post-graph-rag profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

The handed memory profile is supported within its stated memory boundary. I checked all ten axes, their unit scopes, coverage assessments, controlled findings and evidence bases against the supplied runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow members. I applied the supplied reconciliation: passage prose, report prose and withdrawal use the canonical memory declarations; entity/relation containers and the community-rating part remain distinct from their broader or narrower counterparts. No source read, replacement record or new quotation was needed. The supplied profile answers file was empty.

Retained objects, encoding and origin

Storage separates graph-organized PostgreSQL payloads, database vector columns and evaluation/replay files. These are supported by MEM-OBJ-documents, MEM-OBJ-entity-metadata, MEM-OBJ-relation-metadata, MEM-OBJ-community-text, MEM-OBJ-retrieval-events, MEM-OBJ-embeddings and MEM-RTE-evaluation-memory. Graph and relational storage coexist; neither value substitutes for encoding. Grouped database units share the same substrate coverage rather than claiming that every payload has the same consumers.

Representational form separates interpreted prose, fixed-rule metadata/lexical consumption and distributed numerical representations. The separate symbolic hash alternative is supported by RT-CMP-local-embedding, not inferred from learned vectors. Evaluation text and structured fields have separately described interpretive and fixed-reader roles in EPI-OBJ-grade. The profile does not classify provider weights as accumulated memory.

Lineage preserves caller import, subsequent model/code compilation and trace extraction without treating a known embedding call as knowledge of provider training provenance. Session-derived facts and retrieval-derived access state have recorded derivation paths in MEM-RTE-evaluation-memory and RT-RTE-retention-control. Unknown custom proposal origin remains local to RT-RTE-extractor-extension. These unresolved alternatives justify partial axes rather than universal provenance findings.

Consumers, admission and curation

Behavioral-authority findings name actual retained inputs and effects. Prose supplies context; vectors, lexical relation content and report ratings affect priority; lifecycle fields supply eligibility criteria and enforced exclusions; identity/provenance fields select later operations or affected rows. The distinctions are supported by RT-RTE-question-answer, MEM-BAP-access-state, MEM-OBJ-relations, MEM-OBJ-community-metadata and EPI-RTE-supersession-write. Validation here means local eligibility, not factual certification. The profile preserves the lack of all-channel withholding.

Write agency follows admission, not the identity of the process that performs I/O. Default extraction, report admission, retention selection and evaluator serialization support automatic findings. Caller initiation does not prove per-content human approval; generic initial supply and custom admission remain unresolved. See RT-RTE-document-admission, RT-RTE-community-build, RT-RTE-retention-control and MEM-RTE-evaluation-memory.

Curation findings correspond to transformations rather than method names: extraction/report compression consolidates; alias and same-key payload merges deduplicate and revise; supersession/withdrawal invalidate retained reliance; exposure-based archiving demotes access. MEM-OBJ-entities, MEM-OBJ-community-text, EPI-RTE-relation-upsert, MEM-RTE-document-withdrawal and RT-RTE-retention-control support those mappings. Unproven semantic faithfulness does not establish synthesis. The epistemic projection concerns in EPI-RTE-community-render remain compatible with this bounded operational classification.

Later consumption and trace-fed updates

Read-back direction distinguishes requested retrieval from unsolicited supply. Query, build, retention, polling and replay fulfill requests; documented inspection remains separately afforded rather than upgraded to wired use. See RT-RTE-question-answer, RT-RTE-community-build, MEM-RTE-change-polling and MEM-RTE-corpus-inspection. Internal delivery does not add a push finding. Push signals are consequently inapplicable for those assessed chains, but the whole signal axis remains not-determinable because additional included consumers are unresolved. Pull selectors are not incorrectly emitted as push signals.

Trace learning has two supported automatic write/later-consumer chains: exposure events change durable archive state used by later seed/snapshot selectors; recorded conversational turns produce retained facts used by later benchmark questions. Their original inputs support event-streams and session-logs respectively. See MEM-OBJ-retrieval-events, RT-RTE-retention-control and MEM-RTE-evaluation-memory. Caller-triggered retention and instance-local cleanup bound activation and persistence without defeating these wired capacities. Neither capacity requires observed improvement or parameter training. Update-consumer learning authority and downstream knowledge/enforcement authority remain separate.

The partial learning inventory supports a wired system union yes, not a complete-value conclusion. No unsupported local or system-wide no is emitted. Session serialization does not add event-stream origin, and saved grades alone do not establish a qualifying update consumer: EPI-RTE-benchmark-check.

All positive findings retain implementation or explicitly afforded bases. None asserts observed operation, reliable model compliance or causal benefit. Broadly grouped units remain intelligible through their named parts and consumers; their grouping does not change a supported comparison value or conceal unresolved coverage. Custom implementation and evaluator uncertainties are already expressed in the extracted assessments, so they do not require an additional publication limit. No material unsupported value, absence, evidence strength or complete-coverage claim was found.

Blockers

none

Limits

none