Kherad profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes of the memory profile against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow records, resolving duplicate routes through reconciliation. The review covered each emitted value and basis, its natural unit, and both unit and axis coverage. The earlier verification and author answer were assessed as arguments, not accepted conclusions. No source reread was necessary; this judgment adds no evidence or records.

Storage and form distinguish retained Git knowledge from relational access/task state, and readable prose from symbolic metadata and dense numerical retrieval payloads. The repository and relational findings have implementation support. The embedding payload is classified at its cosine-distance consumer rather than from its readable snippet or provider model. Grouped local units share the stated substrate or form; opaque remote retention is separately unresolved. See MEM-OBJ-source-pages, MEM-OBJ-compiled-docs, MEM-OBJ-source-mirror, MEM-OBJ-search-index, MEM-OBJ-chunk-content, MEM-OBJ-chunk-embedding, MEM-OBJ-session-content and MEM-OBJ-message-parts.

Lineage separates administrator-authored methods, imported content, local compilation/copy/index derivations and conversational capture. Known local derivations do not settle initial corpus, caller or upstream provenance. Capturing message parts is not presented as extracting a standing lesson. The partial inventory preserves those distinctions. See RT-RTE-admin-configuration, RT-RTE-ingest-document, RT-RTE-source-authoring, RT-RTE-remote-pull, MEM-RTE-search-refresh and MEM-OBJ-message-parts.

Behavioral authority is supported at the named consumers: content supplies knowledge, skills prescribe methods, retained retrieval features affect ranking, mirror differences route compilation, and access/edit state supplies eligibility criteria and vetoes. These effects are not inferred from storage alone. The grouped units preserve distinct content and control parts, while remote effects and trace-update consumers remain unresolved. See RT-BAP-session-skills, RT-BAP-attached-pages, MEM-OBJ-source-mirror, MEM-RTE-search-read, MEM-OBJ-session-content and RT-RTE-source-authoring. None of these findings asserts reliable model compliance or factual acceptance.

Write agency distinguishes automatic proposal/projection/message admission from explicit administrator method editing and ordinary human publication decisions. Software remote replacement is not made manual merely because an administrator starts the pull. Generic authorized caller routes retain unresolved agency. The canonical compiled-edit and version-restore records are used after supersession; conflict resolution remains a distinct subroute, not another ordinary review mechanism. See RT-RTE-indexer-compile, RT-RTE-review-merge, RT-RTE-admin-configuration, RT-RTE-remote-pull, MEM-RTE-compiled-edit, MEM-RTE-version-restore and WF-RTE-conflict-resolution.

Curation now emits only supported replacement and bounded-withdrawal findings. Existing entries can be revised, and live reliance can be withdrawn without erasing history or every derivative. The prior requested-consolidation finding has been removed, and its dependent axis note and rationale now retain semantic compilation as unresolved. The fidelity policy and citation rewriting are not substituted for an implemented consolidation or synthesis transformation. This resolves the earlier objection on its evidence, not merely on the author's answer. See MEM-RTE-compiled-edit, MEM-OBJ-session-content, EPI-RTE-page-delete, MEM-RTE-search-refresh, EPI-CLM-source-fidelity and EPI-RTE-resource-rewrite.

Read-back direction separates requested document/search/history/attachment returns from automatic task-state supply. Signal classifies only the push operations: coarse section recaps and inventories, and source/resource lookup selecting related retained document names for incremental kickoff. The identifier finding does not claim delivery of full bodies, and requested semantic search does not become an inferred push signal. Skill-selection and external alternatives remain unresolved rather than being declared inapplicable from the known pull routes. See MEM-RTE-search-read, MEM-RTE-history-replay, RT-BAP-attached-pages, MEM-OBJ-session-content, MEM-OBJ-source-mirror, RT-RTE-indexer-compile and RT-BAP-session-skills.

Trace learning and trace source emit no positive, negative or inapplicability finding. The records establish raw replay, automatic proposal persistence and later retained-content consumption, but do not fully identify the original trace input to a qualifying durable behavior-shaping update. The profile does not require demonstrated improvement to classify wiring; it retains missing input/consumer linkage and opaque alternatives. No evidenced-absence record licenses a local learning negative or a completely assessed absence of qualifying writes. See MEM-OBJ-message-parts, MEM-RTE-history-replay, MEM-OBJ-session-content, RT-RTE-specialist-session and RT-RTE-admin-configuration.

The partial and not-determinable assessments preserve the recorded unknowns without turning them into absence or complete coverage. No emitted finding is upgraded to observed operation or causal benefit. No unresolved report disagreement changes these classifications; differences in inspection depth and overlapping object containers do not supply additional witnesses or negate the canonical parts. The stated uncertainty already bounds the extracted comparison values, so it requires no additional verification limit.

Blockers

none

Limits

none