no bounded-absence record licensing a local negative. The unresolved operational alternatives remain included across the inventory. Partial assessments on the eight classified axes and unresolved assessments on the two trace axes do not imply complete enumeration or absence.

I checked both reconciliation disagreements for consequences to these classifications. The filing-budget qualification does not defeat the supported selection mechanisms. The quote-domain disagreement between RT-RTE-scoped-answer and EPI-RTE-answer-check prevents a delivered-text or snapshot guarantee, but no emitted comparison finding requires that guarantee. The profile retains both qualifications. Its positive bases describe inspected mechanisms, not observed use or causal benefit. The remaining uncertainty is faithfully scoped; no material classification defect or additional publication limit was established.

Blockers

none

Limits

none