Amanuensis profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I checked all ten axes of the memory profile, including their unit scopes, findings, evidence bases, unresolved alternatives and inventory assessments. I resolved the five object supersessions through the handed reconciliation: the memory declarations own claims, findings, explanations, research results and file standing; the narrower epistemic routes remain usable. No frozen-source read was needed. The handed profile answers were empty and supplied no argument to adopt.
The profile's accumulated-memory boundary is appropriate. Static skill instructions and provider parameters are not counted as retained experience. Included but untraced maintenance, evaluation, adapter and driver alternatives remain visible rather than disappearing behind the inspected principal reader. None of the eight partial axes asserts complete system coverage. The two unresolved trace axes assert neither absence nor inapplicability.
Storage, form and lineage
The SQLite finding is supported by the declared retained objects, including MEM-OBJ-claims, MEM-OBJ-codebase-brief and MEM-OBJ-learning-policy. The profile does not mistake relational links for graph storage. Registered prose and projected views support files through MEM-OBJ-prose-artifacts and RT-RTE-docs-publication. Storage checkpoints are bounded by the persistence and recovery account in RT-RTE-survey-cycle, including the final-session ordering caveat. These are implementation findings, not successful deployed checkpoints.
The form axis separates interpretive bodies from symbolic keys, validity, selection and evaluation fields. Arbitrary configuration internals remain unresolved rather than being classified from their JSON envelope or upgraded to parametric memory. The grouped units preserve those principal distinctions, but leave a local body-level inventory omission described under Limits.
Authored survey content, imported carry/research evidence, compiled briefs/review aggregates/views and terminal-artifact extraction have distinct recorded derivation paths. In particular, MEM-OBJ-learning-lessons distinguishes extracted artifact states from a separately supplied proposition. The profile does not turn trace-extracted lineage into a learning conclusion. Initial ledger provenance and opaque configuration derivation remain unresolved beside their known subsequent transformations.
Authority and admission
Knowledge at later readers is supported by MEM-RTE-knowledge-revision, MEM-RTE-explanation-cycle and MEM-RTE-brief-delivery. The standing-guidance finding is explicitly afforded at the answering host through MEM-BAP-recorded-standing; it does not claim enforced answer compliance or count the static opening as accumulated memory.
Validation and enforcement concern retained evidence relationships, slot dispositions, verdicts and predecessor/configuration state at actual code gates. EPI-RTE-claim-admission, EPI-RTE-explanation-selection, EPI-RTE-review-aggregation and RT-RTE-policy-admission support local checks and vetoes, not universal semantic certification. Ranking has concrete retained inputs in heat, demand and scored candidate text. Routing has concrete selectors in validity, disposition, stale flags and task/lens metadata. The profile keeps those effects separate from interpreting the selected prose. Unknown future policy interpretation is not upgraded by the active reader's label.
For write agency, the afforded model-directed survey and wired software admission/compilation witnesses are kept distinct. RT-RTE-survey-cycle, MEM-RTE-knowledge-revision and MEM-RTE-brief-delivery support automatic mechanisms without treating workflow initiation as per-content approval. Generic caller contributions and unresolved initialization do not inherit those witnesses. Decision actor and preference confirmation fields remain unresolved rather than supplying an unsupported manual value. The finding does not establish that manual control is absent.
Curation and read-back
Evolution and invalidation follow implemented successor, effective-body, interval-closure and withdrawal mechanisms, including EPI-RTE-claim-withdrawal. Consolidation follows persisted reduction of candidates and combination of recorded judgments, not a command name or hash check. Promotion follows draft/candidate admission into current or active authority in RT-RTE-decision-admission and RT-RTE-policy-admission. Missing body-specific semantic evidence prevents a synthesis finding; the profile does not invent deduplication or decay from uniqueness checks or response omission.
Requested readers support pull. The design-packet operation in MEM-RTE-brief-delivery supports automatic supply of retained task context to the lens consumer within a larger requested workflow. These are distinct operations, not double counting every requested tool response as push. The push-signal findings identify actual forced candidate matches, lexical scoring and coarse item/section filters along that retained-candidate-to-packet chain. The upstream selection inputs are not merely a request identifier. The forced-before-optional-mode-filter qualification survives. Other packet and policy consumers remain unresolved, so neither direction nor signal claims completeness.
Trace-fed updates and coverage
MEM-OBJ-learning-lessons, MEM-OBJ-learning-policy and RT-RTE-policy-admission establish extraction, authored proposals, durable configuration and internal readback, but leave configuration semantics and a later behavior-shaping consumer unresolved. No positive trace-learning value is established merely by calling that representation active. Conversely, lack of observed benefit is not used as a condition for wiring. Usage ranking, retained review results and prescribed packaging criticism do not by themselves close the qualifying automatic trace-fed write and later-consumer chain. WF-RTE-adversarial-review establishes retained criticisms and prescribed subsequent use, not a classified original trace source for such a chain.
The trace axes therefore appropriately retain unresolved inventories without a system-wide negative. No accepted absence record licenses a local learning no. Terminal session labels do not alone distinguish conversational logs, tool traces, event streams or trajectories. The profile withholds those source values rather than treating every symbolic event or session ID as evidence of a particular origin. Further route classification could change these unresolved axes, but the present uncertainty does not imply absence.
Blockers
none
Limits
- The form inventory in memory-profile does not separately carry the natural-language task objective, constraints and inherited statements of MEM-OBJ-codebase-brief, or the proposition/provenance text of MEM-OBJ-learning-lessons, into its natural-language unit; those objects are cited there for symbolic fields instead. These supported body parts remain incompletely enumerated. This does not invalidate the emitted natural-language or symbolic values, and the axis already says partial. Consumers should withhold a complete object-by-object form inventory or form-prevalence comparison; the supported system-level form findings remain valid.