CORAL profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

The handed memory profile is supported within its declared accumulated-memory boundary. I checked all ten axes, their local findings and evidence bases, inventory assessments, and the distinctions between objects, admission mechanisms, transformations and consumers. Reconciliation makes no supersessions and identifies no unresolved report conflict. I used only the handed members and contracts; no source files were read and no target execution was performed.

  • Storage substrate: The file-backed knowledge, attempt and pointer surfaces, prescribed capture/review files, and separate Git checkpoint history support the emitted files and repo findings. The unknown effective conversation store is not classified from its pointer or a local lookup location. The partial axis does not claim a complete host-storage inventory (MEM-OBJ-notes, MEM-OBJ-raw-sources, MEM-OBJ-checkpoint, MEM-OBJ-session-state).
  • Representational form: Textual guidance and explanations are distinguished from parsed fields, links and executable resources. The capture/review unit explicitly identifies both prescribed parts and their claimed warrant. Numeric attempt scores do not establish parametric memory, and the recovered payload remains uninspected rather than borrowing the display's form (MEM-OBJ-skills, EPI-OBJ-review-json, EPI-OBJ-attempt-score, EPI-OBJ-attempt-feedback, MEM-OBJ-session-state).
  • Lineage: Findings identify the authored and trace-fed revision branches, external import, mechanical navigation/checkpoint derivation, and event/result-derived records. Findings grouped within a unit retain their distinct object/path warrants in their notes and citations. Subsequent model revision does not resolve initial seed provenance, and neither resolves host payload derivation (MEM-RTE-knowledge-revision, MEM-OBJ-note-navigation, MEM-OBJ-checkpoint, MEM-OBJ-migration-arrival, RT-OBJ-attempt).
  • Behavioral authority: Each positive has a named consumed part and effect. Advisory knowledge delivery, requested durable-artifact updating, downstream procedural guidance, numeric ranking/routing, and fixed-reader exclusions are not treated as interchangeable. Saved source passages supply criteria to the prescribed reviewer, which supports claimed validation without implying an enforced truth gate. The profile preserves direct-hash recovery and the lack of universal withdrawal through note metadata (MEM-BAP-retained-guidance, MEM-RTE-knowledge-revision, RT-RTE-island-migration, RT-RTE-resume-steering, EPI-RTE-synthesis-review).
  • Write agency: Model-mediated admission without per-content human approval supports automatic at the afforded or claimed layer. Mechanically generated attempts, snapshots, indices and arrival summaries support wired automatic findings. The separate unresolved seed-supply/replacement decision correctly avoids equating copying files or starting a workflow with human approval of retained content (MEM-RTE-knowledge-revision, MEM-RTE-note-maintenance, MEM-OBJ-skills, MEM-OBJ-roles, RT-RTE-eval-submission).
  • Curation operations: Requested consolidation, duplicate merging and revision retain afforded bases; attempt archival has a wired, consumer-bounded invalidate finding; research withdrawal retains a claimed basis. The profile does not infer synthesize from the command's name or require new knowledge for consolidate. Incomplete semantic/helper inspection remains explicit rather than supporting a complete curation inventory (MEM-RTE-note-maintenance, MEM-RTE-knowledge-revision, RT-RTE-resume-steering, EPI-RTE-confidence-disposition, EPI-RTE-research-writing).
  • Read-back direction: Requested CLI/API/file/history access supports pull. Independent manager-selected feedback supports push. A requested return is not counted again as unsolicited delivery. Uninspected host recovery and skill disclosure prevent complete direction coverage (MEM-RTE-knowledge-query, MEM-OBJ-checkpoint, RT-RTE-heartbeat-feedback, MEM-OBJ-session-state, MEM-OBJ-skills).
  • Read-back signal: The profile identifies the polling trigger, availability/cadence inputs and selected feedback for coarse selection. Its identifier finding concerns matching the committing agent to the live recipient of that result, not merely the presence of a file ID. Pull selectors are locally inapplicable to this axis; they do not make unresolved host push selection globally inapplicable. No lexical or embedding push value is borrowed from requested substring search (RT-RTE-heartbeat-feedback, RT-OBJ-attempt, MEM-RTE-knowledge-query).
  • Trace learning: The requested result/transcript-to-durable-guidance chain supports afforded yes. The automatic arrival announcement supports wired yes: relocation and score state produce retained coordination prose available to later note consumers. The definition does not require an experimental technique, new knowledge, observed dependence or demonstrated improvement. Raw attempt/checkpoint retention alone is not used as a qualifying transformation or an evidenced no; host continuation artifacts remain unresolved (MEM-RTE-knowledge-revision, MEM-OBJ-migration-arrival, MEM-RTE-knowledge-query, MEM-OBJ-checkpoint, MEM-OBJ-session-state).
  • Trace source: Session and execution feedback are attached to the afforded revision chain. Relocation events and recorded grader outcomes are separately identified as the mixed original inputs to the wired arrival-summary write. External research is not relabeled as an event stream merely because it is captured. No trajectory finding or complete host-source classification is asserted (MEM-RTE-knowledge-revision, MEM-OBJ-skills, MEM-OBJ-migration-arrival, RT-RTE-island-migration, EPI-OBJ-attempt-score).

The inventory is compact rather than one row per file. Its finding notes preserve the consequential part, derivation, consumer and evidence-layer distinctions within grouped units. I found no grouping that upgrades an unresolved included alternative or changes the supported comparison findings. Every axis remains partial, with positive witnesses and named unresolved coverage; local known assessments describe the specified branches rather than the system as a whole. No absence assessment, observed operation or causal benefit is inferred. These explicitly scoped uncertainties are not additional verification limits.

Blockers

none

Limits

none