sign-lang profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the memory profile against the supplied runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow members, resolving the source/index/bundle duplicate identities through the supplied reconciliation. The memory objects are the canonical references for those identities; the separate manifest and checksum records remain usable parts of the valid epistemic aggregate. No source files were read, no replacement records were introduced, and no earlier objection was assumed correct. The supplied profile answers were empty.

The scope is maintained canon and its compiler-replaced products, not the enclosing agent runtime. That is a defensible retained-content boundary: later authoring and compilation can change these files, even though the shipped corpus does not establish agent-acquired experience. Excluding static executable rules, static skill-reference instructions and transient diagnostics does not conceal an established retained trace transformation. External ingestion and host internals are explicitly excluded rather than classified negatively. See MEM-OBJ-canon-source, MEM-OBJ-skill-reference, RT-RTE-import-delegation and MEM-RTE-canon-delivery.

  • Storage substrate: Files and repository storage are supported for the named source inventory; all four output objects are files. Grouping the outputs does not hide a different substrate or opaque provider payload within this boundary. The known assessment is bounded to these objects, not external deployment storage. See MEM-OBJ-canon-source, MEM-OBJ-canon-index, MEM-OBJ-canon-bundle, MEM-OBJ-canon-manifest and MEM-OBJ-bundle-checksum.
  • Representational form: The profile separates interpreted prose, copied summaries and symbolic framing/metadata. The wired basis establishes retained encoding and deterministic structural consumption, not wired external agent interpretation. The infer and edge-provenance parts introduce no additional distributed-parametric form. See MEM-OBJ-canon-source, MEM-OBJ-canon-index, MEM-OBJ-canon-bundle, EPI-OBJ-infer and EPI-OBJ-edge-provenance.
  • Lineage: Other-compiled is supported for projection, assembly and generated build metadata. Keeping original source derivation unresolved is cautious but does not suppress a recorded authoring/import mechanism: “authored outside compilation” does not specify how the content was originally produced. The partial assessment preserves that distinction. See MEM-OBJ-canon-source and RT-RTE-compile-canon.
  • Behavioral authority: Knowledge and instruction are supported at the afforded external interpretation channel, while source status/anchors provide wired routing at deterministic consumers. Neither guidance nor checks imply enforced model compliance. Unknown metadata consumers and host payload semantics remain explicit. The inventory is partial; a local structural-authority omission is retained below. See MEM-RTE-canon-delivery, RT-BAP-canon-guidance, RT-RTE-compile-canon and RT-RTE-source-signals.
  • Write agency: The compiler's admission mechanism is automatic; initiating compilation does not supply a per-content human decision. Source admission is separately unresolved. The profile does not convert governance doctrine into evidence of actual manual approval. See RT-RTE-compile-canon, MEM-OBJ-canon-source and EPI-CLM-provenance-authority.
  • Curation operations: Index selection and anchor reduction support consolidate under the supplied definition, without requiring generated prose. Raw concatenation, overwrite and transient change signals do not independently establish synthesis, evolution or invalidation. The unresolved maintenance unit is coarse but its partial inventory neither asserts absence nor complete enumeration. See MEM-OBJ-canon-index, MEM-OBJ-canon-bundle, RT-RTE-source-signals and RT-RTE-corpus-diff.
  • Read-back direction: The afforded whole-index supply is push, and the requested full-document return is pull. Grouping them in one documented chain leaves the operations and their different triggers explicit. The missing host implementation is not upgraded to wiring or operation. See MEM-RTE-canon-delivery and RT-BAP-canon-guidance.
  • Read-back signal: Coarse is supported for per-invocation supply of the complete index. The requested document ID does not establish identifier-based push. Partial coverage preserves unknown host selectors without inventing an additional route. See MEM-RTE-canon-delivery and MEM-OBJ-canon-index.
  • Trace learning: No accepted record establishes a qualifying automatic trace-fed write and later consumer. No evidenced-absence record supports a local no. The unresolved assessment therefore avoids both an unsupported positive and a system-wide negative. See MEM-OBJ-canon-source, RT-RTE-compile-canon and MEM-RTE-canon-delivery.
  • Trace source: Original source provenance remains unresolved and no qualifying trace-fed write is established. Git baselines for transient diagnostics are not a learning source. Not-determinable, rather than inapplicable, preserves that limitation. See MEM-OBJ-canon-source and RT-RTE-corpus-diff.

All emitted findings remain at wired or afforded strength. Nothing supports observed activation, improvement or causal benefit. The file-level bundle passthrough, missing host resolver, and distinction between structural admission and epistemic acceptance are preserved rather than replaced by stronger interpretations. See RT-RTE-compile-canon, MEM-OBJ-canon-bundle and EPI-RTE-infer-check.

Blockers

none

Limits

  • The partial behavioral-authority inventory does not separately classify retained source document identities as reference criteria for strict link checking and the resulting compiler veto. RT-RTE-compile-canon and RT-RTE-validate-source establish that missing link targets can produce errors in strict mode, whereas non-strict validation warns; MEM-OBJ-canon-source identifies the retained source fields consumed by these checks. This leaves validation/enforcement comparisons at that structural consumer incomplete in the profile. It does not invalidate the emitted routing or afforded guidance findings, and it does not establish enforcement of domain truth or agent actions. Publication can retain this local omission because authority coverage is explicitly partial and the profile makes no complete authority-value or absence claim.