Nuggets profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked every axis, unit assessment and positive finding in the memory profile against the supplied declarations and annotations. This judgment concerns support and classification, not successful operation. No target-source files were read, no new evidence was added and no target code was executed. The supplied profile answers are empty; no refusal was supplied.

The profile uses the canonical task object MEM-OBJ-task-summary and migration route MEM-RTE-legacy-migration after the handed reconciliation's supersessions. The remaining wording dispute does not change a value: RT-RTE-memory-context and MEM-RTE-compaction-extract agree that the final twenty tool-use blocks are selected before filtering for file operations.

  • Storage substrate: Files and process RAM are supported for the named fact, metadata, local-map, Markdown and cron parts. Reconstructed HRR state is RAM, not a vector database. The profile does not infer host snapshot serialization from readable extension details. See MEM-OBJ-nugget-facts, MEM-OBJ-session-facts, MEM-OBJ-promoted-memory, RT-OBJ-cron-jobs and RT-CMP-hrr-vectors.
  • Representational form: The units distinguish interpreted values, fixed-rule keys/counters/control fields and distributed numerical state. Splitting captured paths by consumption accounts for their symbolic capture and later interpreted model context. Parametric form does not assert provider-weight training. See EPI-OBJ-file-path, MEM-OBJ-hit-metadata and EPI-RTE-recall-decode.
  • Lineage: Authored proposals, trace extraction, imported migration/reload paths and compiled numerical/snapshot/Markdown parts have recorded producers. Known reload and rendering paths do not resolve original authorship; the profile retains separate unknown initial-content units. See MEM-RTE-fact-mutation, MEM-RTE-hook-capture, MEM-RTE-context-rebuild and MEM-RTE-legacy-migration.
  • Behavioral authority: The seven emitted values follow named consumers and effects. Facts supply knowledge; retained preferences and scheduled prompts supply directions; experience feeds automatic artifact updates. Retained content and numerical features rank recall. Keys and scheduling state route consumption. Hit metadata supplies promotion admissibility and an enforced threshold, not truth acceptance. Exported fact context remains afforded rather than wired external reading. See RT-BAP-facts-prompt, RT-BAP-scheduled-prompt, EPI-RTE-recall-score, MEM-OBJ-hit-metadata and RT-RTE-memory-promotion.
  • Write agency: Automatic admission is supported for the classified model/code mechanisms. Neither human input authorship nor migration launch establishes per-content human approval. Generic callers, initial files and external checkpoint production remain unresolved. See MEM-RTE-fact-mutation, MEM-RTE-hook-capture, MEM-RTE-legacy-migration and RT-RTE-schedule-admission.
  • Curation operations: Replacement, optional oldest-entry eviction, selected-text reduction and threshold placement support evolve, decay, consolidate and promote respectively. The extraction counterexample does not establish synthesis. Key collisions alone do not establish deduplication, and physical deletion without retained withdrawal history does not establish invalidate. These are not emitted system-wide negatives. See MEM-RTE-fact-mutation, MEM-RTE-compaction-extract, EPI-RTE-preference-capture and RT-RTE-memory-promotion.
  • Read-back direction: Requested recall/list/display is pull. Lifecycle selection followed by unsolicited fact injection and timer-selected job prompts establishes push. Returning a requested decoded answer adds no independent push. External Markdown loading and opaque host continuation remain unresolved. See MEM-RTE-recall-selection, MEM-RTE-context-rebuild and RT-RTE-proactive-turn.
  • Read-back signal: Tool-result identity actually selects the retained snapshot payload for replay; it is not merely an identifier attached to a requested file. Availability/category/order budgets and clock eligibility support coarse selection. The profile correctly keeps requested lexical/numerical recall outside push-signal findings. See MEM-RTE-context-rebuild, MEM-OBJ-session-facts and RT-RTE-proactive-turn.
  • Trace learning: Automatic fragment/path/task writes have retained outputs and later context or requested-recall consumers. The usage-counter unit also qualifies: recall activity changes durable metadata consumed to determine later context placement. This finding does not require new knowledge, observed improvement or an exercised external Markdown reader. Ordinary extension recall's missing session ID remains an activation qualification. Precompaction-only path durability remains partial rather than being upgraded by the separately persistent task excerpt. See MEM-RTE-hook-capture, MEM-RTE-compaction-extract, MEM-OBJ-hit-metadata and RT-RTE-memory-promotion.
  • Trace source: Conversational fragments and selected user messages support session-logs; captured tool-call paths support tool-traces; discrete recall access activity supports event-streams for the counter update. Callback wrapping and session markers do not manufacture additional origins or trajectories. Unknown proposal derivations and host alternatives remain unresolved. See MEM-RTE-hook-capture, MEM-RTE-compaction-extract, MEM-OBJ-hit-metadata and EPI-RTE-recall-score.

All ten axis assessments are partial, consistently with the included opaque continuation alternatives and local unresolved provenance, control, durability or loading facts. Grouped known units share the classification and coverage of their named parts; they do not upgrade those unresolved alternatives. Wired witnesses establish implemented mechanisms, not activation, reliable delivery, factual warrant or benefit. The exported-context authority finding retains its weaker afforded basis. I found no unsupported emitted value, false bounded absence, unjustified inapplicability or claim of complete inventory coverage requiring a blocker. Faithfully expressed uncertainty is not an additional verification limit.

Blockers

none

Limits

none