SAGE profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I checked every axis, its included units, emitted values, evidence bases and coverage assessments in the handed memory profile. This judgment uses the supplied runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow records, with superseded content, reflection, correction and lifecycle declarations resolved to their canonical memory records. Gate evidence, semantic verdict and operator review remain distinct parts. No frozen-source reads were needed or made, and this verification adds no evidence or replacement classifications.
The two correction answers match the handed profile. Reflection packaging no longer emits promotion, and bridge transformation no longer emits consolidation or synthesis at any basis. Their unit notes, axis note and comparison rationale preserve the unresolved semantic questions without retaining those positives. I reassessed both objections rather than treating the previous verification as dispositive.
| Axis | Support and disposition |
|---|---|
| storage_substrate | Canonical Badger state, SQLite serving and admission parts, PostgreSQL daemon records, retained vector indexes, capture files and benchmark output have recorded witnesses. Preference/run storage and broader recovery/coordination alternatives remain unresolved. The vector finding names retained search state, not external model weights. MEM-OBJ-memory-record, MEM-OBJ-memory-indexes, MEM-OBJ-capture-progress, MEM-RTE-evaluation-readback, WF-RTE-local-exchange. No unsupported emitted substrate identified. |
| representational_form | Prose interpreted by models/humans, localized symbolic metadata and distributed dense representations are distinguished. Numerical feedback counters are not misclassified as learned model parameters. MEM-OBJ-memory-record, MEM-OBJ-validator-stats, MEM-OBJ-memory-indexes. Positive forms hold; coarse groups limit inventory comparisons below. |
| lineage | Authored content, imports/copies, selected conversation text, generated outcome lessons and software-derived state have supported derivation paths. Unknown deployed initialization and legacy vector provenance remain separate from known subsequent transformations. MEM-RTE-import-material, MEM-RTE-sync-copy, MEM-OBJ-capture-unit, RT-RTE-bridge-distillation. No unsupported emitted lineage identified. |
| behavioral_authority | Actual consumers support knowledge from recalled context, instruction from boot text, ranking from retrieval inputs/quorum factors, validation and enforcement from gate decisions/service fences, and routing from continuation state. Learning authority is attached to update inputs rather than inferred from downstream benefit. RT-BAP-retained-context, RT-RTE-boot-guidance, MEM-OBJ-review-decision, MEM-RTE-verdict-feedback, RT-RTE-bridge-distillation. Values hold; combined consumer units remain coarse. |
| write_agency | Software admission without mandatory per-content human approval supports automatic. Explicit operator boot replacement and semantic review support manual. Process consent, migration initiation and generic signatures are not substituted for per-content human decisions. The provider-ready repair alternative remains unresolved rather than inheriting the inspected migration lane's coverage. RT-RTE-memory-admission, RT-RTE-boot-guidance, MEM-OBJ-review-decision, MEM-RTE-reembed-index. No unsupported emitted agency value identified. |
| curation_operations | Confidence aging supports decay; correction and lifecycle withdrawal support evolve/invalidate; selective transcript retention supports a reduced representation of retained conversational content. MEM-OBJ-memory-indexes, MEM-RTE-correction-cycle, MEM-RTE-lifecycle-change, MEM-OBJ-capture-unit. The corrected reflection and bridge units emit no unsupported operations: initial fact typing is not promotion of retained memory, and a request for novel distilled advice does not settle the transformation. MEM-RTE-reflection-storage, RT-RTE-bridge-distillation. Both previous blockers are resolved, including dependent rationale. |
| read_back_direction | Explicit retrieval and Message/result paging support pull. Host hooks and independent downstream model-prompt assembly support push, separately from the upstream requests they consume. Boot preference loading and custom-guidance supply are distinguished within inception. RT-RTE-targeted-recall, RT-RTE-hook-context, RT-RTE-bridge-distillation, RT-RTE-boot-guidance, MEM-RTE-evaluation-readback, WF-RTE-local-exchange. No unsupported emitted direction identified. |
| read_back_signal | Recent availability/recency supports coarse, and exact thread matching supports identifier for the resumed-thread push. Bridge and benchmark units retain uncertainty about additional selector modes rather than borrowing all modes from another recall route. Requested foreground/Message returns are locally inapplicable to push-signal classification, not an axis-wide absence. RT-RTE-hook-context, RT-RTE-bridge-distillation, MEM-RTE-evaluation-readback, WF-RTE-local-exchange. No unsupported positive or inapplicability identified. |
| trace_learning | Vote-to-statistics-to-later-quorum and outcome-to-durable-advice-to-later-context routes support wired yes. Neither implies improved capacity or observed use. Capture's selected raw-text encoding is not evidence of a generated continuation summary; its unresolved unit emits neither yes nor an unsupported local no. MEM-RTE-verdict-feedback, RT-RTE-bridge-distillation, MEM-OBJ-capture-unit. No unsupported emitted trace-learning value identified. |
| trace_source | Recorded vote events and terminal transitions support event-streams for the qualifying statistics update. Bridge challenge/outcome labels do not resolve original source categories, and known conversational capture origin is not independently emitted as the source of an unestablished qualifying update. MEM-RTE-verdict-feedback, RT-RTE-bridge-distillation, MEM-OBJ-capture-unit. No unsupported emitted source identified. |
All ten axes remain partial. Their included unresolved families prevent complete-value claims; no strong local witness upgrades those families. Findings stay at wired evidence, not observed or causal support. The conservative empty units preserve uncertainty rather than asserting absence. The remaining inventory-resolution issue below does not change a supported system union or require a new source fact to preserve the bounded account.
Blockers
none
Limits
- The partial profile inventories use some coarse groups across distinct parts, consumers and admission mechanisms, notably the prose/symbolic form groups, authored/imported paths, retrieval/quorum ranking group, service-fence group and automatic-admission group. MEM-OBJ-memory-record, MEM-OBJ-memory-indexes, MEM-OBJ-review-decision, MEM-RTE-verdict-feedback and WF-RTE-local-exchange distinguish these mechanisms more finely. The grouped positives retain valid existence witnesses; no additional unsupported value follows from their grouping. Withhold per-object, per-consumer and per-admission-mechanism inventory comparisons or unit-count statistics from these partial axes. This is an inventory-resolution limit, not a qualification of the emitted positive values or permission to treat grouped units as an exhaustive mechanism census.