KHMS memory profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I checked every axis, unit assessment, finding and evidence basis in the memory profile against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow records. I also read reconciliation: it establishes no supersessions, so the cited declarations remain canonical. The profile-answer input is empty. No source reads, new records or new quotations were needed.
The profile classifies retained material and later consumption rather than all runtime storage. Its positive findings concern inspectable mechanisms, not deployment observations. All ten axes retain partial coverage. The unknown initial corpus, private guidance, external history and provider alternatives are not converted into absence or complete system coverage. Some units group several mechanisms, but their notes and finding-level citations preserve the relevant parts, consumers and evidence bases; I found no grouping that changes an emitted comparison value.
| Axis | Support and coverage judgment |
|---|---|
| Storage substrate | File storage is supported for text, structured metadata and numerical index files by MEM-OBJ-trace-material, MEM-OBJ-inbox, MEM-OBJ-card-content, MEM-OBJ-mark-ledger and MEM-OBJ-embedding-index. Extension file access is supported by RT-RTE-operational-change. Graph edges and NPZ encoding are not mistaken for additional storage substrates. External-history/provider uncertainty prevents a complete inventory. |
| Representational form | Prose interpreted by models/readers, fixed-rule metadata and numerical ranking inputs are separated. MEM-OBJ-card-content, MEM-OBJ-card-metadata and MEM-OBJ-embedding-index support natural-language, symbolic and parametric findings respectively. The numerical finding concerns retained vectors, not an inferred change to model weights. Private/opaque content remains unresolved. |
| Lineage | Imported source packets, trace-extracted findings and compiled access structures have distinct derivation paths in MEM-OBJ-trace-material, MEM-OBJ-inbox, MEM-OBJ-views and MEM-OBJ-embedding-index. The card/correction unit retains the difference between wired proposal import, afforded editing and claimed external-report capture. It does not infer initial authorship from known later transformations. |
| Behavioral authority | Knowledge and instruction concern interpreted card/pending content; learning concerns retained experience at the proposal-update consumer; ranking concerns scored text/features/vectors. RT-BAP-context-delivery, MEM-RTE-pending-evidence, RT-RTE-mark-evaluation and MEM-OBJ-embedding-index support these separate effects. Routing/enforcement concern code consumers of coverage, relations and delivery state, not obedience to card prose. Retraction lint criteria support validation independently of downstream historical explanation: MEM-OBJ-mark-ledger, MEM-OBJ-hook-state, MEM-OBJ-tombstones. Afforded index/export/lookup roles are not upgraded to wired host use. |
| Write agency | The automatic finding concerns software/model admission of generated findings, proposals and derived structures, not human initiation or physical I/O. MEM-OBJ-inbox, MEM-OBJ-views and RT-RTE-mark-evaluation support it. The unresolved capture/review/correction/extension unit correctly withholds manual classification: RT-RTE-card-admission and RT-RTE-maintenance-admission do not authenticate a per-content human decision. |
| Curation operations | Retained trace reduction supports consolidation; candidate replacement and errata support evolution; supersession/refutation supports invalidation; archive removal supports bounded forgetting. These are different implemented effects in MEM-OBJ-trace-material, MEM-OBJ-inbox, MEM-OBJ-tombstones, EPI-RTE-supersession-link and EPI-RTE-triage-verdict. Synthesis stays claimed under EPI-CLM-synthesis-review; orchestration and requested novelty do not prove a new claim was produced. No semantic deduplication or promotion is inferred from ID checks or approval alone. |
| Read-back direction | Explicit recall and precheck are requested returns; hook injection and prepared later-evaluation packets are automatic supply. RT-RTE-recall-return, MEM-RTE-precheck-return and the memory/workflow annotations on RT-RTE-mark-evaluation support the distinction. Generated-index loading and portable/historical consumer roles retain afforded basis through MEM-RTE-index-bootstrap, MEM-RTE-export-copy and MEM-RTE-retired-lookup. Requested delivery is not counted again as push. |
| Read-back signal | The profile ties lexical/embedding selection to event or MARK text, identity selection to actual relation/card/tag matches, and coarse supply to availability and budgets. RT-RTE-recall-return, MEM-OBJ-card-metadata, MEM-OBJ-embedding-index, MEM-RTE-precheck-return and RT-RTE-mark-evaluation support these selectors and selected parts. The index is coarse afforded navigation, not card-ID matching. Unknown host/private selection is not made inapplicable by a known pull route. |
| Trace learning | Automatic trace-fed generation and candidate updates persist material reused in later model packets: MEM-OBJ-inbox and RT-RTE-mark-evaluation. This supports wired yes without requiring model training, improved capacity or approved-card status. The weekly own-mistake branch retains claimed basis under EPI-CLM-synthesis-review. Unresolved alternatives remain separate. No local or system-wide no is asserted without an absence warrant. |
| Trace source | Conversational turns and recorded tool names/error snippets support session-logs and tool-traces for the qualifying nightly writes: MEM-OBJ-trace-material, MEM-OBJ-inbox, RT-RTE-nightly-proposals. Mixed Git/journal and weekly/private origins remain unresolved. Serialization, timestamps and journal wrapping do not independently establish event-streams or trajectories. |
I checked the consequential qualifications across axes. The profile preserves the current generated index's navigation-only content rather than treating the bootstrap-body doctrine in RT-BAP-context-delivery as implemented card preload; MEM-RTE-index-bootstrap supplies the narrower account. It distinguishes SessionStart reminders from ranked card search and keeps correction pointers bounded, as recorded in the memory annotations on RT-RTE-recall-return. History does not silently include archive, and archive withdrawal does not erase MARK coverage: MEM-OBJ-card-metadata, MEM-OBJ-mark-ledger. Conditional hook enforcement is not generalized into a universal review or truth gate: EPI-RTE-hook-gates.
The supported system existence findings survive the unresolved coverage. They do not license complete-value statistics, observed compliance, successful semantic acceptance, improved future capacity or causal benefit. Those restrictions are already expressed by the profile's assessments, bases and notes; they are faithfully scoped uncertainty rather than additional publication defects. I found no unsupported emitted value or materially misleading completeness claim.
Blockers
none
Limits
none