Voyager profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes of the memory profile against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow members, resolving the duplicate objects and routes through the supplied reconciliation. The empty profile answers supplied no additional argument. No source files were reopened and no execution evidence was added.

Storage classifications are supported for the named file-backed maps, vector access structures, event archive, reconstructed accounting and within-bot Set. The known assessment concerns storage locations and mechanisms, not opaque payload contents or historical provenance. The grouped storage units distinguish their parts in their notes; in particular, the QA answer map is not itself a vector store. See MEM-OBJ-qa-cache, MEM-OBJ-qa-questions, MEM-OBJ-events and MEM-OBJ-block-records.

Representational form separates executable semantics, model interpretation, structured lookup/control state and numerical access representations. Classifying the retrieved code's model-facing use as natural-language does not replace its symbolic executor classification. The partial assessment preserves the uninspected trial payload alternative. Lineage separately retains live trace extraction, code-to-description/index compilation, checkpoint import and unresolved earlier production. Neither the live producer nor a reload establishes the original provenance of shipped content. See MEM-OBJ-skills-code, MEM-OBJ-skill-description, MEM-OBJ-skill-vectordb, MEM-RTE-skill-retrieval and EPI-RTE-skill-description.

The behavioral-authority findings distinguish model reference examples from executable definitions, ranking inputs from answer guidance, and contextual histories from control counts. Instruction at the executor is conditional executable direction, not an assertion of enforced primitive-only behavior. Replayed iteration has an actual continuation/exit consumer; the other recorder metrics are not assigned an invented model consumer. The authority inventory remains partial, with the additional local omission stated below. See RT-BAP-skill-execution, MEM-RTE-chest-update, MEM-RTE-progress-update and MEM-RTE-event-replay.

Write agency follows admission decisions rather than the fact that software writes files. Automatic learning admission, manual critic approval of the candidate attempt, subsequent automatic description generation and unresolved caller/checkpoint origins remain separate. Manual task confirmation is not treated as approval of the later description. The grouping of automatic chest/history/event/QA mechanisms names their distinct controls in the cited records. See RT-RTE-task-judgment, RT-RTE-skill-admission and EPI-RTE-skill-description.

Curation positives track active same-name replacement, chest-entry revision, completed-string deduplication, failure withdrawal with separately retained recorder history, and replay aggregation. They do not infer synthesis from an unchecked generated summary, promotion from archival filenames, or curation merely from adding an index entry. Historical maintenance remains unresolved rather than absent. See MEM-RTE-progress-update, MEM-RTE-chest-update, MEM-RTE-event-replay and RT-RTE-skill-admission.

Read-back direction and signal distinguish requested retrieval/reload from independent automatic supply. Semantic retrieval and exact key lookup belong to requested returns; they do not establish embedding or identifier push. All-library execution supply and automatic model-context rendering have their own consumers and coarse selectors. The known direction/signal assessments concern these inspected delivery operations, not the semantic contents of historical libraries. See MEM-RTE-skill-retrieval, MEM-RTE-qa-cache, MEM-RTE-context-refresh and RT-BAP-skill-execution.

Trace learning's three positive chains have automatic trace-conditioned writes, durable retained outputs and established later consumers. Their wired basis claims neither improved capacity nor observed activation. The unresolved QA, replay, transient frame/Set and historical alternatives are not converted into negative findings or source inapplicability. Tool execution/outcome feedback and environmental chest callbacks support the local tool-traces and event-streams findings. No linked trajectory or conversational-session source is inferred merely from an existing library. See RT-RTE-skill-admission, MEM-RTE-chest-update, MEM-RTE-progress-update, MEM-RTE-qa-cache and MEM-RTE-event-replay.

The supplied reports agree on task acceptance versus durable publication, prompt selection versus all-code execution supply, and learning versus inference admission. The workflow's delivery qualification does not upgrade persistence to successful reuse. See RT-RTE-task-inference, RT-RTE-skill-admission and workflow delivery. No unsupported emitted value, evidence basis, absence or complete-coverage assertion requiring a blocker was established. Faithfully expressed uncertainty is not counted as a finding.

Blockers

none

Limits

  • The profile's partial behavioral_authority inventory identifies learning authority at skill admission but does not separately classify the corresponding trace-fed update consumers for chest maps and task histories. MEM-RTE-chest-update and MEM-RTE-progress-update establish those automatic durable behavior-shaping updates, while the profile records mainly their downstream knowledge/routing effects. Withhold exhaustive update-consumer authority comparisons for these routes. The emitted learning existence finding and the listed downstream forces remain supported; this omission does not change the supported system-level positive union.
  • The profile's partial trace_learning and trace_source inventories do not separately assess the code-to-description write as a downstream branch of successful task retention. EPI-RTE-skill-description, MEM-OBJ-skill-description and RT-RTE-skill-admission establish automatic generation from admitted code, durable description/index retention and later ranking consumption. Withhold a complete inventory of trace-derived description updates and their original-input source classifications. The existing skill-retention yes finding and tool-traces witness remain valid, and the partial assessments do not assert that this branch is absent.