OKF Harness profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the memory profile, including their scope, natural units, positive findings, evidence bases and inventory assessments. Judgment uses the handed reports and reconciliation, not target execution or new source evidence. The duplicate epistemic check and graph routes resolve to MEM-RTE-workspace-check and MEM-RTE-graph-report; the profile uses these canonical records.

The correction argument is supported. The read_back_direction axis now separates requested ingest metadata planning (pull, wired) from source/wiki reading assigned to the agent (pull, claimed). Its unit notes and comparison rationale preserve that distinction. RT-RTE-source-ingest supports executable metadata planning, not implementation of the agent's shell reading. RT-RTE-source-reconcile supports the delivered reading obligation separately from pair validation and ledger append. The previous unsupported extension of a wired witness no longer occurs; the unchanged pull direction remains supported for both scopes.

Storage distinguishes local retained files from Git recovery objects. The known assessment is bounded to the recorded object inventory, not all host storage. Opaque source encoding does not make its filesystem substrate unknown. Form and lineage separately retain unresolved source encodings, historical provenance and captured checkpoint payloads. Their grouped positive units do not resolve the opaque alternatives. See MEM-OBJ-source-bytes, MEM-OBJ-url-metadata, MEM-OBJ-wiki-content, MEM-OBJ-backlinks and MEM-OBJ-checkpoint-tree.

Behavioral authority distinguishes answering context, lexical ranking, identity routing, integrity criteria and planner-local enforcement by retained part and consumer. Acknowledged edge identities affect currency bookkeeping, not semantic validation or general evidence eligibility. Retained note semantics remain unresolved because no later semantic consumer is established. Restoration selects a working state without conferring one uniform downstream force on every captured part. See MEM-OBJ-manifest, MEM-OBJ-wiki-metadata, MEM-CLM-currency-evidence, MEM-OBJ-reconciliation-notes and RT-RTE-workspace-recovery.

Write agency keeps software/model admission separate from authorship and physical writes. Explicit permission to retain the particular conversation answer supports manual admission at the claimed protocol layer; generic checkpoint and acknowledgment callers do not establish human control. Curation retains claimed revision and withdrawal without treating an instruction to synthesize as evidence of a particular meaning-changing transformation. See RT-RTE-source-ingest, RT-RTE-source-reconcile, RT-RTE-evidence-answer and MEM-OBJ-wiki-content.

The remaining direction units preserve requested pull at their respective wired or afforded bases. Automatic excerpt selection inside a retrieval request is not a separate unsolicited push. Requested read identities and lexical matching therefore establish no push-selection signal. The unestablished note consumer prevents a whole-inventory inapplicable signal assessment; that uncertainty is retained rather than silently excluded. See RT-RTE-direct-retrieval, RT-RTE-evidence-answer, MEM-RTE-graph-report and MEM-OBJ-reconciliation-notes.

Trace learning and trace source do not assert a system-wide negative. Human-admitted answer retention does not meet automatic trace-fed admission. Arbitrary source content and unresolved caller/derivation control do not establish a qualifying trace write or its original input class. The records supply no bounded absence licensing a controlled trace-learning no finding. Consequently the unresolved axis assessments, rather than absence or whole-axis inapplicability, are warranted. See RT-RTE-evidence-answer, MEM-OBJ-source-bytes, MEM-OBJ-checkpoint-judgment and RT-RTE-workspace-recovery.

No emitted finding claims observed operation or causal benefit. The remaining scoped uncertainties are expressed in the profile's own assessments and notes; they are not additional publication defects. No material unsupported value, false complete-coverage assessment or unresolved report conflict was found.

Source-read log: none. No ambiguity required inspection beyond the supplied accepted members.

Blockers

none

Limits

none