Origin profile verification
Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md
Verification
I checked all ten axes, their positive findings and evidence bases, local coverage assessments, natural units and unresolved alternatives against the supplied reports and profile type. The supplied reconciliation establishes no supersession; containers and their distinct parts remain usable. No target-source reads or execution were performed. The profile rationale and frontmatter were judged together; explanatory prose cannot strengthen a value beyond its cited records.
| Axis | Judgment |
|---|---|
| storage_substrate | Relational/libSQL carriers, retained vectors and filesystem projections/overrides support the corresponding findings. Cached lint reports now have no positive substrate finding and remain not-determinable. The partial inventory preserves unresolved carriers rather than inferring storage from a cache or feature name. |
| representational_form | Readable prose, rule-consumed identities/state and distributed dense representations support natural-language, symbolic and parametric findings respectively. Parametric does not imply trained weights. The revision/repair unit preserves incomplete payload coverage rather than treating a readable proposal as the whole payload. |
| lineage | Authored affordances, inspected imports, instructed session extraction and wired derivations retain their local warrants. Known subsequent derivation does not resolve initial authors or historical embedding provenance. The claim/support unit is bounded to its local derivation, not complete source ancestry. |
| behavioral_authority | Knowledge at recall/compilation, instructions at Brief/override consumers, ranking inputs, admission/exposure controls and durable work-routing state have recorded consumers and effects. Learning authority is separately assigned to trace-fed update consumers, not inferred from downstream knowledge authority or measured improvement. |
| write_agency | Software admission is distinguished from input authorship and workflow initiation. Human editing and requested review decisions remain afforded/claimed alternatives; cutover's explicit plan confirmation supports its wired manual finding. Unauthenticated generic callers remain unresolved. |
| curation_operations | Rollup/recap reduction, entry revision, support/eligibility withdrawal, confidence decay and pending-to-active confirmation support the emitted operations. Neither duplicate-input checks nor an unimplemented dedup action supports retained-memory deduplication. Unknown generated semantic relations do not establish synthesis. |
| read_back_direction | Requested recall and Brief reload are pull. Automatic selectors supplying retained content to later inference tasks support background push without implying foreground knowledge injection. Explicit artifact requests are distinct from automatic truth-worker supply. |
| read_back_signal | Eligibility/temporal filters support coarse selection; actual page-source identity lookup supports identifier selection. Unknown linked-evidence ranking does not establish an inferred relevance signal. Requested recall ranking is not recast as push selection. |
| trace_learning | Instructed session handoff and the recorded conversational enrichment branch support their separate afforded/wired positive findings. Mixed recap/rollup ancestry stays partial. Current-case evaluator compression has no established durable reload and is not a system-wide negative. |
| trace_source | Recorded conversation supports session-logs on the named qualifying branches. Git evidence does not by itself establish tool-traces or trajectories; refinery labels and serialization do not establish event-streams. Mixed origins remain partial. |
The principal distinctions are supported by MEM-OBJ-memories, MEM-OBJ-episode-rows, MEM-OBJ-fact-children, MEM-RTE-brief-handoff, MEM-RTE-enrichment-slices, MEM-RTE-burst-recaps and MEM-RTE-summary-rollup. Their implementation findings do not establish observed activation or benefit.
The correction answer is supported by the current profile. Its Cached lint reports unit now says not-determinable with no findings, and both the storage-axis note and rationale retain the missing carrier fact. EPI-OBJ-lint-report and EPI-RTE-lint-assessment establish exact-scope caching and later planning consumption, not process-memory storage. The unsupported in-memory finding is no longer emitted. The earlier blocker therefore does not recur.
I also checked that page support is not conflated with synthesis admission. RT-RTE-page-refresh retains branch-specific fencing and lexical admission. EPI-RTE-support-publish, EPI-RTE-support-withdrawal and EPI-RTE-truth-exposure establish separate retained authority and conditional exposure, including generation-zero pass-through and review/grant exceptions. WF-RTE-rebuild-request does not turn the receipt into page-body delivery or user confirmation into approval of unseen generated prose.
All axes are partial. The explicitly retained graph/community/vocabulary, import, repair, projection and provenance alternatives support that coverage assessment; no bounded absence or system-complete negative is emitted. Faithfully scoped uncertainties need no additional limit. Coarse grouping leaves the supported positive unions intact, but constrains mechanism-level comparisons as stated below.
Blockers
none
Limits
- Several profile units group distinct operative parts or mechanisms: the revision-card/lint/repair form unit combines prose and symbolic payloads, while the claim/support versus diagnostic/repair read-back unit combines automatic judge supply and requested artifact consumption. MEM-OBJ-revision-cards, EPI-OBJ-lint-report, EPI-OBJ-repair-manifest, EPI-RTE-claim-judgment and EPI-RTE-repair-admission distinguish those parts and consumers. The profile's finding notes identify the positive witnesses and these grouped units already say partial, so the existence findings remain supported. Consumers should withhold per-payload form completeness and one-to-one mechanism-level direction comparisons; the grouped units are not independent, fully resolved natural units.