WikiSkill profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes of the memory profile against the handed records and annotations, including natural units, positive values, evidence bases and inventory assessments. I applied the reconciliation's supersession of the epistemic product-pattern declaration by MEM-OBJ-patterns. The journal container, research Wiki, impact history and named SKILL/PURPOSE mapping remain distinct. No source files were read, and no new records or quotations were added.

  • Storage substrate and representational form: The inspected product, research and deployment objects support file storage. Interpreted lesson/instruction text is distinguished from fixed-rule identifiers, scores and replay metadata. Opaque product outputs retain unresolved form rather than inheriting the form of their display rows. The excluded external inference weights do not become an operational memory substrate. See RT-OBJ-product-journal, MEM-OBJ-experience, MEM-OBJ-research-wiki and MEM-OBJ-paper-skills.
  • Lineage: Authored role outputs, imported initial/inherited content, trace-extracted procedural outputs and deterministic compiled views describe separate derivation paths. Those findings do not authenticate every direct submission or resolve pre-import provenance. The local unresolved unit preserves that distinction. See MEM-OBJ-skill, MEM-OBJ-research-evidence and EPI-RTE-wiki-index.
  • Behavioral authority: The profile distinguishes reference and guidance at learning authors, retained experience at update consumers, SKILL instructions at task executors, and control metadata at replay/admission consumers. Learning authority does not imply observed improvement; source-ID checks do not establish truth. Retained criteria supporting validation and enforced refusal are separate from interpreted lessons. See MEM-BAP-wiki-authors, RT-BAP-skill-consumption, RT-OBJ-product-journal and RT-RTE-feedback-gate.
  • Write agency: Model/software admission and generated views support automatic findings. Initial supply, direct callers and deployment replacement remain unresolved rather than becoming manual through an origin string or replacement flag. Starting a workflow is not per-content approval. See MEM-OBJ-patterns, MEM-RTE-paper-adapters and RT-RTE-skill-install.
  • Curation operations: Named-entry replacement, page updates and local patches support evolution. Reduced retained trace views support wired consolidation; index rebuilding alone would not establish that operation. Requested semantic consolidation remains a distinct claimed finding. Unresolved model-output semantics do not warrant synthesis or deduplication. See MEM-OBJ-research-evidence, EPI-RTE-paper-contract and EPI-CLM-wiki-lessons.
  • Read-back direction and signal: Automatic context assembly supports push, while later model requests for staged files support pull. Whole-content inclusion and bounded sampling support coarse signals; round/request matching and retained-skill identity support identifier selection. File availability alone establishes neither targeted push nor ranking. Export/installation/restoration now retain only their filesystem effects and unresolved external-host direction, not an independently wired pull route. See RT-RTE-product-round, MEM-OBJ-research-evidence and RT-RTE-skill-install.
  • Trace learning and trace source: Automatic research trace-fed Wiki/skill writes have durable results and later consumers. The study's Maintainer-to-Proposer bridge qualifies without inventing another final-skill deployment. Optional product trace input remains conditional. Tool activity and case-linked execution support tool-traces and trajectories; session call/output fallback items do not establish conversational turns. The revised paper/study source unit retains this uncertainty with a partial assessment and no session-logs finding. See MEM-OBJ-research-evidence, MEM-RTE-paper-adapters and RT-RTE-isolated-study.

Both predecessor objections were rechecked against the current profile, not accepted merely from the correction answers. The unsupported session-logs value and deployment pull value are removed, and their dependent notes and rationale preserve the unresolved alternatives. The independently supported staged-file pull and trace-source positives remain valid.

All ten axis assessments remain partial. Included additional callable research controllers, opaque inputs, generic caller control and external host consumption are not silently excluded to obtain complete coverage. These are faithfully scoped uncertainties; they support neither absence nor complete-value comparisons. No remaining material unsupported value, evidence upgrade or false complete-coverage assessment was established.

Blockers

none

Limits

none