SkillWeaver profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the profile against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow findings. The review covers each emitted value, its evidence basis, its unit scope and the axis inventory assessment. Reconciliation supersedes the four duplicate epistemic library-object declarations with the memory declarations; the profile uses those canonical objects. The selected episode, success judgment and benchmark results remain distinct parts of the trace inventory. No source read was needed, and this verification adds no evidence.

  • Storage substrate: files and in-memory structures are supported for skill bodies, documentation, metadata, semantic text, experience/diagnostic artifacts, scores and the optional embedding cache. The grouped units share those substrates and coverage. The cache is not a vector database, and provider parameters and website state are explicitly outside this memory boundary. The scoped local inventory supports known (MEM-OBJ-code, MEM-OBJ-docstring, MEM-OBJ-metadata, MEM-OBJ-semantic-knowledge, MEM-OBJ-traces, RT-CMP-embed, EPI-RTE-score-retention).
  • Representational form: symbolic procedures, signatures and structured fields are separated from model-interpreted text and dense parametric access representations. The cache's numerical form does not imply changed model weights. Screenshots receive no invented controlled form, and arbitrary semantic payloads remain unaudited. These unresolved parts support the axis's partial assessment (MEM-OBJ-code, MEM-OBJ-docstring, MEM-OBJ-traces, MEM-OBJ-semantic-knowledge, MEM-RTE-embedding-selection).
  • Lineage: the profile distinguishes practice-derived skills, imported initial content, programmatic metadata and selective serialization. Raw recording and deterministic episode rendering retain separate derivation findings. Initial authorship and embedding provenance remain unresolved rather than inheriting a known subsequent path. The afforded embedding derivation does not claim activation of an agent consumer (MEM-OBJ-code, MEM-OBJ-metadata, MEM-OBJ-traces, EPI-RTE-trajectory-format, RT-CMP-embed).
  • Behavioral authority: descriptions supply knowledge and relevance-ranking inputs. Prior source, documentation, semantic context and experience feed durable updates at synthesis, supporting learning authority there independently of downstream effects. Metadata supplies enforced presentation/inclusion, routing and relative practice ranking; it does not enforce a universal execution barrier. Episode evidence and scores support judgment/reporting. Direct executable effects alone do not establish one of the controlled forces, and unknown export or external continuation consumers remain unresolved. The optional dot-product selector retains its afforded ranking basis (MEM-OBJ-docstring, MEM-OBJ-semantic-knowledge, MEM-OBJ-metadata, RT-RTE-skill-admission, RT-BAP-library-execution, MEM-RTE-embedding-selection, EPI-RTE-success-check, EPI-RTE-score-retention).
  • Write agency: synthesis/merge admission, builder counters/resets, reference cleanup and recording are automatic mechanisms, not merely physical saves or model authorship. Optional cache insertion remains afforded. Generic initial-content and override callers do not establish human approval; prefix selection at read time does not classify checkpoint replacement admission. Partial coverage preserves these distinctions (RT-RTE-skill-admission, MEM-OBJ-metadata, EPI-RTE-tested-label, MEM-OBJ-traces, MEM-RTE-embedding-selection).
  • Curation operations: same-name revision supports evolve, and deterministic reduction of retained experience to a selected episode supports consolidate even though raw artifacts remain. Arbitrary generated claims cannot be classified as synthesis merely because the prompt requests generalization. Test resets and transient disabling do not establish durable invalidation. The unresolved semantic edge is retained in the partial inventory (MEM-OBJ-code, EPI-RTE-skill-merge, MEM-OBJ-traces, EPI-RTE-trajectory-format).
  • Read-back direction: established native, builder and adapter chains support request-directed pull. Benchmark aggregation/reload remains afforded at the enclosing route rather than upgraded by local output wiring. The revised capability-only unit emits no direction and retains missing later-consumer invocation explicitly, so the axis is partial (RT-RTE-native-task, RT-RTE-explore-practice, RT-RTE-browser-use, RT-RTE-benchmark-evaluation, MEM-RTE-embedding-selection, MEM-OBJ-docstring, MEM-OBJ-traces).
  • Read-back signal: signal is locally inapplicable to the established request-directed chains. Relevance judgment, name matching and delivery within those requests are not separate push operations. The unresolved capability-only alternatives prevent axis-wide inapplicability; the axis now expresses not-determinable without a positive signal finding. This preserves the incomplete direction inventory rather than asserting complete pull-only coverage (RT-RTE-native-task, RT-RTE-browser-use, MEM-RTE-embedding-selection, MEM-OBJ-docstring, MEM-OBJ-traces).
  • Trace learning: automatic episode-to-code/documentation writes and trace-conditioned persistent counters both have later behavior-shaping consumers. Their wired yes findings require neither observed benefit nor proof that the named skill executed. Unknown initial and external mutations do not inherit those findings (RT-RTE-skill-admission, RT-BAP-library-execution, MEM-OBJ-metadata, EPI-RTE-test-check, EPI-RTE-tested-label).
  • Trace source: procedural synthesis consumes a linked episode with execution feedback, supporting trajectories and tool-traces; the counter predicate consumes last-action source/result fields, supporting tool-traces locally. Metadata event labels do not establish event-stream inputs, and generated reasoning alone does not establish session logs. Unknown mutation origins remain unresolved (MEM-OBJ-traces, EPI-RTE-trajectory-format, RT-RTE-skill-admission, EPI-RTE-test-check, EPI-RTE-tested-label).

The prior blocker is resolved in the handed profile: the unsupported capability-only pull finding is removed, direction coverage is partial, signal coverage is not determinable, and the rationale preserves the same qualification. I assessed that change and its dependent passages rather than accepting the author's answer as proof. No remaining comparison finding depends on complete classification of those alternatives.

The current reports agree on the syntactic test shortcut, reduced builder trajectory and absence of an invariant final checker veto. The profile preserves these distinctions. Local benchmark parts do not upgrade the defective enclosing invocation, and no finding asserts observed operation or causal benefit. The remaining uncertainty is already expressed in the affected units and assessments; it is not an additional publication defect.

Blockers

none

Limits

none