llm-wiki reconciliation
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-reconciliation-report.md
Reconciliation
Record identities and containment
Amendment: EPI-OBJ-reference is superseded by MEM-OBJ-reference-source. Both now identify only the copied references/refDir asset, expressly distinct from the conditional generated Reference concept. Their identity evidence is SRC-1, packages/core/lib/ingest.mjs, with copy-before-lookup and existing-destination behavior; both use packages/core/lib/bundle.mjs to qualify Markdown graph visibility. The corrected epistemic record explicitly names the same raw referent. This identity carries the raw-copy findings, not the excerpt's semantic relation or a uniform raw/derived pair.
Amendment: EPI-RTE-directory-deprecate is superseded by MEM-RTE-directory-deprecation. Both identify caller-selected directory-prefix graph selection, status/generated metadata writes, log/index maintenance and returned counts under SRC-1, packages/core/lib/write.mjs. Their status-write passages support the same route. Both report wired implementation and uninspected operation; bodies remain retrievable. The epistemic disposition function and memory's soft-withdrawal interpretation do not identify different retirements.
Amendment: EPI-RTE-index-refresh is superseded by MEM-RTE-index-refresh. Both identify graph-derived index regeneration, including explicit refresh and maintenance after mutation, under SRC-1, packages/core/lib/indexlog.mjs. Both retain rendering/refresh passages and report wired implementation with uninspected operation. The current epistemic record explicitly separates standalone refresh from mutation callers' action logging. Supersession connects the navigation operation without adding log persistence to every refresh.
Other overlaps are containment or complementary scope, not interchangeable referents:
- EPI-OBJ-concept is the concept-file container. MEM-OBJ-concept-body and MEM-OBJ-concept-metadata separate body and metadata consumers. EPI-OBJ-trust-fields is a declared part of the concept and covers only the trust/lifecycle subset of frontmatter. None replaces another whole referent. Their SRC-1
packages/core/lib/write.mjs,packages/core/lib/bundle.mjsand adapter-display findings leave the container valid alongside the parts; no split supersession is required. - EPI-OBJ-derived-reference now separately declares the conditional generated page, as part of EPI-OBJ-concept. It contains the registration statement, resource pointer and shortened excerpt. It is not identical to the raw asset in MEM-OBJ-reference-source, nor to the whole registration route RT-RTE-source-ingest. SRC-1
packages/core/lib/ingest.mjssupplies the null-lookup condition and excerpt construction. The ordinary concept container remains valid; the new part does not supersede it. - EPI-OBJ-index-log groups the files separately declared as MEM-OBJ-index and MEM-OBJ-log. SRC-1
packages/core/lib/indexlog.mjsandpackages/core/lib/write.mjsdistinguish navigation from operation history. The grouped object does not make those distinct consumers interchangeable, and its findings do not require replacing the valid container. - MEM-RTE-bundle-diagnostics covers the two routines separately identified by EPI-RTE-format-check and EPI-RTE-health-check. SRC-1
packages/core/lib/validate.mjsandpackages/core/lib/lint.mjsestablish different predicates and outputs. Neither individual routine replaces the combined coverage record. EPI-OBJ-health-results is the diagnostic result, not another route. No supersession is required. - MEM-RTE-bundle-migration groups legacy conversion and cloud replication, separated by EPI-RTE-legacy-migration and EPI-RTE-cloud-migration. SRC-1
scripts/migrate.mjsandscripts/migrate-to-feishu.mjssupply different selectors and effects. Neither individual entry is identical to the whole memory record. Its bounded migration request and epistemic's open migration mode both describe caller-selected bulk operations with dry-run/apply controls, not conflicting experimental curricula.
The remaining new objects and maintenance routes are not identities with runtime's core component, rule objects or ordinary read/write/sync routes merely because those routes produce or consume them. In particular, memory's registry, ledger and autosync objects distinguish retained operational state within runtime's broader synchronization account. The attester specification and smoke predicates are also distinct from ordinary retrieval. The claims concern separate propositions: form equivalence, local compliance labelling, requested recording discipline and demo attestation. Workflow declares no records requiring supersession. These comparisons establish no additional record identity.
Disposition of earlier discrepancies
The earlier raw/Reference conflict is no longer present in the supplied findings. RT-RTE-source-ingest already describes an optional Reference; MEM-OBJ-reference-source explains the copied-Markdown/stem-lookup overlap. The current EPI-OBJ-reference confines its referent to the raw asset, while EPI-OBJ-derived-reference declares the previously missing generated part. The epistemic ledger and bounded conclusion now state the null-lookup condition and distinguish preserved new raw bytes from an excerpt that can lose qualifications or differ from an existing destination. Their cited SRC-1 packages/core/lib/ingest.mjs lookup and first-line passages support these distinctions. The reports no longer require a uniform two-artifact output. They retain the uncertainty about the excerpt's semantic relation; that uncertainty is not a disagreement.
The earlier index/log conflict is also no longer present. EPI-RTE-index-refresh now says standalone refresh creates no durable action-log entry and assigns logging to surrounding mutation callers. This agrees with MEM-RTE-index-refresh and MEM-OBJ-log. The records' SRC-1 packages/core/lib/indexlog.mjs render/refresh passages and packages/core/lib/write.mjs Update passage remain attached to different effects. The index identity above therefore carries no unresolved conflict over mandatory logging.
No correction-answer file or declined objection was supplied. These dispositions compare the current findings, not presumed acceptance of an author's explanation. No remaining disagreement between the supplied reports requires an Unresolved conflict: paragraph.
Convergence and integration issues
Consumer input is narrower than stored or core-returned data. RT-RTE-bundle-read distinguishes core return from adapter formatting. MEM-OBJ-concept-metadata and EPI-OBJ-concept independently identify omitted structured provenance and computation bindings in common get displays, citing SRC-1 packages/mcp/lib/tools.mjs and packages/skill/bin/wiki.mjs. Workflow's read handoff describes the same CLI body/backlinks/appendix delivery. Memory's first integration issue therefore qualifies the consumer boundary without contradicting runtime or requiring a duplicate route. File access remains a separate possibility, not proof of delivered provenance.
The MCP fallback issue concerns source doctrine, not a runtime disagreement. Memory's annotations and integration issues distinguish the promise in SRC-1 packages/mcp/lib/instructions.mjs from the inspected get rendering in packages/mcp/lib/tools.mjs. RT-RTE-context-delivery confines its automatic get/create/update appendix finding to CLI; explicit rules calls remain an alternate path. This aligns with RT-CLM-form-equivalence: shared core does not establish identical adapter channels, reload cadence or completeness. Memory and epistemic also preserve truncation and omitted-provenance limits rather than inferring reliable model receipt.
Admission is not semantic acceptance. RT-RTE-concept-create, RT-RTE-concept-update, EPI-OBJ-trust-fields and memory's write annotations converge on caller-asserted confirmation, nonuniversal create gates and historical verification labels that can survive revisions. Their SRC-1 packages/core/lib/write.mjs findings complement workflow's CLI refusal/retry protocol. EPI-CLM-knowledge-recording describes requested investigation and confirmation, not observed evidence-consuming acceptance. Structural diagnostics are optional checks, not an automatically enforced truth gate.
Withdrawal and synchronization have different consumers and effects. Memory's retirement issue connects the deprecation identity above with RT-RTE-remote-sync, MEM-OBJ-wiki-cloud and MEM-OBJ-wiki-registry. Deprecation, deregistration, ledger forgetting and destructive deletion are not synonyms. The records' SRC-1 packages/core/lib/write.mjs, packages/core/lib/registry.mjs and packages/core/lib/feishu.mjs findings do not establish recall of already delivered text. Synchronization and backup recovery concern accessibility and file reconciliation, not semantic endorsement. Cloud migration's Markdown-only selector adds an asset-coverage limit without contradicting memory's replication account.
Declared checks and supplied expectations remain separate from outcomes. EPI-RTE-attester-check and EPI-CLM-attester-demo agree with MEM-OBJ-concept-body on the SQL equality placeholder under SRC-1 examples/demo-bundle/references/attesters/sql-equality.md. The route's claimed implementation conclusion status and doctrine-only ledger architectural status express different vocabularies, not conflicting findings. EPI-OBJ-smoke-checks supplies synthetic expectations under SRC-1 scripts/smoke-test.mjs, not observed passing results.
Memory's remaining integration questions about initialization, actual approval, external synthesis, omitted-provenance reads, backlink following, host compaction and remote outcomes remain bounded uncertainties. Together with RT-BAP-rule-delivery, the reports distinguish persistence and target-side delivery from activation, compliance, learning, reflection, autonomous theory-building and exercised self-improvement. None converts missing observations into an evidenced absence. The boundary's evidence limits apply throughout. This reconciliation made no additional source reads and does not adjudicate analyst support or rewrite their findings.