Compound Engineering Plugin profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
Checked all ten axes, their findings, evidence bases, coverage assessments and classification units in the profile. Resolved the five superseded epistemic object/route identities to the memory declarations. Capture grounding, refresh, session enrichment and later retrieval remain distinct mechanisms within or connected to the broad admission container. No reconciliation disagreement requires selecting between competing values. The supplied profile answers are empty; no predecessor objection determined this judgment.
Storage and form. File and conditional Git retention are supported by MEM-OBJ-solutions, MEM-OBJ-concepts, MEM-OBJ-pack-rules, MEM-RTE-pack-resolution and RT-OBJ-run-manifest. Temporary handoffs and gitignored optimization state are correctly distinguished from permanent or branch-portable retention. Natural-language effects are separated from fixed-rule controller, review and grading fields; RT-BAP-controller-state and EPI-RTE-eval-grading support the wired symbolic witnesses. External model weights do not classify the included opaque memory payloads. Some units aggregate objects or parts; the consequence is recorded below rather than treating their bounded existence findings as unsupported.
Lineage and authority. Authored, imported, trace-extracted and other-compiled findings attach to distinct derivation paths. The extraction witness does not upgrade historian synthesis, and known acquisition does not settle upstream authorship. MEM-RTE-session-capture supports lossy extraction, not complete original provenance. Knowledge and relevance-ranking authority at planning/review consumers follow MEM-BAP-project-evidence, MEM-RTE-learning-retrieval and MEM-RTE-review-retrieval. Controller validation, enforced veto and routing remain confined to RT-RTE-external-unit. Experiment inputs' learning authority is kept separate from downstream digest knowledge authority in MEM-RTE-experiment-digest. Revised-method instruction authority is afforded, not observed deployment, under RT-RTE-skill-authoring.
Write agency and curation. Automatic content admission is not inferred from physical I/O alone: silent glossary edits, session incorporation, handoff assembly and batch digestion have model/software admission owners. Conditional human approvals remain separate mechanisms under RT-RTE-learning-admission, EPI-RTE-capture-grounding and EPI-RTE-refresh-curation. Unknown initial and contributor admission is preserved. Revision, merging, duplicate removal, withdrawal with Git history and active-corpus forgetting support the stated curation findings. Session reduction has a wired extraction witness; semantic consolidation remains claimed. Neither a route called synthesis nor uncertain summary fidelity establishes a new claim absent from the inputs. Postwrite grounding and Lightweight exceptions are not promoted to an enforced semantic admission gate.
Read-back. The classified pull operations fulfill requests for retained research, pack roots, historical evidence, selected continuity, optimization state or recovery evidence. Their return is not separately classified as push merely because selection is automatic. MEM-RTE-handoff-resume retains user source selection and orientation-only consumption. RT-RTE-external-unit supports requested recovery, not complete auditing of resume internals. Local push-signal inapplicability is confined to the resolved pull operations; the signal axis remains uninspected because changed-method loading, host injection and ancillary delivery are unresolved. No identifier-based push or pull-only system negative is asserted.
Trace learning and source. The three positive chains satisfy the specified write-route definition: prior sessions into durable learning, conversation/workspace experience into a later-consumed handoff, and experiment outcomes into next-batch strategy. Their end-to-end bases remain claimed under MEM-RTE-session-capture, MEM-RTE-handoff-resume and MEM-RTE-experiment-digest. A continuation summary need not generalize or demonstrate improvement to qualify. Session turns and recorded tool activity support their respective source values; linked hypotheses, actions, measurements and keep/revert outcomes support optimization trajectories alongside tool feedback. Mixed handoff and host-summary provenance remains partial. No local trace-learning no, event-stream source, observed benefit or causal improvement is invented.
Every system-level axis with positive findings remains partial; read-back signal has no positive finding and remains uninspected. Named host and ancillary alternatives are retained instead of being dropped to obtain complete coverage. These uncertainties preserve the supported existence conclusions and prevent complete-value statistics. No source reads were needed: judgment used only the handed members and governing contracts.
Blockers
none
Limits
- Classification units in the profile sometimes combine several objects or consumption paths rather than exposing each as a separate unit. Examples include project solutions/glossary/live packs in storage, experiment prose and metric fields in form, and session/handoff/experiment reads in direction. MEM-OBJ-solutions, MEM-OBJ-pack-rules, MEM-OBJ-experiment-log, MEM-RTE-handoff-resume and MEM-RTE-experiment-digest preserve the underlying distinctions, and the finding notes identify conditional Git retention and different consumers. The partial axes and scoped notes preserve the emitted values and evidence strengths. Consumers should withhold exact per-object inventory counts, one-to-one unit comparisons and conclusions that every grouped object shares every finding; the profile supplies bounded mechanism findings, not that finer inventory.