llm-wiki-newsroom memory profile
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-memory-profile.md
Comparison rationale
Boundary and evidence strength
The inventory follows the accepted memory objects and routes, not the enclosing host's whole storage. A JSON graph is a symbolic file artifact, not evidence of a graph database. Numeric partition IDs and contradiction scores are localized fields, not distributed parameters. The opaque QMD mode labels cannot classify a retained embedding payload. See MEM-OBJ-graph, MEM-RTE-cluster-rebuild, EPI-OBJ-contradiction-db and RT-CMP-qmd.
The accepted reconciliation establishes no supersessions. Broader memory containers and narrower epistemic objects retain different extents; classifications do not treat their overlap as independent corroboration. Each axis retains unresolved local initialization, host/provider or semantic-maintenance alternatives. Consequently no axis claims complete boundary coverage. A wired copy/selector is not evidence that the model followed its authoring/review instructions. Experiment artifacts support only their sampled retained fields and judgments, not observed production updates. See EPI-RTE-judge-measurement.
Admission and curation
Software rebuilds automatically admit generated values once invoked. Model-generated ordinary page content is likewise not individually approved merely because a human initiated ingest. Optional synthesis save and guideline adoption have explicit human decisions, and therefore separate manual mechanisms. Generic ledger callers and unavailable initial notes/labels do not resolve human control. See RT-RTE-source-ingest, RT-RTE-wiki-query, RT-RTE-guideline-change and MEM-OBJ-defect-log.
A source reflection requests consolidation of imported claims. Regrounding requests evolution. Graph repeated-target collapse implements local deduplication; URL-first duplicate detection alone does not. Cross-source narrative names do not establish synthesis in the controlled sense of a new claim absent from inputs: semantic relation remains indeterminate. Withdrawal triage is not observed deletion or global forgetting. See MEM-OBJ-source, MEM-OBJ-graph, EPI-RTE-narrative-authoring and MEM-RTE-hub-withdrawal.
Consumers and selection
Requested wiki reads and miner reports are pull. Automatic injection of prior partition into clustering is a separate push operation, with identity matching distinct from coarse branch gating. Briefing distribution is push relative to its recipient even though the sender initiates the workflow; explicit file identity and latest-week selection remain separate mechanisms. Role guidance supplied by role identity is only a claimed host route. Uploaded export context has no inspected hosted selection mechanism. Current broken-link feedback is not counted as accumulated memory solely because it enters context. See MEM-RTE-cluster-rebuild, MEM-RTE-briefing-read, RT-BAP-role-guidance, RT-RTE-wiki-export and RT-BAP-hook-feedback.
Trace-fed revision limits
Experience has learning authority at a consumer proposing durable rule edits; adopted text has downstream instruction authority. Separately, the feedback checkpoint automatically retains reaction-derived counts/history and review windows for later mining selection. That durable routing artifact is behavior-shaping memory, even though it is not final guidance. It supports wired trace-learning yes and session-logs for its original conversational input. Explicit checkpoint invocation does not make content admission manual. Operator-mediated guidance adoption, mixed failure-review admission and opaque host alternatives remain separate unresolved units. Thus both trace axes have partial coverage with supported positives; no analyst declares an evidenced-absence record, so neither local nor system-wide trace-learning no is asserted. See MEM-RTE-feedback-review, MEM-RTE-failure-review, MEM-OBJ-review-watermarks, MEM-OBJ-local-memory and RT-RTE-guideline-change.
Source-read log
No frozen source files were read for this profile. The supplied accepted records carry its warrants; no new records, quotations, execution evidence or verification findings were added.