SAGE profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes of the memory profile, including positive values, local evidence bases, natural units and coverage assessments, against the handed records and annotations. Reconciliation establishes no supersessions. Paired functions, continuing evaluation records, expert functions, numerical access parts, corpora, parameters and optional cached responses remain distinct referents. No source reads or new evidence were needed.

Storage findings distinguish files, process dictionaries/lists, access tensors and model weights. Dense representation does not imply a vector database. Form findings distinguish executable source and structured access fields from model-interpreted source/documentation, query text and corpus prose; tensors and weights have parametric form. Some units group parts with the same supported classifications rather than enumerate each separately. The consequential recovery-inventory omission is retained below (RT-OBJ-skill-libraries, RT-OBJ-skill-library-functions, MEM-OBJ-skill-embeddings, MEM-OBJ-query-list, MEM-OBJ-query-embeddings, MEM-OBJ-expert-dataset, RT-CMP-actor-rollout, RT-CMP-sft-model).

Lineage separates extracted action source and expert messages, imported query inputs and provider envelopes, encoded vectors and optimized parameters. Known subsequent transformations do not settle original predefined-library or starting-weight provenance. The profile preserves these unresolved derivation paths rather than upgrading them from a known downstream route (MEM-OBJ-rollout-functions, MEM-OBJ-query-list, MEM-OBJ-skill-embeddings, MEM-OBJ-query-embeddings, MEM-OBJ-llm-calls, RT-RTE-policy-update, RT-RTE-sft-admission).

Authority findings distinguish interpreter instructions and model reference/guidance, retrieval ranking, identifier/checkpoint routing and retained experience at update consumers. A transient failure-marker predicate is not itself retained validation or enforcement memory. Update-consumer learning authority is distinct from the resulting code's downstream guidance. Write agency is automatic at the recorded extraction, index, corpus, cache and optimizer admissions; operator launch alone supplies no manual content decision (RT-BAP-function-execution, RT-BAP-function-guidance, RT-RTE-evaluation-loop, MEM-OBJ-query-list, MEM-RTE-response-cache, RT-RTE-policy-update).

The previous manual-write objection is repaired. The profile no longer emits manual agency for selecting an existing SFT model path. Its write-agency note and rationale now distinguish that requested read from a separately evidenced content admission. The requested-load finding remains supported, while initial-content admission stays unresolved (RT-RTE-sft-admission, RT-CMP-sft-model).

Curation retains supported consolidation of action histories and supervised messages, local same-name evolution, and configured checkpoint forgetting. Extraction defects do not establish synthesis. The previous dedup objection is also repaired: the finding has been removed, and the unit note and rationale no longer equate name collisions or first-name delivery filtering with near-duplicate retained-content removal. Local revision remains distinct from global revision of the append-only evaluation list (EPI-RTE-function-extraction, RT-OBJ-skill-library-functions, MEM-OBJ-rollout-functions, MEM-OBJ-expert-dataset, RT-RTE-policy-update).

Direction and signal findings separate automatic initialization supply and active-parameter consumption from requested cache, dataset and explicitly selected model/checkpoint loads. Paired/expert whole-library availability is coarse; default evaluation uses actual scenario-derived task-ID matching; vector and n-gram alternatives use embedding and lexical selection. Substring matching is not represented as exact equality. A filename alone is not treated as identifier targeting, nor a requested cache return as another push. Predefined loading and output persistence remain separate paths (RT-RTE-skill-install, RT-RTE-evaluation-loop, MEM-OBJ-rollout-functions, MEM-OBJ-skill-embeddings, MEM-OBJ-query-list, MEM-OBJ-query-embeddings, MEM-RTE-response-cache, RT-RTE-policy-update, RT-RTE-sft-admission).

Trace-learning positives have automatic trace-fed writes and later consumers: extracted reusable functions and RL/SFT parameters. They require neither improved competence nor observed invocation. Trace-source findings retain conversational messages, execution feedback and linked task experience without manufacturing event-stream provenance from JSON envelopes. The grouped paired-extraction/RL source unit does not establish identical input windows for extraction and optimization. The normal evaluation and expert gates also remain distinct (RT-RTE-skill-install, RT-RTE-paired-rollout, RT-RTE-policy-update, RT-RTE-expert-admission, MEM-OBJ-expert-dataset, WF-RTE-failed-code-filter).

All positive bases remain wired rather than observed or causal. The rationale preserves the shipped two-node launcher's loader mismatch: internal paired reuse and policy-update capacities are not claims of successful launch-to-learning progression. The separately launched SFT path and operator-selected later use likewise do not demonstrate an automatically successful pipeline (RT-RTE-paired-rollout, RT-RTE-policy-update, RT-RTE-sft-admission).

Every axis remains partial. Included opaque provider/backend alternatives and unresolved initial preparation retain uncertainty rather than inheriting inspected positives or implying absence. These faithfully scoped uncertainties are not additional defects. The static API-prediction/retry context is not silently counted as acquired long-term memory (RT-CMP-language-model, RT-RTE-policy-update, MEM-RTE-api-context, EPI-RTE-code-retrial). Neither predecessor objection remains a blocker after checking the changed findings and dependent rationale. No additional unsupported system-level comparison value was established.

Blockers

none

Limits

• The profile includes recovery state but its storage, form and lineage inventories do not separately enumerate all non-parameter recovery parts. RT-RTE-policy-update, including its memory annotation, covers the latest-iteration tracker and saved dataloader state alongside actor/optional critic checkpoints. Resume routing is represented, and the rationale now explicitly acknowledges incomplete per-part classification. The affected axes remain partial and their positive substrate/form findings remain supported. Readers should withhold complete per-part recovery-inventory comparisons; this omission does not establish absent recovery state or invalidate the emitted substrate/form union.