GMemory profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the memory profile against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow accounts, using the reconciliation to resolve duplicate rule-text and metadata records. The classifications are supported at their stated evidence strengths. No emitted value claims observed operation or causal benefit. The unresolved units keep every axis partial rather than turning a wired witness into complete system coverage.

  • Storage substrate: Task objects and Chroma access, the task-query graph and pickle, rule dictionaries and JSON, and MacNet temporal lists support the emitted substrates. Serialization is not treated as a separate file store, and no SQL implementation is inferred from Chroma. The task-query graph is distinguished from the serialized interaction payload (MEM-OBJ-mas-message, MEM-OBJ-state-chain, MEM-OBJ-task-layer, MEM-OBJ-insights-rule, MEM-OBJ-node-memory).
  • Representational form: Text interpreted by models, fixed-code graph/metadata consumers, and dense task-index vectors support the separate natural-language, symbolic and parametric findings. The encoder's own weights are not misclassified as a use-updated memory artifact (RT-CMP-embedding-func, RT-RTE-memory-delivery, MEM-OBJ-insights-metadata).
  • Lineage: Imported descriptions and observations, trace-derived task extras and rules, and code-derived access structures remain separate derivation paths. Unknown initial-store and embedding provenance are retained rather than resolved by later known transformations (MEM-OBJ-mas-message, MEM-OBJ-task-layer, MEM-OBJ-insights-rule, MEM-RTE-cluster-merge).
  • Behavioral authority: The profile distinguishes advisory context at solving consumers from learning inputs at update consumers, ranking/routing at selectors, and validation/enforcement at survival and duplicate gates. These classifications concern actual retained inputs and consequences, not semantic correctness or model compliance. Advisory rule wording alone does not establish standing instruction authority (RT-BAP-retained-guidance, RT-RTE-insight-maintenance, MEM-OBJ-insights-metadata, EPI-RTE-rule-disposition).
  • Write agency: Normal task admission, ordinary rule operations, merge replacement and temporal appends have software admission without per-content human approval. Merge is correctly a separate mechanism. Launching the workflow does not establish manual admission; initial content and external replacement remain unresolved (RT-RTE-task-retention, RT-RTE-insight-maintenance, MEM-RTE-cluster-merge, MEM-OBJ-node-memory).
  • Curation operations: EDIT supports wired evolution, and score decrements/pruning support wired decay. Model-requested extraction and merging support afforded consolidation without establishing faithful compression. Semantic novelty remains unresolved; syntax checks and duplicate rejection do not establish synthesis or deduplication of retained entries (RT-RTE-task-retention, RT-RTE-insight-maintenance, MEM-RTE-cluster-merge, EPI-RTE-rule-disposition).
  • Read-back direction: Requested task-query return is pull. Count-triggered maintenance and automatic temporal predecessor delivery establish distinct push operations. Requested prompt delivery is not counted again as push (RT-RTE-memory-delivery, RT-RTE-insight-maintenance, RT-RTE-macnet-actions).
  • Read-back signal: Count/availability and latest-position filtering support coarse selection; task similarity/clustering supports embedding selection; positive task-name membership and temporal predecessor identity support identifier selection. These findings name selected retained parts, not identifiers merely present in storage. Pull-only selection has a locally inapplicable push-signal unit, not a system-wide inapplicability claim (MEM-OBJ-task-layer, MEM-OBJ-insights-metadata, MEM-RTE-cluster-merge, MEM-OBJ-node-memory).
  • Trace learning: Automatic task-derived extras and rule updates produce durable behavior-shaping material with later consumers, supporting wired yes without requiring improved performance. Raw interaction storage alone is not the warrant. MacNet's qualifying durability remains explicitly unresolved rather than supplying an unsupported negative (RT-RTE-task-retention, MEM-OBJ-mas-message, RT-RTE-insight-maintenance, MEM-OBJ-node-memory).
  • Trace source: Linked actions, observations and outcomes support trajectories; executed environment requests and feedback support tool-traces. The rule path preserves those origins through derived inputs. Stored prompts alone do not establish session-log consumption, and imported context does not become an event stream merely through retention (RT-RTE-task-retention, MEM-OBJ-mas-message, RT-RTE-insight-maintenance).

The profile uses the canonical memory rule objects rather than their superseded epistemic duplicates. The stale memory attribution about effective reward pruning does not alter the current shared mechanism: attempted deletion leaves backing states unchanged. The profile preserves that conclusion and does not emit a pruning-derived curation finding (MEM-RTE-state-roundtrip, RT-RTE-task-retention, EPI-RTE-trajectory-cleanup).

Initial admission/provenance, opaque endpoint retention, particular generated semantics, actual activation and benefit remain bounded unknowns. Their uncertainty is already expressed in the affected values and coverage notes; it does not require an additional publication limit. The endpoint's parametric implementation alone supplies no positive memory-substrate or trace-learning classification (RT-CMP-gpt-chat).

Source-read log: none. This judgment uses only the handed records and contracts; it adds no source evidence or replacement classification.

Blockers

none

Limits

none