Cortex profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I judged all ten axes of the memory profile against the handed reports, including scope, natural units, evidence bases, emitted findings and inventory assessments. Reconciliation resolves the duplicate note, edge and retirement records to their memory declarations; the profile uses those canonical records. I assessed the supplied correction answer and earlier objection afresh. No frozen-source reads, new records or replacement classifications were needed.
| Axis | Judgment and support |
|---|---|
| storage_substrate | Repository notes/receipts, relational state, process corpus cache, KV replies/proposals and local curation files support the emitted values. Relational edge rows do not imply a separate graph database. Administrative storage uncertainty prevents complete enumeration, not these witnesses. See MEM-OBJ-notes, MEM-OBJ-mirror, MEM-OBJ-note-edges, MEM-OBJ-cached-answer, MEM-RTE-local-curation and RT-RTE-proposal-admission. |
| representational_form | Interpreted prose and localized fixed-rule fields are distinguished by consumption path. Numerical scores and graph weights are symbolic, not distributed parameters. Provider inference does not establish accumulated parametric Cortex memory. See MEM-OBJ-notes, MEM-OBJ-bubble-body, MEM-OBJ-bubble-state, MEM-OBJ-note-scores and RT-CMP-reader. |
| lineage | Direct submissions, imports, compiled representations and usage-derived state retain different derivation warrants. Claimed host extraction is not upgraded to implementation or observation. Initial authorship and maintenance-log provenance remain unresolved. See MEM-RTE-local-curation, MEM-OBJ-mirror, MEM-OBJ-cached-answer, MEM-RTE-usage-selection and RT-RTE-groundskeeper-maintenance. |
| behavioral_authority | Knowledge, ranking, routing, enforcement, validation and learning have recorded consumers and effects. Access history at update consumers is separate from derived metadata at ranking consumers. Private-host standing instruction force remains unresolved; shipped static instructions are excluded. See MEM-BAP-selection-metadata, MEM-RTE-usage-selection, RT-RTE-guest-mediation, RT-RTE-proposal-admission and RT-RTE-production-jobs. |
| write_agency | Software admission and explicit human attention/pin decisions have separate warrants. Claimed automatic maintenance filing and claimed human proposal review are separate mechanisms, not universal server policy. Generic credentialed callers and batch flags do not resolve per-content human control. See MEM-OBJ-note-scores, MEM-RTE-local-curation, RT-RTE-trusted-write and RT-RTE-groundskeeper-maintenance, including their memory annotations. |
| curation_operations | Existing-entry revision, withdrawal from open working context, time decay/expiry and hotter pin overrides support the wired findings. Groundskeeper consolidation, correction and historical withdrawal remain claimed. Nomination, relocation, collision checks and generated answers alone do not establish deletion, deduplication or synthesis. See MEM-OBJ-bubble-state, MEM-OBJ-note-scores, MEM-OBJ-cached-answer, MEM-RTE-retirement-nomination and RT-RTE-groundskeeper-maintenance. |
| read_back_direction | Requested returns are pull; automatic selection and supply to downstream context/reader consumers support push within those chains. A requested return is not counted again merely because software delivers it. Groundskeeper acquisition remains claimed pull. See RT-RTE-reader-answer, RT-RTE-context-delivery and RT-RTE-groundskeeper-maintenance. |
| read_back_signal | Boot availability/age/bands/budgets, project and graph-endpoint matches, and question-token selection support coarse, identifier and inferred-lexical findings. Each names the trigger, selector inputs and selected retained parts. The corrected groundskeeper unit emits no finding and gives a local pull-only inapplicability reason; unresolved administrative selection remains separate. See MEM-OBJ-router, MEM-OBJ-bubble-state, MEM-OBJ-note-edges, RT-RTE-context-delivery and RT-RTE-reader-answer. |
| trace_learning | The automatic access-to-score/graph-to-later-context chain supports wired yes. The host log-to-page/digest chain supports a separate claimed yes. Neither establishes improved capacity; no unsupported local or system-wide no is emitted. See MEM-RTE-usage-selection and RT-RTE-groundskeeper-maintenance. |
| trace_source | Serving rows record tool activity and discrete runtime access observations, supporting tool-traces and event-streams for the qualifying usage update. These origins follow recorded content, not a serialization label. Groundskeeper daily prose does not establish conversational turns, tool results or trajectories, and its original source remains unresolved. See MEM-OBJ-note-access and MEM-RTE-usage-selection. |
The correction removes the earlier unsupported judgment-based push finding and the groundskeeper coarse finding. Its unit, axis note and comparison rationale now consistently distinguish requested acquisition from write-side fact selection. RT-RTE-groundskeeper-maintenance, its memory annotation and the workflow account support that distinction. The earlier blocker is resolved, not merely deferred to a synthesis caveat.
The workflow's health gate, non-atomic filing, absorption-marker mismatch and conditional digest delivery qualify execution and recovery. They do not refute the explicitly claimed retained-output path, nor establish an additional push selector. No observation or causal benefit is inferred from that procedure.
Some units group several objects or mechanisms sharing controlled findings. Their notes and canonical records preserve the consequential content/metadata, consumer, derivation and evidence-layer distinctions; the grouping does not emit a stronger existence or completeness conclusion. All axes remain partial, with unresolved included initialization, provenance and administrative alternatives retained rather than silently excluded. Those uncertainties are faithfully scoped, not evidenced absences or unresolved publication defects. I found no material unsupported value or complete-coverage assertion requiring correction.
Blockers
none
Limits
none