Antinomia profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes, their findings, evidence bases, natural units, coverage assessments and comparison rationale against the handed records. I applied the reconciliation's supersessions for the inline-assumption route and seeded-evaluation claim without upgrading their evidence. I assessed the previous objection and the author's correction afresh. No frozen-source reads were needed; this verification adds no records or quotations.

Storage and representational form. File storage is supported for vault objects and backup copies; the settings backing store remains unresolved rather than inferred from the host API. The form inventory separates interpreted prose, symbolic selectors/configuration and unresolved PDF internals. Neither YAML dependency edges nor model-service configuration establish graph storage or retained parametric memory. The grouped units share their findings and coverage despite spanning several objects. See MEM-OBJ-source-hubs, MEM-OBJ-migration-backup, MEM-OBJ-plugin-settings and MEM-OBJ-note-metadata.

Lineage and write agency. Authored, imported and software-derived paths have wired witnesses, without claiming authenticated histories for existing vault contents. Human content/batch admission is distinguished from software admission of hubs, dependency unions, backups and run metadata. Model authorship does not imply automatic admission; workflow initiation does not imply per-content human approval of derived writes. The unresolved initialization units justify partial coverage. See MEM-OBJ-note-content, MEM-OBJ-source-hubs, MEM-OBJ-plugin-settings, RT-RTE-source-ingest and RT-RTE-schema-migration.

Behavioral authority. Knowledge at interpreting consumers, routing through retained metadata/configuration, modification-time ranking and dismissal-based validation/enforcement have supported wired witnesses. The exclusion criterion and its veto are separate effects of the same retained keys. No standing instruction or learning authority is inferred from IF/THEN prose or persistence alone. The recorded consumer inventory supports the axis's known assessment within the declared boundary; missing execution does not make the architectural effects unknown. The U-prefix deletion qualification prevents a universal cleanup assurance, not classification of the dependency consumer. See MEM-OBJ-note-content, MEM-BAP-dependency-display, MEM-OBJ-plugin-settings, RT-RTE-hunter-scan and RT-BAP-dismissal-filter.

Curation. Recorded replacements and lifecycle withdrawals support wired evolve/invalidate findings. Faithful reduced source claims support the expressly claimed consolidation finding, not a claim of demonstrated semantic preservation. Generated principles and assumptions remain unresolved rather than being labeled synthesis without a supported meaning relation. Merge without body copying is not treated as semantic deduplication. See MEM-RTE-note-maintenance, MEM-RTE-inline-assumptions, EPI-RTE-collapse-review, EPI-CLM-source-fidelity and RT-RTE-rule-admission.

Read-back direction and signal. The previous blocker is repaired. Requested model input assembly, navigation and restore remain pull. Host-event-triggered refresh is now separately classified as wired push to an included human consumer; its category/layer/view predicates support coarse selection. Initial view opening is not mistaken for a new request on each later event. These findings and the rationale no longer impose a later-agent-invocation requirement. Settings reload and dismissal-control consumption remain separate unresolved units, keeping both axes partial without suppressing the supported refresh findings. Exact dismissal matching selects vetoes, not delivered retained parts, so it does not warrant identifier push. See MEM-RTE-retained-inspection, RT-RTE-hunter-scan, RT-RTE-schema-migration, MEM-OBJ-plugin-settings and MEM-OBJ-hunter-feedback. The changed units, axis notes, scope and comparison rationale are consistent with this separation.

Trace learning and source. Neither axis asserts a positive chain, a local negative or inapplicability. The records establish no qualifying automatic trace-fed durable update and contain no evidenced-absence record that would license known no. Raw responses, counters and manually admitted feedback do not alone establish such a chain. The resulting not-determinable assessments preserve uncertainty rather than asserting absence. See MEM-OBJ-hunter-raw, MEM-OBJ-plugin-settings and RT-RTE-pair-dismissal.

The missing separately declared inline object remains an analyst-inventory qualification, not a missing warrant for the route's explicit retained fields and later consumers. The profile uses MEM-RTE-inline-assumptions without claiming to repair those declarations. No further material defect follows from coarse grouping where controlled findings and coverage agree. Faithfully scoped uncertainties already expressed in the profile do not require additional publication limits.

Blockers

none

Limits

none