FrameCode-VibeWork memory profile

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-memory-profile.md

Comparison rationale

Boundary and coverage

FCVW's memory is primarily project-owned files plus disposable access and check artifacts. The host performs semantic curation; Python implements mechanical derivation, selection and consistency checks. The profile separates retained prose from metadata, compiled copies from source pages, and update consumers from downstream readers. It does not classify the enclosing host's weights or transcript system. The navigation graph/catalog remains an included uninspected alternative, and linked QA payloads remain unresolved rather than classified from the audit's readable description. See MEM-OBJ-wiki, MEM-OBJ-context-index, MEM-OBJ-knowledge-graph and MEM-OBJ-qa-run.

The reconciliation supersedes four epistemic object declarations with the memory declarations: wiki content, wiki metadata, product contract and QA run. All object references here use those canonical memory records. Epistemic phase records remain distinct, including metadata checks, source review and divergence decisions; their valid route containers are not superseded. See MEM-OBJ-wiki, MEM-OBJ-wiki-metadata, MEM-OBJ-product-contract, MEM-OBJ-qa-run, EPI-RTE-evidence-check and EPI-RTE-divergence-decision.

Admission, transformation and authority

Automatic admission is not a synonym for an autonomous FCVW service. The index and report writers are wired software admission. The prescribed model-host synthesis and revision branches require no separate human decision per content item, so they support automatic admission only at claimed strength. Human-supplied content and explicit product-divergence direction are separate manual branches. Unspecified initial imports and generic upgrade callers remain unresolved. See MEM-RTE-index-build, MEM-RTE-session-handoff, RT-RTE-asset-admission, EPI-RTE-divergence-decision and RT-RTE-framework-upgrade.

Consolidation, deduplication, revision, promotion and invalidation are prescribed host transformations. Source-digest mismatch itself only emits review candidates. Lifecycle downweighting is wired decay at the ranking consumer, not universal withdrawal or deletion. Neither a page called synthesis nor index packaging establishes synthesis of a new claim. See MEM-RTE-source-review, EPI-RTE-wiki-review and RT-RTE-context-delivery.

Knowledge, instruction and learning name different consumer paths: notes advise later work; revised skill bodies direct later work; retained experience feeds their update. Ranking, routing and validation concern fixed-rule consumers of retained text/metadata. Plan presence and QA run checks have narrow enforcement force, not universal host isolation. Metadata can influence retrieval before the independent validator flags an authority mismatch; no mandatory validation-before-index chain is established. See MEM-BAP-knowledge-consumption, RT-BAP-policy-consumption, RT-RTE-asset-admission, RT-RTE-hook-lifecycle, EPI-RTE-qa-check and EPI-RTE-evidence-check.

Selection and trace-fed updates

Requested lexical retrieval, section reads, queue requests and handoff resumption are pull. The session-start hook is push of retained plan identities using coarse directory/status selection and a pending-name cap. Filenames in its output do not establish an identity-match selector. References, digests and outlines do not establish delivery of the underlying claim bodies. The current runtime records already incorporate the MCP/hook read-back correction; the memory report's stale integration-issue description does not override them. See RT-RTE-context-delivery, RT-RTE-mcp-checks, RT-RTE-hook-lifecycle and MEM-RTE-session-handoff.

The prescribed experience-to-summary/guidance branches qualify for a claimed trace-learning yes: work evidence feeds a retained artifact for a later interpreting consumer, without universal per-content human approval. The memory report's narrower denial of an implemented automatic transcript learner is consistent with this claimed, not wired, finding. The conversation-fed and recorded execution-feedback branches retain their separate source warrants. Arbitrary imported files, unresolved mixed origins and content-free trace retention do not establish additional trace sources. A continuation summary need not improve capacity or add knowledge to meet this axis. See MEM-RTE-session-handoff, RT-RTE-asset-admission, MEM-OBJ-decision-trace and RT-RTE-local-checks.

There are no accepted evidenced-absence records warranting a local trace-learning no. Unresolved alternatives therefore remain not-determinable; neither the absence of target execution nor lack of demonstrated benefit becomes a negative. The derived system union can retain claimed yes, but cannot support a complete-value learning conclusion. No event-stream or trajectory source is inferred merely from a tool hook, a serialized record or a multi-step workflow. See MEM-OBJ-wiki, MEM-OBJ-decision-trace and RT-RTE-asset-admission.

Source-read log

No source files were read for this classification. Only the invocation's accepted members and governing contracts were read. No named record ambiguity required an additional frozen-source inspection. All findings retain their evidence layer; no observed operation, causal benefit or complete deployment inventory is asserted.