auto-harness profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the memory profile for support, evidence basis, natural units and inventory coverage against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow members. I also checked the supplied reconciliation and the empty profile answers. Reconciliation makes the memory declaration of the learning log canonical; the profile uses MEM-OBJ-learnings, not its superseded epistemic counterpart. The suite container remains valid alongside its three operative parts. No unresolved cross-report conflict changes a classification.

The scope is the retained experiment loop, including through-use candidate revisions, not every state holder in the runtime. Excluding unchanged shipped instructions, ordinary task/session accumulation and external host/provider internals agrees with the records. In particular, BIRD diagnostic previews do not establish a retained model-window checkpoint, and ordinary tau history does not establish cross-task memory; see RT-RTE-bird-session, RT-RTE-tau-task and their memory annotations. These exclusions do not conceal an accepted qualifying local memory route.

  • Storage substrate and representational form: The known inventories are supported within that scope. Local diagnostic, log, evaluation and split objects are files; candidate revisions have an afforded file path and prescribed Git retention. The profile does not upgrade prescribed commits to observed storage. It separates trace text from structured fields and candidate Python execution from model interpretation of embedded directions. Grouping local objects with the same substrate does not hide an unresolved substrate. Supporting records include MEM-OBJ-traces, MEM-OBJ-suite, MEM-OBJ-task-split, RT-OBJ-agent-code, RT-OBJ-agent-instructions and RT-BAP-candidate-runtime.
  • Lineage: Imported diagnostic copies, feedback-derived outcome/membership data and prescribed coding-agent authorship have distinct warrants. The partial axis preserves upstream payload uncertainty and the unresolved origin of supplied history numbers and threshold configuration. A known local serialization path does not resolve those origins; see MEM-RTE-trace-retention, MEM-OBJ-train-results, MEM-OBJ-results, MEM-OBJ-suite-threshold and RT-RTE-candidate-revision.
  • Behavioral authority: The profile distinguishes diagnostic evidence and update use, downstream task routing, gate criteria and vetoes, and instruction delivery. Its learning findings name update consumers rather than assuming that every diagnostic object has learning authority. Validation and enforcement apply within the invoked gate, not to all commits. Unknown note reuse, arbitrary revised-code effects and unconsumed diagnostics remain unresolved rather than receiving invented force. These distinctions follow RT-RTE-gate-admission, RT-BAP-history-gate, RT-BAP-candidate-runtime, MEM-OBJ-suite-tasks, MEM-OBJ-suite-last-results and MEM-OBJ-learnings.
  • Write agency: Automatic adapter/gate admissions and prescribed computational editing are supported at their separate wired and claimed bases. Caller-supplied score content, configuration origin and preserved prior contents remain separate unresolved admission mechanisms. Starting preparation is not treated as human approval of every later write. The partial assessment is warranted by RT-RTE-prepare-baseline, RT-RTE-iteration-record, RT-RTE-candidate-revision and the suite-part records.
  • Curation operations: Suite promotion raises future evaluation salience and revises existing membership; diagnostic replacement/merge revises retained entries, and raw-job deletion supplies the bounded decay finding. Requested candidate revision remains claimed evolution. The profile does not infer consolidation or synthesis from extraction, copying or a learning label. Its unresolved semantic-transformation unit and partial axis preserve the limit of MEM-RTE-trace-retention, MEM-OBJ-suite-tasks, MEM-OBJ-suite-last-results and RT-RTE-candidate-revision.
  • Read-back direction and signal: Gate/split/import requests and foreground diagnostic reads are pull. Supplying revised instruction constants during task-model context construction is a distinct coarse push, not a second label for the requested import. The profile names its trigger, selector input and selected retained part. It correctly withholds identifier-based push from task IDs on requested data. Unknown learning-log and diagnostic reuse keep both axes partial; local signal inapplicability is confined to the assessed pull operations. Support is supplied by RT-BAP-candidate-runtime, RT-OBJ-agent-instructions, RT-BAP-history-gate, MEM-RTE-trace-retention and MEM-OBJ-learnings.
  • Trace learning and trace source: Reward-fed suite/split writes produce durable controls consumed by later gate/runner invocations. That wired chain meets this axis's definition without establishing improved capacity. Trace-responsive candidate revision has only afforded support, despite wired downstream imports. Its dialogue and tool-feedback source findings retain that basis. Local membership updates consume execution feedback, supporting tool-traces; opaque BIRD payloads and field labels do not establish additional trajectory or event-stream inputs. The missing learning-log consumer and unresolved caller/upstream alternatives remain in the partial inventories. See MEM-OBJ-suite-tasks, MEM-OBJ-task-split, MEM-OBJ-traces, RT-RTE-candidate-revision and RT-RTE-iteration-record.

The emitted positives and their bases are supported. The two known axes concern resolved local substrate/form inventories, not observed operation; the other eight retain unresolved included mechanisms. No system-wide absence, complete external coverage, observed learning or causal benefit is implied. The recorded uncertainties are faithful qualifications already carried by the profile values, not additional verification findings. I found no material defect requiring repair and no local unresolved defect requiring a publication limit. No source files were read: this judgment uses the supplied accepted records only and introduces no replacement record or quotation.

Blockers

none

Limits

none