MiroShark profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes in the profile against the accepted records, their natural classification units, evidence bases and coverage assessments. I applied reconciliation's supersessions for relation, belief and community objects and for round-compaction, belief-feedback and community-generation routes. Contained round prose remains distinct from the whole resident store. No additional source reads were needed. This judgment concerns meaning and support, not a repetition of deterministic citation or quotation checks.

Storage findings distinguish resident objects, persistent files, graph/vector access and platform SQLite state. Form findings distinguish readable prose, fixed-rule symbolic controls and dense distributed representations. Inference weights are not classified as accumulated memory merely because they are loaded. Lineage findings separate imported text, trace-derived experience and other computational derivations; unresolved initialization and remote provenance remain unresolved. The grouped units are coarse, but their supported local findings do not imply a complete system inventory. See MEM-OBJ-relation, MEM-OBJ-belief-state, MEM-OBJ-community, MEM-RTE-graph-ingestion, RT-RTE-prepare-population and EPI-RTE-web-research.

Behavioral authority remains tied to actual consumers: experience feeds context/stance updates, derived history supplies later model context and guidance, retained text/vectors influence ranking, and temporal/category controls enforce only covered edge filters. Configuration and checkpoint matching supply routing; retained appraisal labels influence gallery inclusion and downstream categories. Neither universal withdrawal nor factual acceptance follows. Write agency distinguishes automatic derived-content admission from unresolved human control of caller initialization and appraisal replacement. A workflow start or authenticated caller identity does not establish per-content human approval. See MEM-RTE-belief-feedback, MEM-RTE-graph-retrieval, EPI-RTE-edge-invalidation, RT-OBJ-simulation-config, EPI-RTE-outcome-annotation and WF-RTE-report-delivery.

Curation has implemented witnesses for round consolidation, resident-detail decay, cross-platform tail eviction, stance evolution, canonical entity deduplication and current-edge invalidation. Community compression and replacement support consolidation and evolution without establishing fidelity, atomicity or novel-claim synthesis. Exact-replay skipping during contradiction checks does not establish relation deduplication. See MEM-RTE-round-history, MEM-OBJ-cross-platform-log, EPI-RTE-entity-resolution, MEM-RTE-graph-ingestion and MEM-RTE-community-rebuild.

I reassessed the predecessor's MCP objection and the supplied correction answer. The current profile classifies pending external-tool result delivery as pull and its push signal as inapplicable, bounded to that requested-result chain. Its rationale now makes the same distinction. RT-RTE-agent-mcp establishes model-authored tool requests, buffered results and delivery to the requesting agent on later activation; delayed fulfillment and recipient matching do not establish a separate unsolicited selector. The correction therefore resolves both dependent findings and the rationale. Independent round scheduling still supports push, coarse history selection and agent/platform identifier selection through MEM-RTE-round-history, MEM-RTE-belief-feedback and MEM-OBJ-cross-platform-log. Requested graph ranking remains pull rather than an inferred embedding push signal, as supported by MEM-RTE-graph-retrieval.

Trace learning has separate wired witnesses for continuation summaries, checkpointed stance, retained cross-platform digests and optional activity-derived graph memory. Later-invocation consumption establishes the relevant architectural paths without requiring parameter training, cross-run persistence or measured improvement. Original platform action requests/results support tool-trace origins; recommendation exposure and engagement support event-stream origins at belief updates. Full analyzer provenance remains explicitly unresolved. Saved trajectory outputs are not thereby trajectory learning inputs, and raw report-trace retention is not automatically a learning write. See MEM-RTE-round-history, MEM-RTE-belief-feedback, MEM-OBJ-cross-platform-log, MEM-RTE-graph-ingestion and MEM-OBJ-reasoning-trace.

All axes retain partial inventory coverage. Named market/media, dedicated-driver, auxiliary-consumer and opaque host/provider alternatives are not converted into absence or complete coverage by a known local witness. The profile's uncertainty already bounds those comparisons; it is not an additional publication limit. No emitted finding asserts observed operation, causal benefit, universal source trust or improved future capacity. I found no remaining material classification defect.

Blockers

none

Limits

none