LACP profile verification

Type: agentic-system-analyses/types/agentic-system-verification.md

Verification

I checked all ten axes, their findings, evidence bases, natural units and inventory assessments in the profile against the handed runtime, memory, epistemic and workflow members. Reconciliation's self-model identity amendment is respected: the profile uses MEM-OBJ-self-model, while EPI-RTE-self-model-update remains a distinct route. Narrative and epoch parts remain separate; neither inherits the other's writer or startup consumer.

  • Storage and form: File persistence, native RAM, materialized graph links, vector access structures and retained repository changes have supporting records. Graph/vector findings do not claim dedicated databases. Text, symbolic envelopes and dense representations have separate consumption units; embedding form does not imply weight training. See MEM-OBJ-research-memory, MEM-OBJ-hybrid-index and RT-OBJ-messages. Some inventory units group several file-backed stages, but the cited parts share the emitted substrate findings; this does not create an unsupported system-complete assertion.
  • Lineage: Authored, trace-extracted, imported and compiled paths are supported locally. Initial narrative, arbitrary caller content and exact embedding provenance remain unresolved rather than inheriting a neighboring path's classification. A local omission in imported tool-result coverage is retained below.
  • Authority: The profile distinguishes interpreted recovery/context from standing self-model guidance, ranking inputs from delivered reference text, and retained controls from downstream host enforcement. Blocked-ID admission vetoes support validation and enforcement; workflow tokens support transition control, not task correctness. See MEM-RTE-trace-research, MEM-RTE-session-memory, RT-RTE-workflow-advance and RT-RTE-learning-promotion. Executable source authority remains unresolved at the controlled-effect level rather than being indiscriminately labeled enforcement.
  • Write agency: Software/model selection supports automatic admission on the named paths. Apply flags, starting experiments, actor strings and manual-gate labels do not establish per-content human decisions. Initial/replacement and generic-caller mechanisms retain uncertainty. See MEM-RTE-keyed-memory, MEM-RTE-daily-promotion and MEM-OBJ-agent-narrative.
  • Curation: Local transformations support the seven emitted values. Compression/copying remains consolidation; the independently documented non-entailed SMS assertions support synthesis. Rename and index rebuild are not assigned semantic curation values. Local resolution, rollback, archival and truncation are not presented as universal withdrawal. The unresolved semantic-helper and nonpersistent supersedes branches remain qualified. See EPI-RTE-self-model-update, EPI-RTE-memory-promotions and MEM-RTE-memory-maintenance.
  • Read-back direction and signal: Requested reads and evaluator reloads are pull; automatic host-event context supply is push. The actual cwd match supports identifier selection, while age, confidence, significance, slices and budget support coarse selection. Requested hybrid ranking does not become a push signal. Read-only incoming consumption is preserved for EPI-RTE-retrieval-ranking and EPI-RTE-learning-metrics.
  • Trace learning and source: Automatic durable recovery, episode, self-model and research/daily transformations have the recorded later consumers needed for wired positives. No observed improvement is inferred. Conversational inputs and recorded execution feedback support session-log and tool-trace sources; hook transport does not itself supply event-stream origin. Narrative, raw conversation retention, generic event admission and opaque external checkpoints remain unresolved. See MEM-RTE-session-memory, MEM-RTE-trace-research and MEM-RTE-daily-promotion.

Every axis remains partial. Included offline and external alternatives are retained explicitly; no absence or complete-value union is asserted. The handed members supply static implementation, not execution or causal experiments, so the wired findings do not establish activation or benefit. No source files were read, no new records or quotations were produced, and no target execution occurred. The empty profile answers supply no predecessor objection to resolve.

Blockers

none

Limits

  • The lineage unit “Native imported tool-result provenance” in the profile preserves unknown original derivation but emits no finding for the established import step. RT-RTE-native-turn records executor results entering provider messages, and the epistemic assessment explicitly classifies imported user/tool text as acquisition with source warrant unknown. Unknown upstream derivation does not settle the import path negatively. Withhold complete route-level lineage comparisons for native tool results. This omission is publishable because the lineage axis and this unit already express uncertainty, and imported lineage remains supported elsewhere in the profile; it does not invalidate the emitted system union or imply absence.