Decapod profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I judged all ten axes against the handed reports, annotations and reconciliation. The profile's comparison rationale distinguishes accumulated memory from static instructions, external models and transient controller state. Its positive findings describe architectural paths, not observed activation or benefit. Reconciled duplicate objects and routes were resolved to their memory declarations; distinct promotion, selection, withdrawal and evaluation records remain usable independently. No source reads, new records or quotations were added.
| Axis | Judgment |
|---|---|
| storage_substrate | Supported file, repository, database and graph witnesses. The graph finding concerns retained node relationships, not complete traversal coverage. Opaque adapter encoding does not obscure its known file substrate. Untraced stores keep the axis partial. See MEM-OBJ-federation-node, MEM-OBJ-adapter-payload, MEM-OBJ-trajectory-artifact and RT-OBJ-accepted-executor. |
| representational_form | Readable prose and fixed-rule metadata are separated. Numerical verdict/aggregate fields do not establish distributed parameters. Custom payload form remains not-determinable and empty noop content is inapplicable. See MEM-OBJ-adapter-payload, MEM-OBJ-summary-entry, EPI-OBJ-eval-verdict and EPI-OBJ-eval-aggregate. |
| lineage | Authored caller text, imported originals/verdicts, trace-derived handoff/LCM content and code-compiled structures have separate warrants. Unknown initial provenance is not erased by a known later transformation. The axis is partial; its route inventory has a local omission noted below. See MEM-RTE-archive-context, MEM-RTE-lcm-summary, MEM-RTE-handoff-memory, MEM-RTE-bundle-transfer and EPI-RTE-eval-judge-import. |
| behavioral_authority | The positive forces have actual consumer witnesses: host reference and standing guidance, ordering inputs, custody/scope selection, retained admission criteria and executable vetoes, and trace-fed durable context production. Learning at an update consumer is not inferred to mean improvement or downstream instruction. Grouped findings are coarse, but their notes identify the operative inputs and effects and do not upgrade the opaque inference consumer. See MEM-RTE-aptitude-reminders, MEM-RTE-governance-reload, EPI-RTE-promotion-record, EPI-RTE-eval-promotion-gate and MEM-RTE-lcm-summary. |
| write_agency | Automatic derived admissions are supported independently of workflow initiation or semantic authorship. Generic callers and alleged approver strings leave explicit-content control unresolved rather than establishing manual agency. These cautious unresolved units do not assert absence of software admission. See MEM-RTE-handoff-memory, MEM-RTE-lcm-summary, MEM-RTE-promotion-lifecycle and EPI-RTE-eval-statistics. |
| curation_operations | LCM combination/prefix reduction supports consolidate despite fidelity limits. Preference replacement and library conflict/edit paths support evolve; retained supersession/staling supports invalidate; expiry and optional recency downweighting support afforded decay. Recording promotion assertions, index rebuilds and placeholder rules do not establish additional operations. Coverage remains partial, with the local route omission below. See MEM-RTE-lcm-summary, MEM-RTE-aptitude-reminders, MEM-RTE-promotion-lifecycle, MEM-RTE-decision-memory and EPI-RTE-knowledge-withdraw. |
| read_back_direction | Requested content returns and requested structural reload chains support pull. Automatic retention alone does not establish unsolicited delivery; the inspected assurance assembly is part of the requested assessment, not an additional requested-return push. Uninspected loaders and scheduled consumers prevent a complete pull-only conclusion. See MEM-RTE-knowledge-store, MEM-RTE-governance-reload, RT-RTE-assurance-observe and MEM-RTE-internalization-lease. |
| read_back_signal | Local pull chains warrant inapplicability, not identifier or lexical push values. The axis correctly stays uninspected because alternative direction units remain unresolved. See MEM-RTE-archive-context, MEM-RTE-aptitude-reminders and MEM-RTE-internalization-lease. |
| trace_learning | LCM interaction/tool branches and successful handoff activity have automatic durable writes and later summary/search/pending consumers. This supports local wired yes without new knowledge, model training, automatic recipient injection or improvement evidence. Mixed inputs and alternative writes remain unresolved; no blanket no is emitted. See MEM-OBJ-lcm-event, MEM-RTE-lcm-summary, MEM-RTE-handoff-memory and MEM-RTE-knowledge-store. |
| trace_source | Recorded conversational/tool-content branches and discrete handoff activity support the emitted session-logs, tool-traces and event-streams findings at architectural strength. These do not authenticate every caller input. The unresolved artifact and summary provenance stays local; curated trajectory declarations do not establish trajectories. See MEM-OBJ-lcm-event, MEM-RTE-lcm-summary, MEM-RTE-handoff-memory and MEM-OBJ-trajectory-artifact. |
The rejected RPC decision producer is not used to establish successful retention: valid library persistence and independent listing remain the witnesses in MEM-RTE-decision-memory. The afforded decay finding preserves the absence of established shipped invocation in EPI-RTE-knowledge-withdraw. Feedback formatting remains a requested non-binding placeholder, not preference adoption, in MEM-RTE-feedback-proposal. Internalization metadata and integrity consumption do not classify the opaque payload's inference effect in MEM-RTE-internalization-lease.
The natural units are often grouped rather than individually enumerated. I assessed the actual parts, mechanisms and consumer effects within those groups. This coarseness does not invalidate their shared positive witnesses or warrant complete system coverage. Unknown prompt initialization, custom payloads and named untraced alternatives remain visible. The local omissions below leave existing system unions valid; they do not establish new controlled values or require withdrawal of an emitted value. No refusal or correction argument was supplied.
Blockers
none
Limits
- The partial lineage and form inventories do not separately enumerate authored living-spec text at its later host consumer. RT-RTE-context-resolve, including its memory annotation, and RT-RTE-validate-candidate establish authored repository prose and subsequent projection while leaving initialization unresolved. The profile includes this surface in storage and authority, but its lineage grouping does not explicitly carry that known authorship path. Authored and natural-language existence findings remain supported by other included parts; withhold complete per-object lineage/form comparisons for living specs.
- The partial curation inventory does not separately classify trajectory revision: MEM-OBJ-trajectory-artifact and MEM-RTE-governance-reload retain array extension, named-check replacement, blocker clearing and active-section replacement before later assurance/validation consumption. These are an additional recorded revision path beyond the profile's preference and knowledge/federation evolution witnesses. The emitted evolve finding remains valid, but route-level comparisons of governance-memory revision are incomplete; this omission does not establish semantic criticism or improved capacity.