llm-wiki memory-profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I judged all ten axes of the profile, including their scope, natural units, evidence bases and inventory assessments, against the handed records. I assessed the correction answer and predecessor objection afresh. No source reads or new quotations were needed.
The reconciliation makes MEM-OBJ-reference-source canonical for the raw asset, MEM-RTE-directory-deprecation for retirement, and MEM-RTE-index-refresh for refresh. The conditional EPI-OBJ-derived-reference remains a separate concept part. The profile preserves those distinctions and does not transfer excerpt properties to opaque raw payloads.
| Axis | Judgment |
|---|---|
| storage_substrate | The files, repo and service-object findings have wired support for local retained parts, Git history and Feishu payloads respectively. Their grouping preserves the common substrate without classifying ephemeral graphs or external host storage. The scoped known assessment concerns target-side persistence, not service internals or successful remote operation. See MEM-OBJ-wiki-cloud, MEM-OBJ-wiki-registry, MEM-OBJ-wiki-autosync and RT-RTE-remote-sync. |
| representational_form | Natural-language content at interpreting readers is separated from symbolic fields at fixed code consumers. The opaque raw-resource and backup branch remains not-determinable, so partial coverage does not imply that all imported files share the excerpt's form. See MEM-OBJ-concept-body, MEM-OBJ-concept-metadata, MEM-OBJ-reference-source and EPI-OBJ-derived-reference. |
| lineage | Authored affordances, wired imports and deterministic compilation are supported as separate derivation paths. Unresolved initial provenance is retained locally; generated labels are not treated as authenticated historical authorship. Grouped paths remain distinguishable in their notes and records. See MEM-OBJ-concept-body, MEM-OBJ-concept-metadata, MEM-RTE-bundle-migration and EPI-OBJ-derived-reference. |
| behavioral_authority | Knowledge at the requesting host, ranking at lexical search, instruction through guidance channels, and validation/enforcement at the create gate are independently supported. In the grouped operational-state unit, routing concerns resolver/scheduling/transfer/injection consumers; the validation and veto notes specifically identify ledger-dependent criteria, not every configuration file. These findings describe actual target-side consumer effects without asserting model compliance. See RT-RTE-bundle-read, RT-BAP-rule-delivery, RT-RTE-concept-create and MEM-OBJ-wiki-cloud. |
| write_agency | Automatic admission on ungated agent writes and deterministic copy/derivation paths is distinct from afforded human approval of a displayed proposal. Actual flagged creates and generic caller-controlled initialization remain unresolved. Operation-level invocation is not mistaken for per-content approval or physical I/O for admission control. See RT-RTE-concept-create, RT-RTE-concept-update, RT-RTE-source-ingest and EPI-CLM-knowledge-recording. |
| curation_operations | Wired evolve follows existing-entry revision; wired invalidate follows soft withdrawal with retained history. Retrieval remaining possible does not negate the withdrawal marker. Partial coverage retains unresolved external semantic work and remote transformations without assigning synthesis from a command label or consolidation from index regeneration. See RT-RTE-concept-update, MEM-RTE-directory-deprecation, MEM-RTE-index-refresh and RT-RTE-remote-sync. |
| read_back_direction | Requested content returns support pull; lifecycle injection and automatic scoped CLI appendices support separate push operations. The requested concept body is not counted as push merely because code returns it. Wired tool delivery and afforded file/resource/recovery reads retain distinct bases and notes. See RT-RTE-bundle-read, RT-RTE-context-delivery, MEM-OBJ-reference-source and MEM-OBJ-wiki-cloud. |
| read_back_signal | Coarse lifecycle collection and identifier-based directory-ancestor selection are supported at their respective push operations. The appendix's directory match selects actual retained APPEND text and AGENTS gate sections, unlike a merely displayed identifier. The known inventory now includes both selector families. See RT-RTE-context-delivery and RT-RTE-bundle-read. |
| trace_learning | Not-determinable faithfully retains the unspecified recorded input and semantic producer in caller-mediated experience recording. Operation logs and counters alone do not establish a qualifying automatic trace-fed transformation. No absence record warrants a local no. This uncertainty does not deny the recording affordance or require observed benefit for an architectural finding. See MEM-OBJ-log, MEM-OBJ-wiki-autosync and EPI-CLM-knowledge-recording. |
| trace_source | No original recorded input to a qualifying automatic learning write is established. The not-determinable inventory correctly avoids deriving session/tool/event/trajectory origin from a source path or task discovery, and avoids inapplicability while learning remains unresolved. See MEM-OBJ-reference-source, MEM-OBJ-log and EPI-CLM-knowledge-recording. |
The earlier blocker is repaired. The direction axis now gives the CLI get/create/update appendix its own wired push unit. The signal axis gives its target-directory ancestor selector a wired identifier finding. Both inventory notes and the rationale preserve the distinction between requested content, automatic scoped rule delivery and broad lifecycle injection. The accepted context-delivery record identifies the ancestor-chain rule parts; its bundle-read annotation distinguishes them from the requested concept output. The workflow account independently describes the CLI appendix and its silent-error fallback. Suppression on error and omission of non-gate AGENTS prose qualify delivered coverage, not the supported direction or selector classification.
The records' former raw/excerpt and standalone-refresh/logging discrepancies are resolved without strengthening evidence. Stored provenance remains distinct from displayed content, operational admission from epistemic acceptance, and target-side wiring from observed activation or causal benefit. The profile makes no system-wide learning negative or complete-value assertion over its partial inventories. No remaining finding meets the blocker threshold or requires a publication limit beyond uncertainty already faithfully expressed in the profile.
Blockers
none
Limits
none