OpenSage profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes, their natural units, findings, evidence bases and coverage assessments against the handed analyst records, resolving supersessions through the supplied reconciliation. No target source was read. The previous verification and the profile author's correction answer were assessed as arguments, not binding judgments. No refusal of this verification was supplied.

The profile separates accumulated memory from static shipped instructions, ordinary inference weights and task-source graphs. All axes remain partial. Opaque service payloads, live retention, trainer updates and extension alternatives remain included uncertainties. The emitted findings do not assert observed activation, improved capacity, causal benefit or system-complete absence. Grouped witnesses retain their named local scopes rather than establishing exhaustive inventories.

• Storage substrate: Files and process state are supported by MEM-OBJ-traj, MEM-OBJ-compacted-content, MEM-OBJ-checkpoint-selectors, RT-OBJ-agent-definition and WF-RTE-devops-grading. The process-memory service handle in MEM-CMP-memory-service is not used to classify its opaque payload or infer a retrieval route.
• Representational form: Interpreted prose, fixed-rule selectors and unresolved binary payloads are separated. Consultation explanation and parsed decisions retain distinct forms under EPI-OBJ-validation-reasoning and EPI-OBJ-validation-decision. The prior image objection is repaired: the profile now has separate known symbolic-wrapper and natural-language rejection-notice units. MEM-OBJ-image-parts identifies the wrapper and readable notices; MEM-RTE-image-retention establishes the notice's instruction to resubmit smaller images. The binary payload remains not-determinable. The dependent rationale preserves these distinctions and does not let a display notice classify consumed image bytes.
• Lineage: Software seeds/control metadata and deterministic prefixes are distinguished from model trace extraction, agent-authored entries and imported tool content. MEM-RTE-wiki-maintenance, MEM-RTE-output-reduction, RT-OBJ-agent-instruction and MEM-OBJ-hook-context support the named paths. Local import does not resolve ultimate provenance; initial writers and per-hook/image origins remain uncertain. The partial inventory's omitted findings/checkpoint derivations are retained as the limit below, now also exposed in the profile rationale.
• Behavioral authority: Retained experience at summary-update consumers and derived context at later models have separate learning and knowledge effects under MEM-OBJ-compacted-content, MEM-RTE-output-reduction and MEM-BAP-summary-authority. Standing child directions are supported by RT-BAP-dynamic-instruction. Prior findings provide duplicate criteria and a veto under EPI-RTE-finding-check and EPI-RTE-finding-write, not truth acceptance. Checkpoint/stage selectors support routing; grade and score consumers support bounded reporting/ranking under WF-RTE-devops-grading and EPI-RTE-cybench-disposition.
• Write agency: Software/model admission is automatic at the named mechanisms, independently of startup, authorship and physical I/O. RT-RTE-create-subagent, MEM-RTE-checkpoint-resume, MEM-RTE-wiki-maintenance and EPI-RTE-finding-write support those witnesses. Other filesystem writers and external replacement possibilities remain unresolved. No explicit per-content human decision is inferred from generic caller identity, and no automatic-only system claim is made.
• Curation operations: History/tool compression and explore quota fallback support consolidation under RT-RTE-history-compaction, MEM-RTE-output-reduction and MEM-RTE-explore-handoff. Raw retention or possible fidelity defects do not defeat that classification. Duplicate suppression supports dedup under EPI-RTE-finding-write, without implying withdrawal of an older contradicted claim. Wiki revision/removal remains claimed rather than wired under EPI-CLM-knowledge-policy. No unsupported synthesis is emitted.
• Read-back direction: Requested file access, resume and consultation are pull operations. Automatic folded-history supply, peer delivery and benchmark prompt inclusion are separately push operations. MEM-RTE-checkpoint-resume, MEM-RTE-history-consultation, EPI-RTE-finding-delivery, MEM-RTE-explore-handoff and MEM-RTE-findings-resume support this operation-level distinction. Requested returns are not additional pushes merely because code delivers them.
• Read-back signal: Branch/identity matching and temporal-range selection remain separate identifier and coarse witnesses in MEM-OBJ-compacted-content and the memory annotation on RT-RTE-history-compaction. Availability and budget filtering remain coarse; inferred-intent model selection has its own inferred-judgment witness in MEM-RTE-output-reduction. Requested filenames and saved-output IDs are not independent evidence of identifier-based push. Uninspected alternatives do not establish absence of lexical or embedding selection.
• Trace learning: Compaction, retained tool-summary/prefix updates and explore quota fallback have automatic trace-fed production, retention and later consumers under RT-RTE-history-compaction, MEM-RTE-output-reduction and MEM-RTE-explore-handoff. These support local wired yes findings without requiring novel knowledge or observed improvement. Raw checkpointing/export alone is not qualifying learning; uncertain branches do not become local or system-wide no findings.
• Trace source: The qualifying model-summary paths consume recorded conversational turns and tool feedback; deterministic tool previews retain their distinct tool-only input classification. MEM-OBJ-compacted-content, MEM-RTE-output-reduction and MEM-RTE-explore-handoff support those findings. Event serialization does not establish event-stream origin, nor do successive turns alone establish trajectories. Unknown qualifying updates retain unknown original inputs.

Canonical findings and tool-summary objects, and the canonical reduction route, are used after supersession. Finding check/write/delivery remain separate functions: their internal wired witnesses do not upgrade the unresolved shipped invocation in MEM-RTE-finding-admission. The scoped registration differences between reports are not contradictory completeness claims. Pin-read failure, non-cumulative summary replacement, image-copy uncertainty and external trainer adoption remain bounded mechanism qualifications, not evidence against the positive classifications.

Blockers

none

Limits

• The partial lineage inventory omits recorded caller-finding and appended-analysis derivations in MEM-OBJ-findings and EPI-RTE-finding-write, and the model-generation/parsing/serialization path in MEM-OBJ-vulnerability-findings and MEM-RTE-findings-resume. The profile rationale now explicitly acknowledges these omissions. The emitted authored, imported, compiled and trace-extracted witnesses remain supported; withhold object-complete lineage comparisons for findings and vulnerability checkpoints. This local inventory gap does not change a supported system-level value or imply complete coverage.