oh-my-pi profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes of the memory profile, their natural units, finding support, evidence bases and inventory coverage against the handed reports and reconciliation. I assessed the previous objections and the author's answers independently. No source files were read and no new evidence or records were added. Managed-skill object citations use the canonical EPI-OBJ-managed-skill; valid local-memory, Mnemopi and decision-file containers remain alongside their parts.

  • Storage substrate: file, SQLite and process-state findings are supported by MEM-OBJ-session-journal, MEM-OBJ-stage1-output, MEM-OBJ-memory-summary, MEM-OBJ-working-memory, MEM-OBJ-mental-models and RT-RTE-task-spawn. Grouped publication findings restrict process caching to summary/lesson snapshots; they do not assign it to every generated file. Opaque backing, archive backing and alternate journal stores remain unresolved.
  • Representational form: interpreted prose, fixed metadata, generated scripts and numerical embeddings are distinguished. MEM-OBJ-memory-embeddings supports the dense numerical part independently of JSON serialization. MEM-OBJ-binary-vector, MEM-OBJ-provider-payload, MEM-OBJ-snapcompact-archive, MEM-OBJ-local-templates and MEM-OBJ-local-examples preserve unresolved encoding or content mixtures. Readable summaries do not classify opaque replay.
  • Lineage: trace extraction, rendered intermediates, acquired transcript content and explicit authoring are separated by derivation path. MEM-RTE-local-consolidation, MEM-RTE-decision-memory and MEM-RTE-autolearn-capture support the trace-derived findings. The imported project-documentation finding is explicitly attached to consolidation, not delta extraction. Initial provenance, checkpoint producers and numerical/core derivations remain unresolved rather than inheriting another path's lineage.
  • Behavioral authority: contextual advice, standing instructions, learning at update consumers and retained controls at software consumers have distinct effects. MEM-BAP-memory-guidance supports the different requested forces of local guidance and project decisions. EPI-RTE-skill-readback supports instruction-body preparation, not observed compliance. MEM-RTE-context-rebuild, MEM-RTE-backend-recall, MEM-RTE-local-consolidation and MEM-RTE-memory-edit support bounded routing, eligibility and veto effects. Numerical ranking and generated-code execution are not inferred from storage or read availability.
  • Write agency: automatic model/software admission is distinguished from conditional human approval of effective content-bearing parameters in RT-RTE-tool-dispatch. The notebook, lesson, edit and managed-skill routes do not infer human approval from a triggering sentence or session startup. Initial content, generic callers, core admissions and service/seed admissions remain unresolved. Conditional wiring is not represented as an exercised approval.
  • Curation operations: the two previous objections are repaired. In MEM-RTE-local-consolidation and MEM-OBJ-stage1-output, no-output removal supports forgetting, not history-preserving invalidation; the profile removes the latter finding and repairs the dependent unit note, axis note and rationale. The notebook, managed-file and Mnemopi edit mechanisms now have separate units. MEM-RTE-notebook-update and MEM-OBJ-context-notes support revision and empty clearing while prior journal versions survive. EPI-RTE-skill-mutation supports file revision and directory deletion without an invalidation finding. MEM-RTE-memory-edit supports eligible row revision, forgetting and retirement-based invalidation, with propagation limits kept separate. Consolidation, deduplication and capped forgetting have mechanism-specific support; no route label or requested novelty substitutes for a synthesis warrant.
  • Read-back direction: automatic reconstruction and backend instruction/recall supply are push; requested recall, artifacts, notebook and selected skill bodies are pull. MEM-RTE-context-rebuild, MEM-RTE-backend-recall, MEM-RTE-artifact-read and EPI-RTE-skill-readback support these distinctions. Requested returns are not counted as additional push operations. WF-RTE-result-delivery preserves uncertainty about later child-artifact retrieval and attained retention.
  • Read-back signal: leaf/checkpoint matching and tracked-row change notices select actual retained parts; availability, scope and budgets supply separate coarse filters. The named triggers, inputs and selected parts agree with MEM-RTE-context-rebuild, MEM-OBJ-recall-entry and MEM-RTE-backend-recall. Requested-file identifiers and discovery eligibility are not mistaken for targeted push. Relevance internals remain unresolved rather than classified from FTS or embedding storage alone.
  • Trace learning: MEM-RTE-local-consolidation, MEM-RTE-decision-memory and MEM-RTE-autolearn-capture, together with EPI-RTE-skill-mutation and EPI-RTE-skill-readback, support conditional automatic trace-to-durable-artifact-to-later-consumer chains. No improvement or execution evidence is required for those wired classifications. Incomplete checkpoint production, raw retention and opaque service/core transformations receive neither an unsupported positive nor a negative.
  • Trace source: session content supports the local and decision findings; EPI-OBJ-capture-messages and EPI-RTE-capture-turn support session and tool origins for capture. Callback triggers do not add event-stream origin, and imported project documentation remains a nontrace input. Local extraction windows and unresolved qualifying routes preserve incomplete origin coverage.

All axes retain partial coverage. Their positive findings establish local conditional mechanisms, not complete system unions, observed activation, benefit, epistemic acceptance or exercised self-improvement. Remaining uncertainty is expressed in the profile itself and does not require a separate publication limit. Differing memory and epistemic inspection scopes are compatible: inspected body preparation does not settle complete dispatch, and missing backend epistemic assessment does not negate memory wiring. The corrected curation inventory no longer associates one mechanism's history-preserving withdrawal with unrelated deletion operations.

Blockers

none

Limits

none