SwarmWorld profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I checked all ten axes of the memory profile against the supplied records and annotations, applying the profile type's definitions rather than requiring observed improvement or epistemic acceptance. The reconciliation identifies one supersession: the empirical-knowledge object is represented by MEM-OBJ-empirical-knowledge. The profile uses that canonical record. The remaining overlapping containers and routes retain distinct scopes; I found no classification relying on treating them as independent evidence of operation.
The scoped boundary includes live retained content, access metadata, program instructions and recorded reconstruction, with unresolved offline transformations. It excludes static scenario instructions, pending action queues, ordinary physical arrays and provider state. Those exclusions agree with the accepted memory account. Every axis remains partial; none asserts a complete system inventory, bounded absence or inapplicability. Included offline alternatives remain explicitly uninspected. All positive bases are wired, consistent with implementation evidence and the absence of supplied runs. The partial research-state source unit and indeterminate semantic-curation unit preserve their separate uncertainties.
| Axis | Support and disposition |
|---|---|
| storage_substrate | Process-local collections and file-backed traces support in-memory and files. JSON is not mistaken for a substrate. See MEM-OBJ-agent-memory, MEM-OBJ-program-library and MEM-OBJ-event-trace. The executable's in-process slot is also supported by RT-OBJ-artifact-program; its omission as a separate substrate unit does not change the emitted union or the partial coverage claim. |
| representational_form | Prose and symbolic metadata are separated. Measurements, recipes, membership and bounded DSL instructions support symbolic form; model-interpreted prose supports natural language. No parametric simulator-memory finding is inferred from the excluded provider. See MEM-OBJ-research-state, MEM-OBJ-research-mission and MEM-OBJ-program-library. |
| lineage | Controller authorship, trace-derived evidence and counters, copied teaching/reconstructed state, and mechanical canonicalization/factoring support the four emitted paths. Imported lineage describes destination-store admission, not a replacement for original authorship. See MEM-RTE-social-retention, MEM-RTE-retrieval-feedback, MEM-OBJ-program-library and MEM-OBJ-event-trace. |
| behavioral_authority | Context supplies knowledge; retained text and counters affect ranking; resource/provenance/membership checks supply validation and vetoes; ledger edges and committed trace fields route later work. Experience at update consumers supports learning authority independently of downstream knowledge/ranking. Installed instructions have fixed-rule executable force. These findings follow actual consumers, not labels such as verified. See MEM-RTE-context-selection, MEM-BAP-evidence-admission, MEM-RTE-retrieval-feedback, MEM-OBJ-message-records, RT-RTE-recorded-replay and RT-BAP-program-execution. |
| write_agency | Software sensing, feedback, inheritance and model-state admission support automatic writes. Manual applies locally to explicit human content-bearing actions, not every write in an interactive episode. See MEM-RTE-evidence-retention, MEM-RTE-cultural-inheritance, RT-RTE-model-planning and RT-RTE-direct-control. |
| curation_operations | Bounded retained-evidence views consolidate; cell/counter/index and installed-program updates evolve; caps and resets decay; reversible prompt factoring deduplicates; fulfillment withdraws pending reliance while preserving history. No synthesis is inferred from a hypothesis field or lossy excerpt. See MEM-RTE-context-selection, MEM-RTE-retrieval-feedback, RT-RTE-program-install, MEM-OBJ-event-trace and MEM-OBJ-message-records. |
| read_back_direction | Scheduled context, receipts and inheritance support push. Requested record/program resolution and reconstruction support pull. A requested return is not counted again as unsolicited supply. See MEM-RTE-context-selection, MEM-RTE-social-retention, MEM-RTE-cultural-inheritance and RT-RTE-recorded-replay. |
| read_back_signal | Macroturn query scoring supports inferred lexical selection; availability, proximity and caps support coarse selection; actual program-focus, recipient and reply matching support identifier selection. The profile does not turn an ID on a requested item into identifier push. See MEM-RTE-context-selection, MEM-OBJ-program-skills, MEM-OBJ-message-records and MEM-RTE-cultural-inheritance. |
| trace_learning | Automatically retained continuation state, adaptive counters and empirical/skill summaries have later context, ranking or admission consumers. These support wired yes without weight updates, novel knowledge or demonstrated benefit. Raw recording alone is not the warrant. See MEM-OBJ-research-state, MEM-RTE-retrieval-feedback, MEM-RTE-evidence-retention and MEM-OBJ-program-skills. |
| trace_source | Discrete simulator observations, selections, citations and outcomes support event streams. The enabled experience-reuse chain links recipe/input, sample and later tested outcome, supporting trajectories locally. Research-state input provenance remains partial; fresh provider messages do not by themselves establish retained conversational session logs. See MEM-RTE-retrieval-feedback, MEM-OBJ-research-mission, EPI-RTE-batch-measurement and MEM-RTE-context-selection. |
I also checked the qualifications shared by the records: retrieval selection precedes trimming, replay does not restore all adaptive-selector evolution, and measured program exposure is not demonstrated competence. The profile preserves these distinctions. See EPI-RTE-memory-selection, MEM-RTE-retrieval-feedback, MEM-OBJ-program-skills and the annotation on RT-RTE-recorded-replay. No value depends on successful execution, model compliance or scientific warrant.
Source-read log: none. This judgment uses only the supplied records, annotations and profile; no source ambiguity required an additional frozen-source read. No correction answers or refusal blockers were supplied.
Blockers
none
Limits
- The partial inventory is coarser than a complete mechanism-level comparison. The profile's storage units do not separately enumerate the installed program slot identified by RT-OBJ-artifact-program, and its signal units acknowledge but do not separately emit coarse verified-status/recency selection for the program view described by MEM-OBJ-program-skills. Several authority and direction units also combine named consumers or operations that share the same emitted value. The profile supports the existence of its emitted values, but consumers should withhold complete object counts, complete per-selector value sets and one-to-one route comparisons from these grouped units. This is not a blocker: the axes already express partial coverage, the omissions add no new system-union value, and the stated local mechanisms remain supported.