Eidetic profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I judged all ten axes, their unit scopes, positive findings, evidence bases and coverage notes in the handed profile against the supplied runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow members. I used the supplied reconciliation to resolve supersessions: export model identity rests on MEM-CMP-export-models, and typed Evidence identity rests on MEM-OBJ-evidence-events. The remaining containers and parts are not interchangeable. No source reads, new records, quotations or replacement classifications were needed.
The profile's boundary is accumulated content, derived retrieval and delivery artifacts, and retained control state with later consumers. It does not classify product-update source replacements, static inference weights or shipped instructions as accumulated memory. Possible provider accumulation stays explicitly unresolved, rather than becoming a positive storage, form or learning finding. All axis assessments are partial; none asserts a complete system inventory or bounded absence.
| Axis | Judgment and supporting records |
|---|---|
| Storage substrate | Files and SQLite are supported for the named local parts. Markdown bodies, generated rules and vault outputs remain separate from database projections and filesystem cache/log controls. Dense encoding does not create a second substrate. See MEM-OBJ-memory-cards, MEM-OBJ-memory-chunks, MEM-OBJ-admission-traces, MEM-RTE-session-hints and MEM-RTE-vault-export. Provider uncertainty does not invalidate these witnesses. |
| Representational form | The profile separates interpretive prose, fixed-rule symbolic fields/scalars and distributed dense vectors by operative part and consumption path. It does not infer a consumed opaque payload's form from a display summary. The unresolved callback and dark-payload units prevent a complete form claim. See MEM-OBJ-memory-chunks, MEM-OBJ-evidence-events and EPI-RTE-m2-reshaping. |
| Lineage | Authored, imported, trace-extracted and other-compiled paths have local support. Known splitting, embedding, folding and export derivations do not settle initial file provenance. Re-retrieved M3 support does not establish the original answer's source-use history. See MEM-OBJ-memory-cards, MEM-RTE-code-projection, RT-RTE-m3-filing and MEM-RTE-vault-export. |
| Behavioral authority | Knowledge at later readers, instruction at the host rules consumer, ranking at selectors, learning at durable-update consumers and routing/validation/enforcement at code gates are supported as distinct effects. Learning force is not presented as improved capacity. Feedback instruction is not model-compliance enforcement. Cache suppression and protected mutation gates have actual veto consumers. See RT-BAP-memory-rules, MEM-BAP-session-awareness, EPI-RTE-confidence-ranking, MEM-OBJ-admission-traces and EPI-RTE-support-check. |
| Write agency | Automatic findings describe software/model admission, not merely physical writes. Invocation or activation is not treated as per-content human approval. The explicit-user base policy has only a claimed manual basis; human edits/reversal have an afforded basis; unspecified direct callers and handoff initialization remain unresolved. See RT-RTE-explicit-admission, MEM-RTE-evidence-projection and MEM-RTE-card-withdrawal. |
| Curation operations | Consolidation, evolution, deduplication, promotion, invalidation and decay follow recorded transformations. Default M2 selects existing salient claims, deduplicates slugs and replaces a managed region. Optional model output is not classified as synthesis from its name or from failure to prove entailment. See EPI-RTE-m2-reshaping, MEM-RTE-evidence-projection, MEM-RTE-card-withdrawal and EPI-RTE-vault-generation. |
| Read-back direction | Requested recall/detail, discovery and browsing retain pull findings. SessionStart assembly and automatic supply to maintenance/support/topic consumers retain push findings. The requested return is not counted again as push. Automatic selection within a requested export is scoped to the separate topic-model consumer. See RT-RTE-memory-recall, RT-RTE-context-injection, RT-RTE-semantic-maintenance and MEM-RTE-vault-export. |
| Read-back signal | Push units name triggers, selector inputs and selected parts. Actual project/session matches support identifier findings; recency, count bands and budgets support coarse findings; lexical/vector selection and relevance judgments have separate local warrants. Requested detail IDs are not used to establish identifier push. See MEM-RTE-fresh-handoff, MEM-RTE-session-hints, RT-RTE-semantic-maintenance, RT-RTE-m3-filing and MEM-RTE-test-affirmation. |
| Trace learning | The positive chains connect automatic trace-fed writes to durable cards, retry controls, generated guidance or ranking state and their later consumers. Dark diagnostic retention alone is not claimed as card filing. The test-promotion finding retains its matching-identity conditions and does not assert ordinary hook activation. Static imports/code projection are locally inapplicable, not a system-wide negative. See RT-RTE-signal-compound, RT-RTE-m3-filing, MEM-RTE-session-hints and MEM-RTE-test-affirmation. |
| Trace source | Conversational mining supports session-logs, session occurrence history supports event-streams, and recorded Bash test feedback supports tool-traces on their respective qualifying writes. Serialization as lifecycle events does not add an origin category. Multi-step workflow structure does not establish trajectories as consumed experience. See RT-RTE-signal-compound, EPI-RTE-acquisition-check, MEM-RTE-session-hints and MEM-RTE-test-affirmation. |
I checked consequential qualifications across members. Workflow's annotations preserve repeatable History appends, daily-signal duplicate checks and loss of originating-project identity in the spool; the profile's dedup finding does not imply exactly-once History admission. MEM-RTE-test-affirmation preserves the ordinary project-identity mismatch alongside conditional implemented capacity. EPI-RTE-support-check preserves deterministic fallback, registered-judge failure and configurable quotation requirements; no profile value depends on universal independent judging. MEM-RTE-vault-export preserves afforded human reading, incomplete withdrawal of copies and unresolved generated-content semantics.
Some units group several named local mechanisms with the same classification and coverage. Their notes and citations retain the consequential distinctions, while opaque branches have separate unresolved units. These groupings do not support complete-value statistics or erase weaker claimed/afforded alternatives. I found no unsupported emitted comparison value, evidence-strength upgrade, absence or complete-coverage assertion. The remaining uncertainty is already expressed in the extracted units and partial axes, so it requires no additional verification limit.
Blockers
none
Limits
none