MCMA-OpenMemory profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes of the memory profile, including each finding's scope, evidence basis, natural unit and coverage assessment. The supplied correction-answers file was empty. I used the accepted reports and reconciliation; no source reads or new quotations were needed. Reconciliation's superseded canonical-memory, interaction and thematic declarations are not used as classification warrants. The knowledge container and its answer/metadata parts remain compatible rather than competing classifications.

Storage and form. The file finding is warranted as a retained object layout, not exhaustive physical-backend classification: MEM-OBJ-library-index supplies object paths and manifest indirection. The profile preserves adapter uncertainty with partial coverage. MEM-OBJ-semantic-vectors supports dense numerical form independently of that storage container. Text, fixed-rule metadata and dense vectors remain separate units; arbitrary answer payloads and vault bytes remain unresolved rather than classified from JSON or format labels. See MEM-OBJ-knowledge-answer and MEM-OBJ-vault.

Lineage. Immediate acquisition, local compilation and transcript extraction are distinguished from upstream authorship and embedding-model provenance. The records support these local derivation findings without resolving the initial generic-content branch. In particular, MEM-RTE-thematic-sync supports extraction from archived answers, whereas MEM-RTE-semantic-maintenance supports inference-derived vectors, not weight learning. Partial coverage preserves those distinctions.

Authority. The profile separates reference/answer consumption, ranking, eligibility checks and vetoes, discovery/destination routing, and the trace-fed update consumer. RT-BAP-memory-reference supports knowledge use without establishing instruction compliance. MEM-BAP-knowledge-reuse, RT-BAP-policy-decision and RT-CLM-permission-scope support local validation/enforcement, not universal trust or host isolation. The routing and learning findings retain different consumers: MEM-OBJ-conversation-index shapes discovery, while EPI-RTE-catalog-classification produces organization consumed by thematic synchronization. Opaque generic consumers remain unresolved.

Admission and curation. Manual agency is confined to explicitly described user source/edit decisions; automatic organization, capture and maintenance do not inherit it. Generic owner/caller operations remain unresolved. RT-RTE-explicit-capture supports this split. The curation findings concern retained compression, revision, withdrawal, reliance promotion and removal from capped current views, not secure erasure. RT-RTE-interaction-approval, MEM-RTE-thematic-sync and MEM-OBJ-context-traces support these bounded effects. Requested model faithfulness is not promoted into established synthesis or consolidation; that branch remains unresolved.

Read-back. The known direction assessment is bounded to shipped consumer routes and the separately afforded secret callback. Request-driven context reconstruction, browser recovery and inspection establish pull; automatic selection within those operations does not establish an independent push. See RT-RTE-context-supply, WF-RTE-request-recovery and MEM-RTE-inspector-snapshot. Within this inventory, push-signal inapplicability is supported. Unknown hypothetical callers do not invalidate the inventory's bounded direction finding.

Trace learning and origin. The two positive units identify automatic writes, durable derived access/organization artifacts and later consumers, rather than raw log retention alone. Their recorded conversational inputs support session-logs: MEM-OBJ-interaction, MEM-OBJ-conversation-index and EPI-RTE-catalog-classification. Wiring does not establish improved capacity or exercised self-improvement. Other alternatives remain unresolved, so partial coverage and the absence of a system-wide negative are appropriate.

Grouped units are coarse, but their named scopes distinguish the consequential forms, consumers, admission controls and unresolved alternatives. I found no unsupported emitted value, material coverage omission or remaining inter-report conflict requiring correction. The profile's uncertainty already prevents complete physical-substrate, generic-payload, upstream-lineage and exhaustive learning conclusions. Those faithfully scoped uncertainties are not additional verification limits. No finding upgrades implementation or affordance to observed operation or causal benefit.

Blockers

none

Limits

none